What Everyone Missed On The Pineapple Question By Hollander

Good Essays
Change is needed in the Education System
Why does one read books? Some people read in order to get rid of the stress and the tension from their life. On the other hand, some people read for fun, but at the end, both of them get a valuable knowledge that can be used to resolve problems. However, education system nowadays have made learning meaningless. Students are reading the books without emotions. What is the use of such reading where student don’t feel the meaning of the word and just read it because they are being tested on it. In her piece, “Learning without Feeling”, Hollander castigates the Current Common Core State Standards which are de-emphasizing literature in the English classroom. In his piece, “What Everyone Missed on the Pineapple
…show more content…
Hollander argues that current educational policy is diminishing the purpose of the reading. It is stated in the quotation, “High-stakes standardized tests, in combination with the skills-based orientation of the common core state standards, are de-emphasizing literature in the English classroom.” (Hollander 2). Hollander criticizes the standardized test and says that student should not be tested on the random text, but “test need to be based on the books students read in school.” (Hollander 3). Hollander’s educational philosophy is truly valid. Students should read the book and feel it in order to understand it and create a meaning out of it which they could apply to their real life. The books are of no use if students can’t find a meaning in it. Rotherham is supporting Hollander’s argument by criticizing standardize tests, which decides the student’s future, for including laughable passage which doesn’t make any sense. Likewise Hollander, Rotherham doesn’t want to drop the standardized test, but is in favor of the tests. Rotherham states in the quotation, “The solution is not to dump standardized testing… but… to include better quality passages for students to read.” (Rotherham 3). Rotherham main target is not the test, but the testing agency who isn’t …show more content…
Hollander argues that school should give more importance selecting text that students should read in school. She argues that Current Common Core State standards focuses more on the skill student needs to learn to read and write rather than what they should read. Selecting the text according to student preference is more crucial than those skill, because those skills are of no use if the text the students read doesn’t interest them. The students should read the literature that would keep them engage with reading or piece that they would read with seriousness. Hollander states this in a quotation, “I like it when my students cry, when they read with solemnity and purpose, when the project of making meaning becomes personal.” (Hollander 1). This is completely true one should read with a ambition then and only then he/she could understand the real meaning of text. Text that student read in school should help them in future otherwise there is no purpose of such a worthless reading which doesn’t help students in any way? Rich has the same perspective as Hollander. She also opposes the university curriculum because it doesn’t include women 's courses. This is mentioned in the quotation, “One of the devastating weakness of university learning …

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Chris Crutcher argues in his article, “How They Do It”, that school systems should not become easily persuaded by the parents’ complaints to censor books that should be a part of the curriculum that their children benefit from due to the fact that the students can relate, learn, and build off of the books that are censored. Crutcher builds his argument throughout his article by including the use of personal anecdotes, pathos, and repetition. Due to the fact that Crutcher includes the use of personal anecdotes, he supports his argument. He builds his argument with the use of personal stories in hope to engage the readers. Crutcher describes an experience where one of his books, Whale Talk, was added as an all-school read for a school in Michigan.…

    • 1165 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When students take a standardized test, they are discouraged to come up with a creative answer to a question. Instead, students choose what’s on the paper, which is not original. Like Robinson said, education is just training students to get accepted to universities, not to be creative. In conclusion, I feel a student’s creativity shouldn’t be frowned upon in school. There are many different ways children can learn in school, and that needs to be addressed.…

    • 730 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Parents, schools, and teachers have the responsibility to teach their children from what is morally right and wrong. Though some parents or schools banned books to prevent negative influences on their child. This issue has impacted students that they won’t be able to read great books and learn about realistic issues that happens. They won’t be able to create an ideal thinking of their own and creativity. Having literature is part of a growing children 's minds and to explore.…

    • 1042 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Mark Edmundson's Analysis

    • 1344 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Using the formalist school of criticism, he is trying to denounce the importance of intertextual school of criticism. He does not want people to criticize reading, but it is still a part of the education system, and that it would be extremely hard to change. Teaching to add a critical lens when reading is essential in schools. The teachers influence on a young student’s growth is key, because they are now able to share different perspectives based on the critical lens concept they are…

    • 1344 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Francine Prose Analysis

    • 360 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The characters are simply too black and white, and students have a harder time identifying with characters that do not seem human. Prose wants the reader to be informed of these injustices against literature, and to realize, whatever age they are, that reading is worth another chance; there really are some masterpieces out there, and they don’t have to be high school favorites. The reader could be any age, however, Prose is focusing on a specific group in her essay, English fanatics. She mentions so many books that English fanatics would know, and she is focused on changing English fanatics’ (and teachers’) minds about their curriculum. Prose is frustrated that this ignorance has gone so far.…

    • 360 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The main conclusion from this paper is that the teachers should base their decision if to use L1 in class or not according the students ' needs from academic and emotionally aspects. Therefore, I support the approach of using L1 limited and controlled manner in L2/FL class. The idea of course is not to teach in the mother tongue, but use it as a tool to help students overcome the lack of understanding or push their confident. our job as teachers is to diagnose what levels and topics to use L1 and when to start reducing this use and give the second language students to deal with the target language even if it difficult for them. It is ok to transfer the students the message that they need to make effort and discover the language, and the teacher use L1 to help them, but defiantly not be handed the language on a silver platter (Wharton, 2007).…

    • 1477 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In The Lost Tools of Learning, Dorothy Sayers, introduced a new idea about how we go about education. Miss Sayers thinks we need to change how we educate our people by “turning back the wheel of progress”, to the end of the Middle Ages (p. 1). She suggests that we keep our children in school longer, and teach them to teach themselves. She says this because she believes that our current educational system only teaches kids to do things like read, but not fully understand what they are being taught. This leaves the children vulnerable to the written word because they can only read it, but not be able to tell if it is true or not.…

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    He also states that, “This is unfortunate in the light that teaching materials are supposed to prepare students for the challenges of future society” (39). Motschenbacher’s point is that, unluckily all the teaching subjects are to get students ready for their future problems. I agree with him in this statement, because it is true, but they don’t have a right to teach students personal information about other people. School is to prepare for college and to get a good job, I think most of us could be in charge of ourselves of how to treat other people. One problem that I see is that teachers talk about students should not bully other people, but yet there’s still a lot of bulling going on, and that’s because not everyone wants to understand what they have been…

    • 1508 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Feeling that their opinion is important can help students gain confidence in their feedback on literary works. Therefore, if students grow up disliking books, educators need to do something to fix it. Professors and teachers should educate their students on reading and thinking like an intellectual. Teachers should be more patient with students who have not yet…

    • 1046 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Kumar (2006) wrote that student will give up when they have no idea how to solve their homework. This is indirectly can be related on how learners will give up when they are lost and low motivated to study more. 3.0 Conclusion In a nutshell, teaching study skills is as vital as teaching subject for the students. Students with different ability will be able to catch up, being independent in part time study and having positive emotions are among the reasons on how having study skills can affect our study outcomes. It should be taken seriously and be implemented in the future for better learning…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays

Related Topics