What Columbus Day Really Means

Improved Essays
A main point brought up to defend Columbus day is that it instills a sense of national pride. This is true but as historian William Connell brings up in his article “What Columbus Day Really Means”, Columbus Day was originally created to honor the Native Americans and immigrants. It was meant to be about all the other American history before “discovery” by the Europeans. It seems that today the focus has shifted away from that and Columbus Day is more about Columbus as an individual and his accomplishments. In order to rework this holiday into what it originally was, it is best to take advice Wilma Mankiller and “make sure that Americans have some sort of historical and cultural context for understanding our [Native Americas’] contemporary

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Did you know Columbus Day is a lie? If you don’t know who Columbus is, he was a man who was claimed to discover America. Many think that Columbus found the New World looking for new undiscovered land but he was in fact trying to find gold and an all-water route to Asia as well as Queen Isabella’s mission for spreading Christianity to Asia. Columbus Day shouldn’t be celebrated because he was not actually the person to discover the Americas and Columbus thought he landed in Asia. First, Columbus Day shouldn’t be celebrated because Columbus thought he landed in India and didn’t think he discovered new territory.…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the most significant cons of Columbus Day is celebrating a holiday dedicated to a man who took over people’s land and killed them. Columbus Day is bad because Christopher Columbus wasn’t even the man who found America first. The Native Americans were the first to be there. He took over the land that the Native Americans had first, took them and kept them as slaves. He also killed them and only went on the journey for Gold, God and fame in the first place.…

    • 612 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In school, children are taught about the great adventurer Christopher Columbus and how he discovered the New World. People learned to lionize him as the hero who discovered the country of America, but what’s never mentioned is that Christopher Columbus is not what Americans are lead to believe. The facts that are missing from history books is that he was a slave owner, a murderer, cruel, and greedy. If he possessed all of these terrible traits, then why is there a day dedicated to him? No good person would celebrate Hitler, so why should Christopher Columbus be celebrated?…

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Columbus Day Dbq

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages

    However, what these people fail to realise is that he may have had an impact on where people sailed in the fifteen hundreds, he was about 500 years late to being the first sailor to come across it, not even taking into consideration the “some 145 million people” who already inhabited the hemisphere in 1492 (Document B). Columbus's influence on future sea voyages may have been great, but it merely led more explorers to conquer lands of Natives and then enslaving them, showing that any impact he had was certainly not positive. Another argument which some use to support the continuation of Columbus Day is that “it is necessary to pay a price for progress,” and that just like “Hiroshima and Vietnam,” we must do anything for the preservation and expansion of Western society and ideology (Document H). This argument is misguided as the slaughter of thousands of innocent Natives through slavery and barbaric ruling cannot be compared to dropping a bomb which will end a war, that would have kill millions of soldiers. It also does not compared to a war launched in order to protect the freedom of other people from the oppression communism.…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Have you ever met someone that looked nice but once you got to know them they was totally different? Sometimes people shouldn’t trust one source. The textbook only shows one side of the whole story. Columbus is not who you think he is, I think Columbus day should be changed. We should still celebrate but something has to change about.…

    • 122 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It's that time of year again; pumpkin spice lattes, Halloween decorations, and the national recognition of a man responsible for mass murder, pillaging, and enslavement. It's no secret that Christopher Columbus was a horrible man, or that he didn't even "discover the new world", yet every year on October 12, he is recognized for his "accomplishment". It seems as though more and more people are unwilling to celebrate Columbus, even going so far as to put an axe in the head of his statue. While there has been opposition of Columbus Day for many years, there is only a handful of cities that refuse to recognize it.…

    • 212 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Celebrating Columbus Day: Should We? The issue of whether the United States should continue to celebrate Columbus Day or not has been a topic of interest for quite some time. To some people Columbus Day is a ridiculous day on which we glorify genocide of the Arawak Indians while to others it is considered a day of great importance and a celebration of an honorable man in history. Columbus Day is actually the latter description, but to prove this an agreeable definition is needed. What exactly is an “honorable man”?…

    • 444 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Columbus Day is an unnecessary holiday that, for some reason, we still honor today. The holiday is also an affront to the indigenous population. The false sense of patriotism is wrong to memorialize. The whole day is based off of a fabrication of the true events. When children are in elementary school, they are taught that Christopher Columbus was a hero, to shield the truth.…

    • 166 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We shouldn't celebrate Columbus Day. Not just because he was a bad person. Yes, it is because spread so much disease, and I really don’t want to be celebrating someone who committed near genocide. But mainly, I don’t want to have a day where the Native Americans in our country feel hurt and betrayed as we celebrate the man who killed so many of their ancestors. The majority of people in America aren't Native American.…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Columbus Day is a well known holiday because it was considered the discovery of the Americas and the exploration of new world, It also help develop the world the way the today. Under all of that joy and happiness is a cruel reality of pain and suffering under the Spanish. America should not memorialize Columbus Day because he did not discover the Americas, and his legacy was all about death and destruction for the people that were there already. Columbus did not accomplish anything he only found land that was discovered already. In source 1 Michael S. Berliner states that columbus did not discover America because people lived there for thousands of years.…

    • 241 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although Columbus Day is a national holiday honoring a famous historic figure, many people take it as an opportunity to hang out with friends, finish homework, or even catch up on sleep. Columbus was known for many brutal attacks and events in history such as multiple rapes, enslaved people, and deaths. It is also well-thought that Columbus was the first one to discover the Americas , where many people don't know that the native Americans where the first to arrive in America. Instead of rewarding Columbus for all of these brutal and terrifying actions, we should abolish Columbus Day because of all of Columbus's lies and mislead ideas. When Columbus came to the Americas, in addition to bringing multiple slaves, he also disrupted their lifestyles.…

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    They wanted a male, Catholic role model their kids could look up to, so they pressured Roosevelt into making it a federal holiday” (Inman). Making Christopher Columbus a role model for children, like you fifth graders, was a bad idea because he made bad decisions that affected many people. Textbooks have lied and said that Columbus was a brave and courageous man, but today, the truth has come out. What I want you to take away from this lesson is that the story of Christopher Columbus was changed so that people see him as a brave explorer and someone children can look up to.…

    • 1122 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, from a certain point of view, the benefits of Columbus might overshadow the negatives. However, that point of view constitutes a holiday that frequently ignores the negatives, devaluing Native American societies. Another dispute is that without abolishing Columbus Day completely, there is no way to utterly eliminate the Eurocentric ideal of his voyages that is celebrated annually. However, rather than wholly eliminate one side, the holiday should celebrate the connection of the Old and New Worlds. Preservation of the holiday allows for the appreciation of both European and Native American cultures before and after…

    • 832 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The only piece of history in his favor is the fact that he accidentally discovered America, which could be disproved in the next few years considering all of the extensive research being conducted to find another discoverer of America. His great accomplishment was the destruction of an entire population. How is that heroic? So the next time Columbus Day is celebrated, consider yourself educated and spread the word on how Christopher Columbus was everything but a hero. This will in hope eventually bring an end to the celebration of a man who is quite contradictory to what America stands…

    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thesis: Christopher Columbus was a man responsible for the decimation of three major civilizations, as well as the ultimate genocide of the indigenous peoples as a whole, one of the largest in human history. Columbus alone committed an array of horrific acts, using the Indians as sex slaves and extorting them for labor, stealing their land and goods, and hunting them for sport and dog food. His choices and treatment influenced how other would later view and deal with the Indians, eventually leading to their near extinction. Most of us know very little about the people who roamed our lands before we “discovered them”, and instead praise one man’s inaccurate claims. and that is why we should replace Columbus Day, which credits a man for deeds…

    • 1500 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays