Christian And Muslim Perspectives: The Crusades

Superior Essays
The Crusades was a gory period in history where the Christians and Muslims had their own differences, which brought them into conflict and leading to a couple million deaths. Both sides had their own perspectives that the other would not agree on. I will be explaining the Western and Eastern Christian and Muslim’s perspectives and how it brought them to war. First I will be going over a summary of this time period so one can feel empathy and understand why things happened the way they did. Pope Urban II launched the first crusade in 1095. He wanted to pilgrimage to the East with armed pilgrims and knights. He told everyone that Jesus was the leader and not to fight with fellow Christians, but unite and push Muslim territory back (Historical …show more content…
Greek Historian Niketas Choniatēs had firsthand experience to the religious zeal and prejudice of the Roman Empire (O City Pg. 224). The crusaders broke through the city’s walls and killed every age and sex by sword while setting the city on fire (O City Pg. 225). Niketas stated, “how horrible it was to see the divine body and blood of Christ poured out and thrown to the ground.” He went on to describe the destruction of the religious property at Hagia Sophia, which underlines the crusaders incentive, which is the difference in religion (O City Pg. 226). The barbarians would not listen to anything that anyone would have to say. If someone spoke freely they were rebuked and would have had a sword drawn onto them or having a small difference in opinion (O City Pg. 227). Niketa’s experience shows how brutal and wicked these “religious” people were. They killed anyone impetuously regardless of sex or age and destroyed everything that they came across only because small differences in religion? The Byzantines looked at these crusaders as savages and barbarians and were very furious about their actions wanting to seek …show more content…
The Western Christians believed in fighting and conquering Jerusalem for God. The Eastern Christians believed that they were barbaric and wicked for killing without thought over small differences in religion. The Muslims believed that they were being treated unfair because of the disrespect of the invasion of their own territory. Muslims believed that they were more passionate about God than any other religion. They did not want Christians teaching the book of Quran to their children because they would misinterpret it. All three of these types of people were all stereotypical and ethnocentric. They did not fully understand the other religion and believed that their religion is the best religion causing millions of deaths between the 11th and 16th

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The Crusades that took place in the medieval period between 1096 and 1291 were a series of political and religious wars fought by European countries in order to gain control of the Holy Land. The first call for a crusade was made by Pope Urban II in order to send aid to the Christian Byzantine Empire, which found itself under attack during this period from Muslim Turks. This first crusade lasted from 1096-1102, with the Christian knights taking control of Jerusalem in 1099. In response to the Christian invasions and their occupation of the Holy City, the Muslim’s retaliated with substantial force, which led to continuous subsequent crusades to maintain control of the Holy land. However in 1291 at the end of the final crusade the Muslims regained control of Jerusalem and the surrounding costal areas, which remained under Islamic control until the twentieth century. Due to the vast and all encompassing nature of the crusades, it is appropriate to conclude that they affected all levels of English society, from culture and politics, to technology, trade and economics; no one was exempt from being effected…

    • 1969 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The great Crusade started in the second half of the 11th Century after Pope Urban II appealed to followers to reconquer the Holy Land from Muslims. Most Turks had converted to Islam, which was a concern for Alexios who was the Byzantine emperor of the Middle East region. The first war was to retake the Holy Land from Muslims, but it was realized that the Crusaders (or the Franj as referred by Muslims) had other intentions of conquering the territory of the Muslims. The book “Crusades Through Arab Eyes” tries to portray a different vantage point from an Arab-Muslim perspective. The author indicates how dissimilar the commonly written books about the Crusade war by most Western writers are in regards to that war. The book summarizes almost 200 years of the Crusade war into 293 pages by noting and quoting different sources from the Arab authors and eyewitnesses. It is not only detailed but also mentions different perspectives, hence a significant revelation for the general audience. The aim of this paper is to discuss and remark on these diverse viewpoints as explained by Amin Maalouf, including reviewing the book and showing how it influences the readers.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Crusade had taken over lands and slaughter many but it was that they were unable to hold Levant, and all conquests were reversed back into the hands of Muslims. Every Crusader kingdom was eventually overrun and cased to exist. Therefore, the military control of the region ended in a failure. The religious “liberation” of Jerusalem from the hand of Muslims was not accomplished. While catholic Christians gained control of the region, they were not successful in converting the local citizens. Catholic Church could be seen as a denomination that was catering hordes of pilgrims from Europe and the invading soldiers. Other Christian denominations were often hostile toward Rome, especially Greek Orthodox Church after 1204. Crusaders did not eliminate Islam in that region and often followed local laws and customs to maintain the delicate balance of power. The failure was also cost by many of their leaders were from different European nations and they brought their own distrust and envy with them, resulting argument and create conflict along the crusade While the language barrier between the leaders could be relatively easily overcome using Latin or French, for the common soldiers it was still a problem that added to the friction between the factions on crusade. The Crusades also have resulting…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The first relationship that was severely hurt was between Muslims and Christians. Their relationship was severed because the Christians kept attacking and attacking the Muslims for 150 years straight to get back the holy lands. While in the process, they killed hundreds of thousands of Muslims, including women and children, even though the Muslims had practiced religious tolerance while they occupied Jerusalem. The second relationship that was hurt was the relationship between the Christians and Jews. Throughout the course of the Crusades the Crusaders committed multiple acts of anti-semitism. Most Christians believed that the Jews were responsible for Jesus Christ’s crucifixion, so they thought that they should not only avenge the Muslims, but the Jews, especially since they lived amongst all of the Christians and not all the way in Jerusalem (“Jews and the Crusades”). One example of their hatred is shown when the king of France received a letter, from Peter the Venerable, about punishing the Jews because, “They defile Christianity and fleece Christians. They should not be killed, but they should be made to suffer fearful torments and be prepared for greater ignominy, for an existence worse than death”(Venerable, Peter the). Although many Christians believed that they should attack the Jews, most church officials were completely against it and tried to stop the…

    • 1686 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “On this account I, rather the Lord, urge you as Christ’s heralds to persuade all people of whatever rank, foot-soldiers and knights, poor and rich, carry aid promptly to those Christians and to destroy the vile race from the lands of our friends” (Urban 1095). Surprisingly, the previous years of hatred towards each other had been diminished as Pope Urban II had called the Byzantine counterparts as “friends” and “Christians”. The Pope recognized the Byzantine as fellow Christians and brothers. Men of all social backgrounds, flocked to become a crusader because “Christ commands it” (Urban 1095). So in 1095, the First Crusade marched toward Jerusalem. Although the journey to Jerusalem was religiously motivated, the Holy City was not apart of the Byzantine Empire, which was where the emperor originally wanted. Pope Urban II had lead the Crusade towards Jerusalem to conquer land that was considered holy. Conquering holy land would allow the Pope to be granted land and power (Class Notes Dec 20…

    • 1426 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the Second Crusade, the Seljuk Turks fought back and took down Edessa. The two leaders set out to take the Holy Land back though, were not successful. In the Third Crusade, it was just bad luck for the three powerful monarchs that set out to take it back. In the Fourth Crusade, the crusaders decided to attack Constantinople instead of going to the Holy Land. The next crusade was called the Children’s Crusade. The pope denied them and told them to go home. In the Fifth Crusade, they failed, ending papal leadership of the western crusaders. In the Sixth Crusade, Frederick II lead it. It took place with no papal support. The Holy City was taken back but was lost when Frederick left (296). The Seventh and Eighth Crusades were both failures and were poorly organized by the king of France, Louis IX (Spielvogel, 296).…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Crusades Dbq Essay

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There are many historians who have differing views regarding the First Crusade in 1095 C.E. Popular questions that tend to arise with this topic are what initially caused the Crusade? What factors led to their successes and failures? How did the Crusades effect areas of Europe and the Middle East? Different historical perspectives attempt to answer these lingering questions with factual representation.…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Children's Crusade

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There were three monolithic faiths (Christianity, Judaism, and Islamic) fighting in the crusades. Despite their common roots the differences often cause conflict between them.…

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Before the First Crusades had started, the Byzantine Empire was having troubles protecting themselves from the Muslim Seljuk Turks. The Muslims were able to conquer some of the Byzantines land, as they were able to acquire Turkey and Armenia. As a result the Emperor Alexias went to ask Pope Urban the second for protection against the Muslims. Pope Urban looked at this as a way to gain land for the Christian faith and accepted, he gave a speech calling all Christians to join forces to claim Jerusalem and the Holy Land. To further motivate people the Pope promised any past sins would be cleansed if they were to join the crusades. This brought many volunteers that had no experience, Peter the hermit took advantage this and created the People’s…

    • 1472 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The causes and effects of the First Crusade have greatly impacted the view of Christianity and Islam because one is seen as associated with what is right and moral, whereas the other even today is still pictured as being deviants and corrupt. The roots of this ongoing struggle of power between Christianity and Islam have left both religions in a state of endless antipathy. Perhaps the factors that prompted First Crusade can be seen…

    • 2031 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    During the Post Classical-Era which lasted roughly from 500 CE to 1450 CE, the world was in a state of accelerated change and growth in the fields of politics, economics, and especially religion. During this time, Islam, one of the largest and most well-known religious traditions in the world, was founded and contained in the expanding Arab Empire. In addition to this, Christianity continued to have a profound impact on the world as it spread its ideas and beliefs across Europe. When one compares these two expanding religious traditions, one can see that they had numerous commonalities. Though Islam and Christianity expanded in different geographic areas utilizing different methods, both contained similar religious ideas and directly influenced each other during the time of the Crusades.…

    • 1864 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The crusade is the group of wars which was undertaken by Christians of the western European which was done to control from the Muslim. These wars was held between 11th, 12th and the 13th century. This history is mostly about the wars and the political situations between the kingdoms.…

    • 1166 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Crusades had a tremendous effect on Medieval world, and Templars were the carriers of Gods might, at least for the western nations. However, muslims saw them as invaders and experienced the true face of Christian soldiers.…

    • 1079 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The crusades is a sequences of revolutionary actions that started back in the eleventh century going through in the late thirteen century. In general the crusades was basically about a mixture between religious awareness and military initiatives. In Europe the Christians were impatient to take back Jerusalem which is known as their holy land. The church had the power to Knights, Chiefs and even Popes that were impatient to transfer their religion to other nations. The Islamic militaries were full of power an energy and took over North Africa and most of Spain.…

    • 1334 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The beliefs each religion have had of one another have differed greatly. While Muslims were content allowing Christianity to exist alongside it peacefully, Christians did not feel the same way. Eventually this led to the Crusades, which were military-religious efforts to seize the sites of Biblical history from the “unfaithful”, i.e. Muslims. Nevertheless, although many Christian rulers have tried to stamp out Islam throughout the years, Islam remains undefeated. Both religions are widespread even today, regardless of their similarities and…

    • 2001 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays