Motherhood And Citizenship: Katrina Trask

Superior Essays
In a nation dominated by Patriarchal Christian discourse, the role of women was highly problematizes as a source of weakness. In order to counteract decline and promote positive reproduction, women were pushed into traditionally Victorian roles of motherhood and passivity. Katrina Trask wrote in her 1895 article entitled “Motherhood and Citizenship: Woman’s Wisest Policy” that woman should bear children with “the mission of the perpetration of the race” and a woman engaging in sexual acts with any other intention “has failed in her obligation and privilege” (Gavin 124). Through the discourse surrounding motherhood, the female body became a tool of the empire and belonged to the male patriarchal leaders. Heterosexuality’s aim is procreation …show more content…
Once more reinforcing the link between colonial, patriarchal, and Evangelical Christian discourse, came the idea “women who lacked sufficient religious fervor would succumb to the allure of the East of disintegrate in the hot tropical climate” (Krishnaswamy 55). Thus fears regarding the weak female in a climate thought to aggravate her nature were escalated due to the importance of her body to the empire. In Anna Lombard, the dynamic of problematic sexuality and desire are enacted in the relationship between Anna and Gerald, and Victoria Cross questions the stringent British views towards gender roles by embedding the female character of Anna with the sexual appetite that is approved of in a male. In Burma, Gerald is told that he must “settle down, take a wife, and live regularly” rather than fretting over a girl abroad (Cross 36). Here the word “regular” makes the claim that a man needs to have a woman in order to express his sexuality. This is reinforced again when another man tells Gerald “This is a country in which a man can live, but he cannot live alone.” (Cross …show more content…
While Gerald is able to live alone and control his desires, Anna’s sexuality is weak and when Gerald leaves her, her strong sexual desire is likened to a man. Unlike Gerald, Anna cannot live alone and takes a foreigner as a husband. In reversing the desires of men and women and giving her female character the sexual desires allowed men, Victoria Cross explores implications of both female and male sexuality as well as problematic discourse surrounding miscegenation. While it was “natural” for a man to take a foreign wife while abroad and then abandon her and her children when he no longer needed her, the public struggled to accept Cross’s depiction of a woman taking a native to satisfy her own sexual desires and reviews claims “Anna Lombard’s ill-regulated sensuality is disgusting” and find fault with Gerald for accepting such a depraved woman. Cross explores the different treatment given male and female sexuality and desire in Anna Lombard and reveals the extent to which a women’s body belongs to the empire and man’s belongs to

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    The mid twentieth century was a defining moment in American history-particularly with respect to the securing of ladies' rights. While the period was thought to be prosperous and later idea to be a cheerful time, in reality, it was a period of grave social clash and human enduring (Parish, 110). Among the individuals who persevered through much enduring were ladies. As Margaret Sanger discovered, ladies, particularly the individuals who were poor, had no way out with respect to pregnancy. The main route not to get pregnant was by not having intercourse a decision that was quite often the husband's.…

    • 1591 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Women's Roles

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages

    A lot has been expected of women throughout history and their roles have changed through time. However, there are some roles of women that have not changed very much, the role might have been performed differently and the benefits of their roles have changed but the purpose has remained the same. These roles have been called a deputy husband, republican motherhood, the cult of true womanhood the names might be different but the roles that are expected of the women remain the same. Women are expected to be housewife’s, and mothers. Women are also expected to be pious, pure, submissive and domestic.…

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    1) Virginian luxuries depict the common tendency of most Americans, which also includes our Founding Fathers in the grounds of enjoying their liberty that undertakes physical violence, sexual harassment and slavery practiced by the common people and slave owners. The brutality, slave practice, violence, sexual harassment etc. conducted by the white people based on their race and power over the African American men and women are featured in “Virginian Luxuries”. The three races described by Alexis de Toqueville are the White or European, the Negro and the Indian. Toqueville describes the whites as the superior people all in terms of their intelligence, power and enjoyment.…

    • 1414 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Sexual attitudes have changed tremendously throughout history. In the 19th century women were seen as inferior individuals and did not equal up to the status of a man. Education and beauty did not at all matter to the superior sex of males. Women’s roles, economic status, and social status were all dominated by the male society. Silence lingered among women during the 19th century.…

    • 2567 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Chrys Ingraham’s “Heterosexuality”, she discusses an angle of women’s oppression that stems from heterosexuality being normalized in society. This normalization is not natural, and is instigated because it helps men stay above in power. It is a social institution that has a bias in favor of heterosexuality and romanticize heterosexual relationships and related rituals. The main argument of Chrys Ingraham’s “Heterosexuality” is that heterosexuality is not something people are born with or have natural leanings toward.…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the late nineteenth century and the early twentieth century, under the repressive ruling of the patriarchal society, female have been greatly tortured by the lack of independence, and lots of works were published regarding these social defects. Two short stories, “the Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman and “the Lottery” by Shirley Jackson, both vividly portray unjust female status during that period. However, two different aspects in these stories ---right of speech and motherhood--- are destroyed under diverse situations, which later lead to two distinct fates and themes. The narrator in “the Yellow Wallpaper” and Mrs. Hutchinson in “the Lottery” both represent women who suffer from and fight against unjust treatments given…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In Samule Selvon’s 1956 novel The Lonely Londoners much of the characters’ interactions with each other are focused on sexual relationships between the West Indian male characters (“the boys”) and the European white women whom they pursue, whether these interactions be between men and women or between male friends. The way these relationships are described by the boys to each other perpetuates the systematic devaluing of women in British society, reducing their personhood to mere sexual conquests in an effort to prove their own masculinity. These scenes have lead some critics to dismiss the novel as too overtly sexist to be groundbreaking from a racial or immigrant perspective. However, the women that the boys have relations with (both working class and rich) have a similar perception of their partners and seek them out in order to feel liberated from oppressive white men in their lives or to fulfill their own racist sexual fantasies.…

    • 2027 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the time period that John Webster’s The Duchess of Malfi was written, women had absolutely no sexual agency. Divided into categories of Madonna or Whore, women had impossible expectations to live up to. While marriage is the one institution in which it is socially acceptable for a woman to be sexual, the play subverts this. That Webster has the Duchess’ brothers the Cardinal and Antonio’s critique her for remarrying makes the categories of Madonna and Whore indistinct, thus demonstrating policing woman’s sexuality is useless.…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Distrust Between the Sexes In the essay by Karen Horney Distrust between the sexes, Horney delivers a pyschoanalytical argument that ( discovers) compelling argument that (gets at) the depperoted conflict between males and females and to what these problems can be attributed to. She illustrates that these troubles stem from a childhood conflict as a result of a the opposite sex parent disappointing the child and this leading to the ultimate distrust between the sexes. The distrust between sexes Horney attritubes it to a psychological history that will later affect relationships with the opposite sex because of certain expectations that will not be met To begin, Karen Horney presents the origins as to why there is a distrust between the sexes.…

    • 640 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Introduction: Summary: Margaret Fuller, author of Woman in the Nineteenth Century argues that humanity will only become suited for the beauty of the world and heaven when “freedom for Woman as much as for Man shall be acknowledged as a right, not yielded as a concession”. The essay begins to show a claim, counter-claim, and refutation format and through this, Fuller argues that women should be equal. Fuller begins her essay with explaining how deeply embedded this idea that women are inferior to men by giving an example of a common phrase of time. She explains how these is not only unfair but also unreasonable because why would a God, who is perfect, create inferior beings and give them less intellectual gifts. This alleged lack of reason…

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Mofe Adeosun When It Changed – Joana Russ “When it changed,’’ is a story about a society of women living on the planet Whileaway, different from planet Earth. A plague wiped out half of the population, including all of the men. Fortunately, for the society, the population that survived was a group of the most intelligent women, who through a scientific breakthrough were able to have children. They are optimistic about their future and aim to thrive at their own pace. Their society is one in which women of all strengths, talents and abilities have come to live peacefully and at ease with one another, without being looked down on as subordinate to another person.…

    • 1288 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Country Wife Analysis

    • 1484 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Deception and cuckoldry enable instability in the traditional home in Wycherley’s The Country Wife. He examines desire and how it affects every aspect of social life. It can cause adverse reactions such as paranoia, fear, jealousy, creativity, anger, deception, and idolatry. It is clear that through the idea of possession and desire, Wycherley exposes harmful gender roles, oppressive institutionalized practices, and the conflicting quality of competition.…

    • 1484 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Constancy In Cupid

    • 1050 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Cupid is emblematic of the constancy of the sonneteer’s love as induced by the female object. As the sonnets progress, he becomes the object of her attention and her criticism, before she finally moves away from both Venus (Wroth, Crown Sonnet 9) wherein she rejects him for her “sunne”, and Cupid (Sonnet 103) (who seems to become a sort of surrogate for her love interest, as well as the representative of her own desire) to a higher form of love that transcends both passion and longing . Shift seems to reject female sexuality, and the lesbian exploration that comes with it, in favor of marital (or at least heterosexual) constancy, and the higher love that comes with it. This is further reflected in the corresponding plot of Urania, wherein…

    • 1050 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Relationships are delicate. In order to thrive, it requires love, but without that durable foundation, the smallest of fractures can cause the collapse of the entire relationship. “Sexy” in the collection, Interpreter of Maladies, written by award winning author Jhumpa Lahiri, portrays what basis an extramarital relationship is supported by. Miranda, a young American, is engaged in an affair with a wedded man, Dev, who is different from any other guy she has ever dated.…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Howells contemplates and disrupts his own recommendations established in Criticism and Fiction throughout his short story Editha. Furthermost, after reading Howells Criticism and Fiction, it is evident that his short story Editha appears somewhat hypocritical. Throughout Criticism and Fiction Howells proclaims that the European style of writing romance novels fails to provide substance in reality however it inclines to romanticize human experiences. He states “The love of the passionate and the heroic, as the Englishman has it, is such a crude and unwholesome thing...” (367).…

    • 207 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays