Victims From Birth Analysis

Improved Essays
In society, there are many different individuals in the world that suffer from some sort of disability. Not everyone gets the chance to live a normal life because they might have a problem or sickness that they have to overcome. In the article “Victims from Birth” founding Editor Wendy McElroy, provides the story of Gauvin Hughes McCullough, whose deaf parents deny him a hearing aid, hoping he would grow up and be just like them. The lesbian couple were delighted to have Gauvin, their child to be born with a hearing disability because he would most likely be involved with the deaf culture. We see how parents want their child to be exactly like them but that isn’t right. A child is going to grow up wanting to make choices and its their decision to decide if they want …show more content…
Levy notes that the deaf will “always [be] restricted to a narrower range of jobs.” Some jobs are difficult to do when an individual is disabled. Gauvin can become a law enforcement officer just like others. For example, him and his partner might get a call for a domestic violence case and when they get to the scene, bunch of people are fighting. When Gauvin separates everyone, he tries to take a police report by trying to get information from the individuals. Since they are talking really fast and keep turning around, he cant fully understand what they are saying so it will be difficult for him to get an accurate report of the scene. Another career that might be difficult for a deaf individual might be a fire fighter. Gauvin can be on the job and trying to set out a fire when a wind warning can occur. Although other fire fighters are on the job, he might not hear it and by the time he realizes the wind is coming towards him, it will be too late. Careers like that might be available to deaf individuals like Gauvin but they might have a hard time in the

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Introduction to American Deaf Culture by Thomas Holcomb begins with a graphic celebrating Deaf culture to set the tone for the whole book. Holcomb discusses the difference between being deaf and the Deaf community, and the difference between community and culture. He uses specific examples to show how Deaf culture adheres to all five hallmarks that make up a culture. In the third chapter, he defines many of the terms and labels used to describe deaf people, including hearing-impaired and hard of hearing. Within this section, a helpful guide of appropriate terms and inappropriate terms is provided so hearing people understand what is acceptable when describing a deaf person.…

    • 1599 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Ashley X: the battle of Growth attenuation Ashley X is nine years-old and is severely disabled due to a disorder called static encephalopathy. Because of this disability her brain is affected leaving her to be physically and cognitively impaired. Ashley’s mindset is the same as a 3-6-month-old baby. To treat her disease her parents decided to use a treatment that’s normally used to stimulate the growth of an individual called Growth Attenuation. Along with the growth attenuation, they decided to have a hysterectomy, estrogen therapy, and an appendectomy.…

    • 2084 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “‘With an enhanced sense of smell, touch, and sight, Gauvin is not disabled, he is blessed”’ (“Introduction to designer… ). Couple Duchesneueu and McCullough genetically altered their child in order to be deaf, just as they are. As stated by Michael Poore, Duchesneau and McCullough do not look at this situation as taking away an ability from their child, instead they perceive this as being able to have their child belong to their minority culture. Or, as in more personal terms they think it is having a child that can “enjoy what we enjoy”(Poore). Sickeningly, these people took it into their own hands to guarantee a disability for their child.…

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wrongful Life

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Reproductive Genetics, Wrongful Life, and Wrongful Birth: A Summary Analysis of “Bill S-201: An Act to Prohibit and Prevent Genetic Discrimination” by Jennifer Ann Rinaldi Summary: Rinaldi’s (2009) article provides legal evidence of various cases involved in litigation related to ‘wringful death” and wrongful birth” issues in genetics reproductive rights. This article provides evidence of the negative biases of disability cases that can be harmful by devaluating the life of the disabled individual. A focus on various legal cases, such as R.H. v. Hunter, [1996] and Arndt v. Smith, [1997], that the burden of wrongful life and wringful death inordinately shift the shame of ‘existing” onto the disabled person in the Canadian court of law. A…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Deaf Like Me Summary

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The book “Deaf Like Me” by Thomas S. Spradley and James P. Spradley intrigued because it was about a hearing family that had a deaf daughter. I was also interested that the book was written in the perspective of the father. The statistic that vast majority of deaf children are born to hearing parents has always made me fascinated with what each hearing parent has done for their deaf child. I knew that this story would most likely have a happy ending considering the title “Deaf Like Me” I made the inference that maybe his daughter would find inclusion from being emerged in the culture of deaf individuals. “Deaf Like Me” followed the story of the parents Tom and Louise Spradley in the early 1960s.…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Through Deaf Eyes Summary

    • 1422 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Through Deaf Eyes was an extremely enlightening documentary about deaf life in America. The film begins with the question, what do you think it would be like being a deaf person? They explain that, whenever you ask a hearing person this question they respond with a lot of “can’ts”. I can’t, I can’t I can’t. Deaf people, however, do not think like that, they think of all the things they can do.…

    • 1422 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Disability and the justification of inequality in American History by Douglas C. Baynton The main idea addressed by Douglas C. Baynton is that disability has never been a focused upon and its is often overlooked and used as a justification for inequality in American History. Disability is ignored and not questioned or treated as a cultural construct. It is viewed as personal tragedy, instead of something that produces social hierarchies. The author goes on to describe how disability functions to justify inequality for disabled persons, as well as for women and other minority groups.…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “The Child Who is Deaf and Hearing Parents” (Exceptional Parent, May, 2010), writer Jess Freeman King focuses on the many challenges parents and their deaf children face while growing up. Accompanied by useful contact information for Deaf Associations, the article gives information and perception of many different approaches about how to raise a deaf child. As an important member in the Deaf community, Freeman argues the differences between a visual and an auditory language used for raising children. He stresses that the parents first discover what kind of learner their child is, before investigating further education for their child with the guidance of a professional.…

    • 142 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Though the treatment of people with disabilities was far form ideal during the early American period, it declined even further during the “progressive” era. The community aspect of caring for each other seems to have been completely lost, and attempts to find a place for individuals incapable of performing traditional labor diminished. Rapid industrialization continued to cause more and more disabilities, and the quality of life of those affected by them became even worse than before. Disabilities during this time were viewed as undesirable defects, and those who had them were ostracized and looked down upon. This era gave birth to the notion of eugenics, which claimed that a “perfect” society could hypothetically be achieved trough breeding out undesirable traits that did not align with their notion of the ideal citizen.…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The DRC’s reflections and recommendations take up the issue surrounding the message that is being sent to potential parents of children with disabilities and the many persons who are living with disabilities. Adrienne Asch argues that with “prenatal diagnosis, a single trait stands in for the whole, the trait obliterates the whole. With both discrimination and prenatal diagnosis, nobody finds out about the rest. The tests send the message that there’s no need to find out about the rest.” It is one thing to want a person to have what society deems a ‘normal’ life and it is another thing that society claims that such person is better served not existing because of their particular disability.…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay #2: Disability or Enhancement? In this essay, I will argue that Gauvin’s parents were not morally justified in their decision to permanently make their son born and remain deaf because by doing so the parents are treating the child as a lesser equal and are inflicting psychological harm. The role of parents is to ensure the wellbeing, safety, and support of their child in hopes that they can become stable, independent, and functional individuals in the near future. However, choosing a sperm donor with a history of deafness or any other disabilities is morally unjust because it is specifically taking a trait and implanting it upon a child causing them a life of hardships that they have to endure.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Sound And Fury Analysis

    • 1243 Words
    • 5 Pages

    "Sound and Fury," a documentary by Josh Aronson, is a compelling story of a struggle between two cultures; the hearing community and the deaf community, grounded in a conflict between members of one family, split over the perceptions and beliefs of what it means to be"normal. " It is a film about identity and culture, belonging and being an outsider, misconceptions and a desire to be understood. It is a film about the struggles of a cultural minority to find its place and acceptance in the larger world. Sound and fury is a tale of a family whose members are both; hearing as well as hearing impaired. The main character in the movie is a six years old Heather Artinian, born deaf to parents who are both hearing impaired.…

    • 1243 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Disability Movement Essay

    • 1472 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Throughout many years of history, those with disabilities were not always treated fairly or given equal opportunity. Activists around the world have worked together to achieve goals such as increased access to all types of transportation and a safer day to day environment. Equal opportunities in employment and education have been a big part of their efforts too. For many years, children with disabilities were many times segregated and not given an equal opportunity for a chance to learn and succeed in school. A disability should not limit a person’s choice to improve themselves and their intellectual capabilities.…

    • 1472 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The medical model of disability is a model which identifies the impairment of a disabled person as the problem, of which, the aim is to fix or cure this impairment by means of medical professionals whereas the social model of disability is a model which identifies that society creates barriers in the environment that do not allow disabled people from participating fully and equally to those who are able bodied and looking at ways that can remove these barriers for disabled people. This essay will thus further discuss the medical model of disability in contrast with the social model of disability and i will illustrate this by using materials such as case studies and academic references that relate to the medical model and social model of disability.…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Person First Language Reflection 1. What concepts did you find interesting or important from this article? I think the most important message that the article brings out is we need to treat the people who have disabilities as people like everyone first, but not as their medical diagnoses. They are the unique individual, they are a group of people that use their bodies in difference way, and they share the same rights as everybody. As people who don’t have disabilities, we shouldn’t use any words that contain with negative perception and stereotypes to describe the people who have disabilities.…

    • 1639 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays