Using The Rogerian Argument In Biology

Decent Essays
I like reading the Rogerian argument a bit more than I do the Toulmin argument, it is much easier to see both sides of the argument and what common ground they share. The Rogerian argument should be used to discuss sensitive topics like the choice of abortion, racial issues, and gun control. It also depends on what audience you are speaking to; because certain audience groups are so diverse sometimes it is best to tread lightly when speaking or writing no matter the topic. If you discuss evolution with a biologist it will be easy, but if you are attempting to discuss evolution with a devoted christian you must use the Rogerian argument and a non threatening tone. The Rogerian argument would be stronger in this example because you are pointing

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    “Evolution as Fact and Theory” by Stephan Jay Gould outlines the constant taxing debate over evolution among creationists and evolutionists. He outlines the major issues that fuel the dispute and provides the logical and scientific approach to evolution for a clear argument against the claims of creationists. He firstly, provides a thorough explanation of the misconceptions of the definitions; “theory” and “Fact’. In the common vernacular a fact may be perceived as undeniable information with absolute certainty. (gould)…

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lamoureaux, who believed that you could be a Christian and still believe in evolutionary theory, wrote the book I love Jesus and Accept Evolution. Evolution is the theory that animals evolved into different species over time. A lot of times people who believe in evolution are not Christians, but there are some Christians who do believe that you can be a Christian and still believe in evolution. This is a controversy because some people believe that if you are a Christian, you cannot believe in evolution. I however am a Christian, and from reading his book and learning more about evolution, I agree with Lamoureaux and believe that you can not only be a Christian, but also be a Christen who accepts the theory of evolution…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the court case Mclean vs. Arkansas on the creationism trial, Laudon “argues that the court decision was correct, but for the wrong reasons. He suggests that instead of showing that creation-science is not scientific (due to being untestable, etc.).” Laudon says the first two properties it must be guided by law; it must be explanatory reference by natural law can be explained he gives an example of world flood (P&R. p.342) cannot be explained by the law of science. Laudon stated that creation since has been tested previously and it was proven incorrect. Laudon believes judge Overton was wrong claiming creationism is unfalsifiable instead he should’ve said creationism is falsifiable because it claims the age of the earth, geological origin,…

    • 134 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Scopes: The Battle over America’s Soul The battle between science and nature seems to be one that is never ending. One of the times when this battle came to a head was in 1925 when a trial occurred over whether evolution was okay to be taught in school. In Tennessee, the practice was outlawed, but when a teacher in Dayton Ohio was coerced into using a textbook that contained evolution, the debate became one of major national attention. John Scopes, a twenty-four year old math and science teacher, were approached by George Rappleya and Fred Robinson.…

    • 1255 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rogerian Argument

    • 384 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1. The writer attempts to establish common ground in the fifth paragraph when she presents a possible compromise. Based on the Rogerian argument, she is successful because she presents a solution to reach common ground. 2. She states her position that instructors are justified in requiring students to turn off their phones in the third paragraph and supports it with research findings showing that cell phones are distractions.…

    • 384 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Roger Williams Beliefs

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As we read in class, Roger Williams wanted to build a wall of separation between the church and state. He was very vocal on his thoughts about the separation from the church and state as well as his disapproval of confiscating land from the Native Americans, and the Massachusetts governor and his assistants didn’t want him putting those thoughts into peoples heads and so they decided to banish him, but not before he could disappear from Massachusetts. Winthrop and Williams shared a friendship, Winthrop welcomed him as “a godly minister” (Bremer), so when Winthrop got word of the banishment coming for Williams he warned him of it. Williams hurriedly got everything he needed and left Massachusetts.…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Scopes Trial

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Throughout history there have been many debates about whether or not evolution and the Bible should be taught in public schools. In fact, there was once a court case, the Scopes Trial, in which many issues had arisen and were resolved about this controversy. One of the main issues discussed was a debate on evolutionism being taught in school. Clarence Darrow, an atheist lawyer, asked William Jennings Bryan, a devout and vocal politician and a Christian, a series of questions in regards to what Bryan believed to be true about the Bible. Darrow later then explained that science had said otherwise about certain issues which even today are still referred back to .…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Fear is something that drives this world. It is a natural emotion that causes damage to the body and mind, affecting our decisions, communication, and productivity. Whether we want to accept it or not, fear has a purpose which is to help us during times of struggle. We take comfort in our fears and let it soothe us. Eula Biss in her essay, “On Immunity: An Inoculation” brings a great point on how people seem to base their paranoia off of other people’s fears, and lack of knowledge.…

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Theory of Evolution, conducted by Charles Darwin brought a grateful amount of controversy in the science and education fields today. Debates between is Darwin’s evolution theory correct and if it should be taught in schools. Many disagree that Darwin’s theory should be taught in public schools because it is not proven and it’s a religious belief. Yet Darwin’s theory has all the characteristics of applying to science education. Teaching evolution in public schools wouldn’t change one’s morals or beliefs.…

    • 1521 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    In his towering essay “Ideas of Nature,” Raymond Williams examined the dynamic relationship which humans hold with nature – a relationship which involves histories of intervention, separation, and domination – to investigate “whether nature include[s] man.” The dominant narratives which emerged from this debate suggest that nature* is wholly separate from human; contemporary discourse argues that nature is intrinsically where industry (and in extension human activity) is not. But what happens when nature becomes industrialized? Moreover, what happens when mechanized intervention invades the pastoral, a realm seen historically as natural? Building from Williams’ line of inquiry, I seek to question two practices which widen the rift between humans…

    • 2085 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Rogerian Argument, coming from Carl Rogers’ theory, is an effective analysis within written arguments. Essentially, it involves adopting the role of a once therapist to aid in solving or coming to a compromise of an issue. The passage “Letter to a Southern Baptist Minister” written by Edward O. Wilson, argues that religion and science could potentially join together. The author uses restatement, which just manipulates the words of the speaker to change their understanding. He proves his point by not confronting his opponent in an adversarial argument.…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Outline and evaluate two or more competing theories of drug use. Which of these do you think is most successful at explaining contemporary patterns of drug use, and why? The causes of drug use have been under discussion for many years. In this essay, I will outline several theories which divided into three main areas: biological theories, psychological theories and sociological theories.…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, I felt that Gould was little harsh to the creationist by his writing style and some choice of words but the constant adding of creationist views and explanation on the theory was needed to prove that there is more logic in the evolution theory over the religious belief. Everyone should believe in religion but not blindly that you start calling it science without no facts to support it. Religion and science should be kept away from each other and religion should be there to learn the values and traditions rather than questioning the existence of science because if it gets out of hand then one day it will put stop to all new discoveries made by scientist. Throughout his essay, Gould was trying to portray that, “We must infer them from results that still surround us: living and fossil organisms for evolution, documents and artifacts for human history”, which is spot-on because the world runs on proofs than on your opinions (Gould, 255). Gould’s presentation of evidences and his disagreement towards the creationist is very logical and written in a straightforward manner for the audience to know that there is more creditability of Darwin’s theory than the creationist…

    • 1002 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Richard Dawkins is a well-known biologist and a writer who takes after Charles Darwin. Charles Darwin was the man who originally discovered the possibility of natural selection. Scott LaFee is a science writer who believes that Dawkin’s work proves that he is very similar to Charles Darwin. “Richard Dawkins, the 68-year-old English biologist and best-selling author, whose rousing defense and explanations of evolution have earned him international admiration, the enduring enmity of creationists and the nickname ‘Darwin 's Rottweiler.’” (LaFee).…

    • 2304 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Richard Dawkins had the better argument in the debate of ‘Has Science Buried God’ because compared to John Lennox, Dawkins’ answers were based on things or theories that had already been proven, the morality of God, and the reason the mind appreciates the idea of a God. Dawkins leaned on the theory of evolution and explained why God didn’t have anything to do with natural selection. Dawkins also used the morality of God in the debate to prove the point that even if there was a God, he was very ‘petty’ and wouldn’t fit the description of a ‘good father.’ In addition to these, he also made a good argument about the reason the mind appreciates having a God to look up to or believe in. So, all personal feelings aside, it is evident that Dawkins made the better argument.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays