Native American Boarding Schools Analysis

Improved Essays
The priority of this monograph is to talk about Native Americans unfair treatment in the United States. The main topics covered range from the initial contact with the European Americans to a more specific example of how the Native Americans have become an extremely oppressed group in the United States. The monograph gave details on the various acts that were passed to control the Native American population. This article also describes the effects on the Native Americans that were created from the discriminatory acts. The authors gave a verity of examples about what the Native Americans lost with all of the discrimination. Examples of the discrimination include loos of their culture, land, language, and most of their customs. The monograph …show more content…
Although the concept of assimilation seemed that it would help the Native American population strive, it ended up doing the opposite. The real intention of the schools was to “provide for the U.S. government a method to educate and civilize Native children away from the influences of their savage lifestyle and unchristian ways” (2000:6). Boarding schools were set up with a military structure, and enforced rigid structure and punitive discipline. The staff of the boarding schools fit right into the model of education. Although many were attracted to the boarding schools, very few had an understanding of the Native American culture. Many of the staff had a military background whose recent past was destroying Native American culture and who possessed a sincere desire to teach Native children that lack appreciation of the Native American culture. Social rejects and people who were labeled as misfits of society were also part of the staff at the boarding schools. These types of people are the ones who implemented and amplified the abusive treatment. Native children were subjected to harsh and cruel punishment for so called inappropriate behavior. Some of the punishments given are being whipped or beaten, denied contact with their family for extended periods of time, denied medical care, used as …show more content…
The Native students never had a chance to learn a traditional family environment, negotiate or compromise with tribe elders, and they were not taught their duties within the tribes. These students missed out on learning their tribe’s culture and were unable to develop into an active tribe member. In addition, alcohol, risk taking, hostility, and limiting coping skills were used as a replacement for being separated for so long. The monograph also talks about Child Welfare/Social Services agencies and how they employed non-Indian standards and lacked and understanding for the family system inside the tribes. This was harmful because they had no understanding for the family and social structures that Native Americans use. By removing the children from their families it increased the parented not wanting to care for their children and drug and alcohol abuse parents. This ultimately led to an increase in the problem with the Child Welfare/Social Services agencies were hoping to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The residential school system did not only lead Aboriginals to behave more violently but also it suppressed the culture and family life of the Indigenous community. The systematic discrimination that Aboriginal children faced in residential schools destroyed families in Aboriginal society, it broke apart the child and parent and violated the parent’s choice to make a decision on behalf of the child (Grant 1996: 233). Aboriginal children were many times only allowed to speak English and were beaten if they spoke their native language which is an example of how the European setters suppressed the Aboriginal culture (ibid 189). The role of language in a culture is the basis all teachings and learning on the oral tradition is that it transits the collective memory of the people (ibid 193). The children grew up losing their cultural identity of what it meant to be a native and were traumatized from these experiences.…

    • 1297 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Students were also told that their parents were not coming for them because they did not love them (O’Connell) when the truth was that parents could not legally rescue their children. This raised distrust among the children when they were allowed to return home after age 18. These of-age students also did not know how to function in a communal body just like they were incapable of communal and family emotions because of the cloud of distrust and individualism. This inability to possess affection,…

    • 1304 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Children were forbidden to practice their indigenous culture and suffered a great deal of abuse while in these schools, therefore resulting in mental illness and confusion amongst Aboriginal communities (Niezen, 2009). Another historic issue that was caused by residential schools was the parent’s opportunity to learn basic parenting skills (Niezen, 2009). Having their children taken away stopped them from having the experience of raising a young child into an adult. This resulted in poor parenting skills amongst generations because they did not learn what parenting ways worked for them and their families. Thirdly, the final historical aspect of Aboriginal community’s in relation to cluster suicide is the indigenous lifestyle.…

    • 1295 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Due to the fact that the Igbo villagers have never known anything other place outside Umuofia, everywhere else seems to be disregarded. This is why the Igbo accordingly do not allow their children and young ones to assimilate into the white missionaries’ religion, culture, education and reject the missionaries’ attempts to teach them a new language due to their devotion of their own Igbo language. In addition to attempting to assimilate the Igbo people, the missionaries change the way their society operates. Before the “white man” arrived, the Igbo had a judicial court system passed down for generations in harmony with their culture, values and beliefs. The Igbo court system was headed by their elders who are believed to be very wise and knowledgeable in their religion according to the Igbo.…

    • 1261 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a future social worker, the instances that angered me the most were the numerous accounts the social workers failed the children and the family as well. This institution was created to protect the children. Alternatively, the social workers didn’t report and record their findings accurately. All the signs of abuse and neglect were ignored and there were times when the social workers tried to make excuses for the incidents. The social workers failed to do follow up’s and closed the multiple cases on the family with inaccurate dictations.…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Victims of child abuse don’t know how to make friends and are scared of individuals because they don’t have an understanding of themselves and others. Abused children don’t have many friends as they tend to scare others because it’s difficult for them to regulate their emotions. Child abuse scars children and also makes it difficult to have healthy interactions. Abused victims suffer from depression, anxiety, etc. due to feelings getting ignored, and so abused children can’t convey their feelings to maintain…

    • 957 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Another stereotype that people think of when they hear people talk about Native Americans is that they know about their culture and history. This is a stereotype because many children do not know about their heritage. There are many reasons why Native American children might not know of their heritage. A reason might be that their parents might not even know about their heritage since they could be from different tribes. Another reason could be, stated by Fleming (2006), “some parents do not know their own cultures because they were products of the boarding school system that discouraged traditional customs and traditions” (Fleming, 2006).…

    • 1017 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I could cover the plight of the misrepresented and poorly presented from almost every minority group America has to offer, but here we will speak of two. I will start in order of who was first, the Native Americans. Since the beginning of exploration to our continent the Native Americans have suffered at the hands of unjust stereotypes and media portrayal. From stories of how the west was won, with its heroic cowboys and bloodthirsty savages, to the pamphlets and spread rumors and justifications to slaughter and eliminate a “Godless” threat. Native Americans have been subjected to harsh stereotypes in order for a few to justify what can only be deemed as greed and extortion.…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Child Abuse Effect

    • 1806 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Child abuse is a serious problem through the world. There are different forms of child abuse such as: physical, sexual, and psychological. The effects of these heinous acts performed by typically parents, or child care givers, can leave lasting scars on children throughout their whole lives. The emotional toll from child abuse can lead to other problems in children as well. Eating disorders, drug use, early sexual behavior, self-harm, discomfort with touching, and trouble sleeping are just a few of the many side effects children suffer from child abuse.…

    • 1806 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Family problems are prevalent in Indigenous communities, these problems stem from changes in communication, parenting and intergenerational relations, which prompt feelings of loneliness (Kral et al. 2014). In addition, multigenerational trauma is detrimental to individuals and communities; adults who attended residential schools are reported to resort to alcohol and substance abuse to cope (Kral et al. 2014), consequently their family life suffers as these individuals are unable to properly function due to trauma and subsequent coping means. Likewise, parents and youth tend to avoid each other due to these negative interactions; cultural loss eliminates traditional activities and practices which originally encouraged family and community cohesion.…

    • 1359 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays