On the other hand, some parents and coaches might think that it is worth a few bucks to make their kids smile. However, instead of spending a lot of money on them, simple a thumbs up or a good job will do just fine. Trophies lose their meaning when people don't earn them. The "Trophies for All" policy does not prepare youth athletes for the real world. According to the SCOPE article, written by Lauren Tarshis, "In life, most people are not rewarding for simply doing what's required.”…
In Vivian Diller’s article, “Do We All Deserve Gold? Setting Kids Up To Fail” and Lisa Heffernan’s article, “In defense of participation trophies: Why they really do teach the right values” both authors disagree on many different things about participation trophies. The one disagreement that drives these authors the furthest apart is kids being given trophies for just participating or giving trophies to those who only win and what the value of this holds for the kids. Lisa Heffernan states that giving “participation trophies remind young kids that they are part of something, and may help build enthusiasm to return for another season” in her article “In defense of participation trophies: Why they really do teach the right values” (In Defense).…
On the topic of participation awards, Lisa Heffernan and Vivian Diller have both published articles advocating either for, or against rewarding children at a young age, regardless if they’ve won a game or not. In terms of making a strong argument, both writers used celebrity testimonies, life experience, and quotes from reputable sources, some tactics more effective than others. In Lisa Heffernan’s article favoring participation trophies, “In Defense of Participation Trophies: Why They Really do Teach the Right Values,” she often pulls from her most powerful and relevant source to her topic- her son. Statements such as “When my son was around eight years old … he scoffed at the very idea that such an award existed.” would play a critical role in setting up a counter argument, but much like her other quotations in her article, it was followed by a statement from Hillary L. Friedman, a sociologist, that initially seems to back up her son’s opinion.…
Corey Turner remembers collecting participation trophies from the YMCA soccer program he was involved in as a young athlete. These trophies are now sitting in a dusty box somewhere in his parent's basement. This leads him to question whether or not young athletes should receive trophies for just showing up. Corey Turner is not alone, people across the nation have debated this issue for as long as youth sports have been in existence. I believe that kids should not get trophies for participating because kids should learn life lessons from both wins and losses and participation trophies do more harm than good.…
Many people find themselves asking if participation trophies are even important or not, or if we should even have them in general. Well we should, for reasons that might have been overlooked. Participation trophies show a great significance consisting of commitment and dedication, they remind one of an experience or the friendships they made, and they give more meaning than you would think to a young child learning self-confidence. Commitment and and dedication show the growth of responsibility and a participation trophy shows just this. Richard Greenberg says this, “Participation trophies mark the fact that these kids kept a commitment and showed up to the games.”…
Participation trophies are bad but not because it hurts the children. Participation trophies are good and bad. They help motavate some children. The children that worl hard for the trophy feel bad that the people that dont work hard get the same trophy. Particapation trophies are…
There has been a long discussion in society on weather or not kids should receive participation trophies. The people that disagree with giving kids participation trophy's say that giving kids participation trophy's will hurt them later in life by not teaching them the values of hard work. However the people that agree with giving kids participation trophy's say that they can make kids feel good and raise there self esteem. I agree with not giving participation trophy's because the value of hard work is very important.…
Trophies should only be given to the youth athletes that do the best. Participation trophies are a waste of scarce funds. According to "The Great Trophy Debate" by John O'Sullivan, he says that this is a really poor use of scarce funds. In the same article it says that we spend $2000-$3000 on participation trophies.says that this is a really poor use of scarce funds. In the same article it says that we spend $2000-$3000 on participation trophies for youth athletes.…
If you give a kid a trophy, but he did not participate he will not learn that he has to earn that he has to work to get things. My second reason is; kids have to work to get better. (Website #2) “The benefit of competition isn't actually winning” according to Ashley Merryman. If you just try and…
Trophy's are a encouragement to youth athletes. Youth athletes just want to play the sport and have a good time . Also it is nice to be rewarded even if u don't always succeed it always a good thing to have hope. Critics say that if youth athletes get a reward just by doing something going to make them think for everything they do they deserve a reward. They believe that giving participation reward is going to ruin there mentality .…
In The Great Trophy Debate: Do We Need Participation Awards? by John O'Sullivan it says, "The $2000-$3000 we spent every year on awards could have put dozens of kids on the field, and/or dozens of coaches through some quality coaching education. " The few thousand dollars that is spent on making the awards could be spent on better and more useful things. Youth athletes might need better uniforms or more sports equipment to train with but the funds for these things are going towards awards. In life, if you don't earn something, you probably won't be rewarded.…
Priceman explains “They were taught that these awards were placeholders in life” (Priceman). Priceman is explaining that having trophy as a placeholder is Ok and nothing is wrong with that, and that is what kids should think of Trophies . Priceman believes when everyone grows up from their childhood and looks back at the Trophies they will remember what they did when they were a kid thanks to having that as a placeholder. However, “We must focus on process and progress, not results and rewards” (Merryman). With giving them Trophies they will not think they need to make progress and don’t care about the process.…
The majority of children participate In many extracurricular activities such as soccer, baseball, and dance. At the end of the season, every team has its annual awards night and where the star players would be recognized for their outstanding achievements. Everyone else on the team receives the “glad you tried but you aren 't good enough” trophy. Many children, including myself, fall into this category. As naive little children, many kids do not understand that this is the situation.…
They argue that when a kid is given a trophy they will continue to strive in order to get another one or maybe an even better one. Yaeger says that “you can work your absolute hardest to accomplish a goal and give it your best shot, but still come up short.” Showing that even if a kid is given a participation trophy it does not mean they did not try their best and work hard to earn that trophy. Cook quote softball coach Stacie Mahoe in basically saying that a trophy is just a piece of wood or plastic and that is does not influence a kid’s attitude toward working hard for things and earning them. The trophy only gives the child a reminder of the good time and something with their name inscribed on it that could actually impel them work harder and escalate how hard they work and earn more trophies that are bigger and better.…
If everybody gets a trophy it can take away the pride of having a trophy. Rewarding every effort with trophies does not prepare children for adult life. In order to receive a trophy, an athlete should prepare and perform above average at an event or at the end of a season. When athletes receive awards for simply showing up at practice and participating in games it sends the wrong message that kids don’t have to try their best to receive a trophy.…