Treaty Of Versailles Case Study

Good Essays
The Treaty of Versailles - Homework Assignment

1. “If I am elected, Germany is going to pay… I have personally no doubt we will get everything you squeeze out of a lemon, and a bit more. I propose that every bit of (German owned) property, movable and immovable, in Allied and neutral countries, whether state property or private property, should be surrendered by the Germans.”
Sir Eric Geddes, a government minister, speaking to a rally in the general election campaign, December 1918.

a. Why was it felt that Germany should be treated so harshly?

When the leaders of Britain, France and the USA arrived at the Paris Peace Conference, they were already under pressure to deal severely with Germany. As there were many people who were in favor that
…show more content…
3. Why did the allied leaders not get the treaty they wanted?

None of the allied leaders was happy with the terms of the treaty. Clemenceau and Wilson disagreed over many issues. The USA hadn’t suffered as much as France during the war and France resented Wilson’s generous attitudes towards Germany. The leaders disagreed over what to do about Germany’s Rhineland and coalfields in the Saar. Wilson had to give up on these issues. But in turn France and Britain did give Wilson what he wanted in Eastern Europe, which was to let them rule themselves.

Wilson was forced to give up on many of his 14 points. Many people considered them unpractical and unrealistic. Wilsons will to put the 14 points into action was further weakened because he didn’t have the support of the USA. The Americans found it pointless that they were joining wars that weren’t there’s to join. They didn’t want to be dragged into a war in Europe ever
…show more content…
George was unhappy with point 2 of the fourteen points, which stated there would be “free access to the seas in peacetime and wartime”. Wilson’s views on people ruling themselves also represented a great threat to the Britain Empire as they ruled millions of people all across the world.

4. How fair was the treaty of Versailles?

The treaty of Versailles was created with the intention of weakening Germany. On one side some people considered that the treaty was unfair to Germany, as they weren’t the only country responsible for starting the war. On the other hand Germany caused a lot of damage, and people thought that Germany should be treaty harshly to prevent it from starting another war.

The Treaty of Versailles was that was used to achieve each powers interest such as Germany’s navy being reduced so that it wouldn’t represent such a great threat to Germany, and Germany being weakened so France could have its revenge. The powers left the conference feeling that they weren’t able to create a treaty that would help keep the peace, and now a days historians blame the treaty of Versailles for helping cause World War 2.

The table below summaries how the Treaty of Versailles was

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The Unhappy Compromise World War I was officially brought to an end with the signing of the Treaty of Versailles on June 28, 1919. The Treaty of Versailles was negotiated among the Allied powers of Britain, France, and America with little to no participation from Germany. The intent of the treaty was two fold, first to prevent another world war, and second to punish Germany for starting the war to begin with. This vindictive approach would spill over into every part of the treaty and would ultimately lead to its failure. The Treaty of Versailles was unsuccessful, because the German people saw it as a betrayal, Germany was isolated politically form the rest of the world, Germany was forced to give up vast amounts of land, Germany’s proud…

    • 946 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Germans had also invaded France in 1870/1871, which also led to this hostility. Lloyd George held the middle ground, as he felt compelled to agree to a harsh peace due to public opinion at home, but he saw Germany as a strong trading partner, and a harsh peace would destroy the German economy, thus hurting the rest of Europe as well. (Pema Dechen Rapten, n.d.) This led to a very flawed treaty that benefited nobody and would prove to be very costly…

    • 2095 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Both the way in which the arrangement was finished and the particular achievements that it contained drove the defeated countries, especially Germany, to feel embarrassed as a persuasively smothered country. 2. Defects of Treaty of Versailles—A Dictated Peace: Apparently it was based upon the vision of US President Wilson 's Fourteen Points, however in all actuality it was intended to handicapped person Germany. The significant terms of the 440 Articles of the Treaty were gone for obliterating the force of Germany. Union of Austria and Germany had been illegal.…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Unit 3 Essay In 1919, Germany was presented with the peace terms of the Treaty of Versailles to end the gruesome World War I with two choices: to sign the treaty, or to be invaded and face yet another war. If they choose to sign, this would mean that they were solely “responsible” for the damage World War I had caused worldwide and would have to face the appropriate penalty for doing so. It was with great difficulty that Germany signed the Treaty of Versailles. Although a percentage from the German government were open to continuing the war, the German military was not prepared for it. The Germans had little choice but to accept to the treaty.…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The devastation in Europe caused by World War I led many countries to be left with little options, and British leaders came to the conclusion that the policy of appeasement would be the best for the country in order to avoid another war. According to Overy, the policy of appeasement was British and French attempts to satisfy the demands of the aggressive nations during the 1930’s, specifically Germany, Japan, and Italy. The interwar years is the time period between each world war, from 1919 to 1939. Appeasement was based on the idea that, eventually, Hitler would become satisfied with his demands; however, this did not happen because Hitler constantly wanted more. The policy of appeasement can be determined as ineffective during the interwar…

    • 1566 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    There are some points that reason that the fault may lay with the Allied Powers. The Allies were more concerned about the reparations they would receive from Germany than helping the world recover from the war. It is said that “America`s allies understood that Wilson`s principles jeopardized their own postwar plans for the acquisition of enemy territory” and so at the Paris Peace Conference they modified Wilson`s requests in a way that they still achieved the land they wanted. The end of the League of Nations was definitely influenced by the hole left by the United States, but the League wouldn’t have continued as it began since the nations were only united because each was looking to better their own…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Cause Of World War 2

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages

    At the Versailes Treaty they got ignored and no one listen them. Therefore when World War 2 started the United States adopted the policy of isolationism . That this war was none of their business. The United States would stop Germany in track if they wanted . However, the main way of thinking was it would be insane to do the same thing twice and expectation a different result.…

    • 809 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Others defend the Germans for their actions, stating that the Treaty of Versailles caused a huge amount of damage for the German people and land. Because Germany was not invited to the forming of the treaty, it was not prepared for the destruction and suffering…

    • 1223 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Clemenceau had enough of seeing damage being done to the land, industry, people, and the pride of France. At the end of the war many viewed Germany as a threat to national security; thus, they wanted Germany to be given a huge burden that they could not overcome easily. Clemenceau was a realist and was aware that not all of what he had wished for was going to be passed; nevertheless, he still viewed the treaty as ‘disappointing.’ The French President had even wanted Germany broken up into tiny states. Meanwhile, Lloyd George also wanted to punish Germany (as a mild treaty would not have been acceptable to the public), but not too harshly. He had wanted Germany to lose its navy and its colonies - the powerful navy threatened the British Empire.…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Under this circumstance, by the time when the war ended, the victors, in this case, the Triple Ententes, had to find someone to pay for the great loss, thus, the Treaty of Versailles was signed on the 28th of June, 1919, during the Paris Peace Conference. The establishment of the Versailles Treaty was criticized more likely as a vindictive act rather than an acceptable solution of peace making regard to its great economic, political and social suppression to Germany due to its harsh reparation provisions, extensive ceded territories and disarmament. However, although we could not deny the great adverse impact the Treaty of Versailles had on Germany which led to the subconscious resistance, it was not entirely the treaty itself which led to the rise of Nazism and the outbreak of the World War two, it was the irresolute attitude and the appeasement showed by the victorious, accompanying with the shadow of the American financial crisis which had fostered an ambitious Germany than…

    • 2110 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays