Treaty Of Tordesillas: A Comparative Analysis

Improved Essays
Spain, Britain, France, and Portugal all developed colonies in North and South America, but they administered them in differing ways. French explorers such as Jacques Cartier, and Samuel de Champlain founded French colonies on the island of Mont Real (now Montreal) and in Quebec by sailing along the St. Lawrence river. The summation of their new colonies became known as New France. After priest Jacques Marquette and trader Louis Joliet explored the Mississippi River and the Great Lakes, add Sieur de La Salle claimed the Mississippi for France and named Louisiana, New France covered much of the midwestern United States and eastern Canada.While New France was expansive, few people inhabited it. Most French colonists were more interested in the …show more content…
The Treaty of Tordesillas gave Spain all of the land to the west of a hypothetical north-south line. Because of the depopulation of Native Americans, the Spanish were able to seize farm lands. There were aspects of American Indian life that the Spanish left in place in their administration. For example, while the priestly class was eliminated, the existing Indian nobility remained with the support of Spanish authority. The enslavement of the Indians was banned by the mid-16th century, however other ways of getting labor or taxation were brought about. Encomiendas allowed individual conquerors to use Indians as workers and servants, and were generally detrimental to the natives' society. The colonial government also extracted labor and taxes from the natives. This included requiring communities to send groups of laborers for public works projects. Although a wage was paid for the work done, abuse of the system was abundant. Agriculture and mining (especially for silver) were the basis of the Spanish colonies' economies. Spain maintained control of their American empire through the use of a meticulously regulated bureaucratic system. Built on a juridical core, it was staffed mostly by university-trained, Spanish lawyers. The laws were codified by the Recopilación, and the king ruled through the Council of the …show more content…
The created the first plantation colonies in the Americas. While Spain and its colonies focused their efforts on mining and silver, Portugal's colonies produced tropical crops, like sugar, that were in high demand in Europe. Eventually, the British and the French established their own sugar plantations in the Caribbean, which undermined Brazil's control on the market. The Portuguese king sent a governor and other officers to Salvador, where a capital was established. Any indigenous resistance was quickly ended through a combination of military action, missionary activity, or disease. Brazil (under control of the Portuguese) became the world's leading sugar producing, primarily because of the labor of Native Americans and African slaves. A social hierarchy was created by the plantation system, and had a lasting impact: the white planter families became aristocracy, and the slaves were the lowliest of society. Similar to Spain, Portugal developed a bureaucratic structure in the Americas. Missionary orders held a particular importance in Portugal, as their large ranches and sugar mills provided them with wealth to support the construction of churches and schools. Just like in the Spanish colonies, officials who had training in the law were the heart of the bureaucracy. However, while the Spanish Empire existed almost exclusively in the Americas (aside from the Philippines), the Portuguese

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Spain acted as one of the first major colonizers of the New World and married Spanish culture into these lands. Colonization allowed Spain to expand its influence and exploit the Americas for natural resources and labor. These efforts secured Spain’s place as one of the strongest countries and allowed a profitable system off the Columbian…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The key difference between the colonies of New Spain and New France and those of Virginia and New England was the way their settlers interacted with the surrounding Native Americans. Whether it be through exploiting the Indians for labor, as was done by the Spanish, or forging alliances with them, like the French, both New Spain and New France became frontiers of inclusion, where natives were incorporated into colonial society. On the contrary, England began massive immigration to Virginia and New England in order to provide workers for tobacco cultivation. Because its colonies were populated with families, there was no need for Indians to be incorporated into society, neither as workers nor as marriage partners. Therefore, the English set…

    • 131 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Due to the fact that the Native Americans that worked for the Spanish landowners we not able to keep up “the output of the mines or the plantations” the Native American labour was replaced with enslaved Africans people many of whom were taken brutally (Slavery Contract). In order to keep up with the raising demand of crops and materials, there began an increase in plantations and mines which eventually lead to the increase of slaves that were traded across the Atlantic. The slaves, for the most part, were shipped to Europe, before being transported to the Americas. Sugar was among many of the heavily grown crops in Spanish America as they imported “8000 slaves per year” to cultivate this crop (Slavery Contract). The slaves, however, that laboured in the mines were intended to collect materials “where gold and silver could be” located (Slavery Contract).…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The Treaty Story”, By the Minnesota Historical Society, and “What Does Justice Look Like?” by Wazyatawin are two pieces about Native American treaties when Minnesota was first being established. They both discuss the initial discovery of the land by fur traders and European settlers in the 1700’s and on, as well as the first communication between natives and white settlers. Both are credible, factual, and reliable, but they differ when it comes to the speaker, the audience, and the word choice used throughout each text. “The Treaty Story” is an online interactive text meant for 6th grade students in Minneapolis Public Schools who are in the Minnesota history course; therefore the Minnesota Historical Society wrote it to be as unbiased as possible.…

    • 248 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    However, in Latin America and the Caribbean, this was not the case. Latin America and the Caribbean were ruled mostly by the Spanish and also by the Portuguese. Because the Spanish ideology was to separate those in power, there was discrimination between the populations. There was the social elite, spanish descendents, and those of mixed race (most commonly known as mestizo).…

    • 455 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Spanish sent over Conquistadors to the New World and their job was to capture the Indians and place them into hard labor so that they could send resources back to Spain to be sold. The surrounding area was filled with Indians because of the fertile lands. Shortly…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the time of the settlements in the New World, France was the latest country to begin to settle in North America. This gap between the British and Spaniards arriving and the French arriving gave them the opportunity to explore and claim more land before the French had even come to America. Also during the time that the French ventured over the seas their country was in turmoil. The French settlers also had few reasons to wish to travel to the colonies. Their colonial government was directly ruled by the King and the colonists gained neither personal representation nor trial by jury.…

    • 304 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In my opinion, the treaty of versai did cause the start if WWII. . • The treatie of versallie is a treatie that was signed in 1919, after World War I, hoping to bring an end to it. • The treatie was supposed to end it, but unluckily, it was the cause for World War II. • It placed a number of limitations on the people of Germany. • There were many settlements in the treaty, one of the main treaty was that Germany had to take blame for the war and make compensations to the members under Dawes Plan and Young Plan.…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the Spanish colonies, the settlers formed large-scale farms called plantations in the 1600’s that skyrocketed their economy and the demand in Europe. From the advancement of the plantations and the product of sugar, the industry proved highly successful considering the intensive work labor that was needed to run the plantations. The Spanish had to rely on the enslavement of indigenous people, they soon had to rely on African enslavement due to the decline of natives due to the hard labor in the plantations, to keep their business prosperous and maintained to aid the rising success of the Spanish economy. Unlike the Spanish, the Massachusetts Bay had fertile soil and prospered from the land. Considering the vast farmable land in the south that could be used for tobacco and other cash crops, the economy began to depend on subsistence farming where the people only grow enough for their own families which led to a tighter knit community in the New England towns.…

    • 1798 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Introduced to Brazil in 1532, Sugar replaced the country's first fundamental export, brazil wood, which turned into nearly worn out due to over-exploitation. Setting up his capital in Salvador, Tome de Sousa enlisted the aid of the Jesuits. The indigenous people that did not covert to Christianity were enslaved and sent to work in sugar plantations. Because of the excessive demand for sugar in Europe, sugar cane grown in engenhos (plantations) alongside the northeastern coast quickly became the base of the Brazilian economic system. Salvador and Olinda emerged as key centers for the sugar alternate.…

    • 139 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Furthermore, in 1519, Spanish-Bishop Juan de Quevedo declared all Native Americans being slaves by nature because they were inferior to society (Ojibwa). During European-Indian battles, Native Americans were frequently conquered because of their lack of advanced weaponry and manpower. This result yielded many war captives and consequently being forced into harsh labor. Europeans also enslaved many indigenous groups because it produced enormous wealth via the mid-Atlantic slave trade (McCarthy). Initially, explorers were not looking to build several colonies containing a surplus population, rather they wanted to extract wealth from lands they discovered (McCarthy).…

    • 1539 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    18th Century Brazil

    • 1631 Words
    • 7 Pages

    European countries through the Eighteenth century had become very dependent on their colonies in the Americas. Most of the colonies had the same situations, watched by the crown from across the sea, they were assets to a much more powerful master. Every colony in Latin America would eventually tire of being exploited, and would begin to revolt slowly relating to each other rather than their ancestry. One of the outliers in this process was Brazil, who experienced a much different road to independence. Portugal’s settlement of Brazil was different from the beginning, it had been settled slowly and Portugal was nowhere near the force that countries like Spain were at the time.…

    • 1631 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The English used these marriages as a way to get the natives to change their ways voluntarily by marrying into a Puritan community. Like the colonies’ views on intermarrying with the native tribes, the Spanish and English were also largely similar in terms of enslaving the native people. The Spanish were nearly completely reliant on slavery. In Spanish colonies, the encomienda system, forcing the Indians to work for and pay tribute to the Spanish in return for protection and entrance into heaven through conversion to Catholicism, were placed upon the natives.…

    • 2387 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The exploration and domination of the New World by the Spanish during the 15th and 16th century have been interpreted as the result of groups of bloodthirsty soldiers wanting nothing more than gold in their rucksacks and kill counts in their heads. As history has made clear, Spanish priests were also important historical actors during this age of discovery who made it their task to convert the natives to Catholicism. The conquering soldiers physically torn at the Natives while, at the same time, the priests harmed the natives spiritually. The importance of history is that we can learn from the past to aid our future. In other words, does the blindness of Spanish culture while regarding the Natives justify the physical, social and religious destruction they caused to the Natives?…

    • 1874 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    One reason for this was the enforcement of Spanish rule, and the dependency the conquest had on the Native peoples; Restall explains that “Spanish settlers depended upon native communities to build and sustain their colonies with tribute, produce and labor” (128). Being a conquistador meant striving to receive an encomienda, “a grant of native tribute and labor” - and this was the ultimate form of slavery for the Indigenous peoples. Furthermore, the second reason for the exploitation of the very victims of the Conquest was the need for survival; as Restall writes, “[Native peoples] tenaciously sought ways to continue local ways of life and improve the quality of life even in the face of colonial changes and challenges” (129). While it was common for Native peoples to demonstrate extreme resistance to the Spaniards when immediately encountered, there were other kinds of defensive strategies. One type of defensive strategy was done through the adaptation of Spanish culture as a way to ‘cover’ and preserve their original practices and systems.…

    • 1559 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays