Treasure Island Comparison Essay

Have you ever wondered what it would be like to be given the task of creating a thrilling film, attracting a modern audience, and based on an authentic story? That is the task that Disney filmmakers took on when producing Treasure Planet from the previously written Treasure Island. From the captivating storyline of Stevenson’s novel, Treasure Island, to the animated plot of Disney’s film, Treasure Planet, many intriguing comparisons can be made between the characters, themes, and settings. Throughout Treasure Island, character relationships and personalities are more deeply developed and explained. The themes and settings of Treasure Island are also more captivating due to the more descriptive and complex text. Although fundamentally based off similar foundations, the bountiful differences between the two pieces prove …show more content…
Countless discrepancies and correlations of character relationships and personalities between the two pieces must be recognized. Characters in Treasure Island tend to be more profoundly perplexing, a quality which often draws readers into the story. The character of Long John Silver in Treasure Island appears to be ruthless and utterly carefree, while also leading the reader to pity him at times. Though Silver executes himself as a superb man by initially gaining Trelawney’s trust in forming a crew, his true colors came to play when Jim heard Silver’s real plans about a mutiny. Being the most charismatic and cunning character in the story, Long John Silver’s role is vital in the ultimate downfall of the treasure quest. His physical disability (lack of one leg) showcases his powerful personality and ability to overcome many obstacles as they arise. Silver’s apparent rationality makes him a very dominant leader, while his persuasive confidence compels others to follow his lead. Long John Silver’s overall contradictory and materialistic behavior prove him to be the major antagonist throughout the development of