The Pros And Cons Of Transactional Leadership

Great Essays
Transactional leadership treats work as a transaction in order to let everyone knows where they stand. For instance, an employee agrees to perform specific tasks, if the employer agrees to pay the approximately equal wages. Those specific tasks can be evaluated by the established measurable criteria, if performance does not meet the expectations, the transaction (wages) can be negotiated. In other words, leaders have the leverage to fire or demote its follower. Likewise, a follower who meets or exceeds a leader’s expectations may also negotiate the transaction. This kind of leadership simplifies the way leader manage its business and eliminate the effects of emotion (Johnston, n.d.).
However, transactional leadership could seem to be impersonal,
…show more content…
As mentioned, since relationship developing does not fit well in the transactional model, leaders do not care whether their followers are satisfied as long as the task or performance is being done efficiently. Therefore, leaders should ensure followers at the time of achieving theirs’ objective, do not forced to violate the moral values, and at the same time adhere to the ethical standard of the organization. This is because leaders should have the initiative to guide theirs’ follower not to affect others interest while accomplishing their tasks and objective (Teck, …show more content…
First, one should take a position that values honesty and trust other than a position that shows dishonesty and trust. Second, one should adapt himself by taking indirect actions through relationships instead of direct actions through power. Third, one should create and retain harmony between both sides during conflict and negotiation session. Fourth, one should keep a balance between adjusting others, such as making the opponent to change, and adjusting self. For example, take the adapting actions to change accordingly situation in order to achieve win-win negotiation outcomes. If trust exists in conflict management, if decision makers are in conflicts take indirect actions through relationships instead of direct actions through power and try to create and retain harmony towards the parties and all the conflicts will be able to be solved peacefully with a win-win situations. Moreover, adjusting others and adjusting ourselves is the important implication in the balance in conflict management. For example, interacted with each other interdependently and coexist forever with the principle Ying and Yang.

Transformational Leadership
Although there is some transformational leadership research has taken place within workplace contexts (Barling et al., 2010), sports (Tucker, Turner, Barling, & McEvoy, 2010), and the military (Hardy et al.,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Management of the conflict is essential, and it is vital that each party involved maintains a balance among all forces, such as the gains and losses. In a destructive conflict, it would be beneficial for the parties to attempt to be more flexible and hear the interests of the other party involved. As long as both sides feel that the outcome is fair and benefits the both of them, then the situation can turn from a nonrealistic conflict to a realistic one. It is easy for a person to perceive a conflict as nonrealistic even if it is not. That is why it is important for all parties to manage their perceptions of the conflict and to communicate their perceived gains and losses with any given…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Negotiate Exchange Model

    • 1820 Words
    • 7 Pages

    We found this to become one of the main topics of a negotiated exchange. In this virtuous cycle stage is where we obtain outcomes. In the book it states, “Counteracting misperception and mistrust at the beginning of a negotiation can help negotiators avoid vicious cycles and sustain virtuous ones”. This important element not only allows us to put all of the issues aside and get down to the matters at hand, but also explains how to make a situation sustainable throughout the entire process. In a winning relationship between parties it is important to know each other’s triggers and to avoid them if possible.…

    • 1820 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    5.8. Conflict Management The link between task and relationship conflict is also affected by team members’ self-regulation tactics when they are confronted with conflicts. Team members can either follow a cooperative, competitive or avoiding approach. Team members that follow a cooperative approach believe that their goals are positively linked. This approach promotes mutual goals and resolves the conflict for mutual benefit.…

    • 2376 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is nothing wrong with having desires, but it is important to minimize your desires so you do not try to take control of things you have no control of in order to obtain that desire. It is in your best interest to desire things that are in your control. If you decide to dodge every unwanted assigned role then you will not be able to overcome destructive emotions when you come across a role you can not get out of. If you accept your role and play your role well then you can move on easily and happier after. You will not dwell on how bad the experience was but rather reflect on it and prepare yourself for your next assigned…

    • 1399 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. In this chapter leadership is described as non-coercive influence. For what reasons might followers be motivated to respond to a leadership initiative? Followers would me more motivated to response to a leadership initiative, if the leaders worked with the followers to achieve common goals. The main reason why coercive influence is a non-factor for leaders, is it uses threats and punishments to entice followers to work towards a goal, but does not include the leaders working with the followers to achieve the goals as a team.…

    • 1310 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why do you think empowerment is not as widely used as power or influence? Generally speaking, empowerment is not widely used due to organizations are not willing to take the chance (risk) to fail. Moreover, organizations prefer to delegate instead of empower because leaders get to keep the control, decision-making authority, and monitor closely the work environment. For the most part, organizations are not willing to give their followers the total control of their task because it could constitute to an irresponsible behavior. In fact, empowerment has been only used a strategy and not as a means to achieve success within the workplace.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    As leaders, we should evaluate each situation not only on its own merit but also against how it would fit into the organization’s own values. In addition, have the courage to stay with your instincts, beliefs, while examining all perspectives, as well as point of views to reach a fair, and ethical decision. Moreover, we need to have the ability to think outside the box, and steer away from our biases, and use active listening skills so that a wrong decision does not to impact anyone negatively. It may appear to be difficult at first, but taking an easy path to avoid altercations could put a lot at stake. Thinking through new, more, and fresh ideas will help to look at the bigger picture, and in return reach a solid decision that has less room for errors, a failure that we may regret later.…

    • 1416 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    360° Leadership

    • 1587 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Finding a common ground amongst leaders at the same level can result in some excellent opportunities for an organization. Building relationships with trust and credibility are crucial when leading down. Others won’t follow a leader that doesn’t do what they say they will do. Leading by example…

    • 1587 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    (BATNA -Best Alternative To a Negotiated Agreement) here is some idea of how to develop BATNA in every negotiation: ♣ Create a backup list of actions you might possibly take if no agreement is reached. ♣ Develop some of the encouraging ideas and adapt them into practical alternatives. ♣ Tentatively selecting the alternative that seems best for both to agree on. ♣ Acknowledge the other side's…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As a virtuous leader, they must be willing to be decisive when making choices and also must be willing to accept the cost or choose an unpopular choice as long as it still satisfies the human and humane need for proper order. When discussing about the application of virtuous leadership, it also acts as the function of institution similar to election or civil service…

    • 1624 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays