Tragic Flaw In Julius Caesar

Decent Essays
Flawed But Not Forgotten Every human has a flaw, but some can be the cause of their own demise. The flaw of Marcus Brutus in The Tragedy of Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare causes his own downfall as the tragedy unravels. Brutus is the tragic hero because he has all of the necessary traits a tragic hero needs, according to Aristotle. Aristotle defines a tragic hero as a man of noble stature or high position who causes his own destruction for a greater cause or principle. A flaw cannot be escaped, and Brutus discovers this the hard way. According to Aristotle’s definition of a tragic hero, Brutus is the tragic hero in The Tragedy of Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare because he follows the five traits of a tragic hero which are noble …show more content…
Brutus’ tragic flaw is his loyalty to Rome, which comes from his lineage in Rome. He is too worried about doing what he thinks is right for Rome and the people of Rome that he becomes blindsided by all of the other things happening. The loyalty Brutus has to Rome leads him to killing Caesar. Caesar is destroying Rome right before his eyes and Brutus cannot just stand back and watch, but he is not quite sure what to do. Since Brutus has these conflicting thoughts, Cassius is able to successfully persuade Brutus into joining the conspirators. During Cassius’ speech, he offers to Brutus, “I have heard / Where many of the best respect in Rome / (Except immortal Caesar), speaking of Brutus” (I.ii.58-60). These words of Cassius sway Brutus’ mind and he begins to think that killing Caesar is the right thing. Killing Caesar starts a chain reaction, and eventually leads to Brutus taking his own life. Later in the play when Cassius suggests killing Antony as well, Brutus denies his request. Noble Brutus replies upon Cassius’ request, “Our course will seem too bloody, Caius Cassius” (II.i.162). Antony’s murder would cause the Romans to further lose trust in Brutus. Caesar and all relations to him being destroyed would cause Rome to think less of Brutus. This loyalty to Rome is Brutus’ tragic flaw that leads to the downfall of Brutus, the tragic …show more content…
Brutus follows this trait because his death evokes pity from the audience. His death is a symbol of him letting go because the guilt was too overwhelming. The last words of Brutus were, “Caesar, now be still; / I killed not thee with half so good a will” (V.v.50-1). These final words create a feeling of pity and sympathy from the audience. Antony cares about Brutus and how his fate turns out even though Antony is one of Brutus’ biggest enemies. This death not only evokes pity from the audience, but from his own enemies as well. Upon Brutus’ death Antony exclaims, “And say to all the word ‘This was a man’” (V.v.75). At one point Antony had wanted the most revenge on Brutus, but he has always believed that Brutus truly did have good intentions. A simple mistake that Brutus could not take back caused his own downfall. Catharsis is shown through Brutus’ death which makes him the tragic hero, according to Aristotle’s

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Shakespeare incorporates the idea of a tragic hero throughout the play. In this case the tragic hero is Marcus Brutus. Marcus Brutus is a tragic hero because he has gone through a catastrophe which is when he realized the conspirators killed Caesar for the wrong reasons and that he being such a noble person has gotten involved with so many bad people. Another reason he is a tragic hero is because of his ancestor Junius Brutus. Finally Marcus Brutus is a tragic hero because of his tragic flaw which is idealism, his idea of making Rome perfect.…

    • 1684 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Multiple plays by Julius Caesar feature a tragic hero, and in Julius Caesar that tragic hero is Brutus. Aristotle wrote that a tragic hero is a person of nobility who suffers misfortune or defeat due to a flaw or weakness in their personality. From the play there is obvious evidence that Brutus suffers misfortune due to the death of Caesar. Said act was commuted because Brutus is extremely naive. More than once the story conveys Brutus as someone who believes people without question.…

    • 1218 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Marcus Brutus has the tragic flaw of having poor judgment, because he so easily trusts people, such as the conspirators consequently causing Marcus to be ignorant and blind to the fact that they were planning to kill Caesar, not to better the government but for personal gain. If Marcus Brutus, would not have as much pride and patriotism for Rome then, he would not have decided to join and trust the conspirators in their quest to kill Caesar. With all of his pride for the democracy, he puts his country over his friends and family. He honestly suspected that Caesar would do harm to Rome’s new republic. So he went along with the conspiracy to assassinate Caesar.…

    • 1701 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This is key as Antony after all was the person who changed the perception of the Romans about Brutus’s righteousness after Cesar’s assassination. Brutus centers his entire world on the virtue of righteousness. Brutus’s morals, however, put him in a position where his projected character hinders him. This results in the eventual demise of Rome and ultimately himself. In Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, Brutus’ personality causes his ruin.…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Brutus: A Tragic Hero

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages

    One tragic recognition Brutus has is that he acts rashly about killing Caesar. Brutus thinks the conspirators act rashly when they kill Caesar because they do not know how Caesar would act if he would become king because he never because king. They just act out of pure impulsive and do not think through their actions and this is the part that troubles Brutus no taking a step back and instead just going for it. A second tragic recognition Brutus has is he realizes that his great friendship with Cassius is gone. Brutus realizes this because when Cassius comes into his tent they start to fight about stuff because Cassius is taking bribes.…

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    There are many great examples of this throughout the entirety of the play. Almost every decision Marcus Brutus makes during the play has an affect on him later on. For example, when he has the opportunity to kill Antony along with Caesar, he doesn’t seize it. Brutus said, “ For antony is but a lim of Caesar, let’s be sacrificers, but not butchers… and in the spirit of men there is no blood.” (II.i.165-168). He makes another choice that has a negative outcome, Brutus decides to let Antony speak at the funeral for Caesar.…

    • 1235 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Brutus is willing to fight without truly knowing what he is up against, because his loyalty told him that Antony is a tyrant and must be removed from Rome; consequently his slavery of loyalty to Rome is leading him into a fight that will get him killed. So now that he has made the decision to fight, he decides to make this formal as possible and so he says, “Words before blows; is it so countrymen?” (V. i. 27). In short, what this means is that the two opposing sides are going to smack talk before the fight begins. He is so blinded by loyalty that he cannot discern how deep he is in over his head.…

    • 1440 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    By saying that, Cassius reminded Brutus that he is noble and the people of Rome look up to, not only Caesar, but him as well. He made Brutus aware of how much he meant to Rome and that some of the people wanted him as a leader too. His tragic flaw is poor judgement, and he is easily manipulated into doing things that might not be right. When he made his decision to kill Caesar he did not really want to do it, but the conspirators quickly and easily changed his mind. The people of Rome were shocked when Brutus and the conspirators took action and killed Caesar.…

    • 490 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I think he meant that he was scared a lot of people wanted Caesar to be king, and that was going to make Rome, suffer. That's the whole reason why Brutus was making that extremely hard decision in the first place. So you can´t blame Brutus for being scared that Caesar would be in favor for the commoners. Also Brutus made that remark before his decision was finalized to kill Caesar. Brutus planned to kill Caesar then went back on his decision, because he thought he was going to make the wrong decision, but finally decided that it was best for Caesar to go.…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It is hard for him to kill his close friend. How he can go through all of his emotions to stab Caesar is astounding. Brutus cries for Caesar, feels pity for him, and it breaks his heart, but nobody sees his pain. Cassius takes advantage of Brutus’s love for Rome, and this results in Brutus’s role as a tragic hero. Cassius challenges Brutus’s faith in Caesar by saying that Brutus can be a better king.…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays