The Toulmin Method

Superior Essays
Writing a written argument is an act which many people recommend you master. The Toulmin method facilitates the way one analyzes an argument. Stephen Toulmin gives us the basics to this method which allows many people to respond to the argument given and also leads one to improve the argument made. Toulmin’s method invites one to examine the claim, reasons, qualifiers, evidence, warrant backing, rebuttals for any counter-arguments, and exceptions of an argument to decide the effectiveness of an argument. In the article titled “The Locavore Myth: Why buying from nearby farmers won’t save the planet,” James McWilliams argues that although the Locavore movement has brought attention to industrialized food, the movement does not prevent damage …show more content…
The different parts that are necessary for a successful argument are used and therefore makes McWilliams argument a success. Some of the main parts that make up an argument are the claim, the use of qualifiers and evidence that the author makes. Without the claim, the writer has nothing to debate about and the argument would be over before it even started. McWilliams’ claim is that the Locavore movement is not completely protecting and saving the earth because it does not take into account the other factors that use energy and contribute to the ruin of the earth. The author leads the reader to think that he will be writing on ALL the “other energy-hogging factors in food production.” The way McWilliams phrases his claim lets the reader know how far he is willing to go to prove his assertion. Qualifiers are another part of the Toulmin method that helps strengthen the argument. Notice how McWilliams uses the phrase “a lot of them” when referring to the fans of the locavore movement that are “making a big mistake”. If McWilliams used the phrase “all of them” he would have allowed opportunities for others to oppose his argument. Using qualifiers make it more manageable and easier to defend ones position because they prevent disputes from those who …show more content…
This chain of reasoning that connects the reason to the claim is known as the warrant. McWilliams does this by keeping in mind that “water usage, fertilizer types, processing methods and packaging techniques” and ” far outweighs the energy it takes to transport food”. McWilliams reasons that because all of these other factors also contribute to the problems of the food industry, food miles are not the only component that make up and add to these problems. In order to back up his warrant McWilliams uses the analysis done by Rich Pirog of the Leopold Center for Sustainable Agriculture. The analysis shows “that transportation accounts for only eleven percent of foods carbon footprint” which makes his warrant credible by using

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Changing human diet can be a controversial topic and to change this omnivore’s mind one needs to present facts as cold as a fresh cut of meat. Marjorie Lee Garretson’s “More Pros Than Cons in a Meat-Free Life” is an essay that tries to persuade the reader to a vegan lifestyle under the guise of vegetarianism using few cited sources and trying to make the reader feel bad about the way they currently eat. “More Pros Than Cons in a Meat-Free Life” is a college level essay written by Marjorie Lee Garretson about the potential positives to vegetarian lifestyle. The essay first focuses on the health benefits of switching to vegetarianism which is done in three sentences claiming decreased cancer rates and longer life expectancy without any…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Despite its publication more than a decade ago, Pollan’s argument remains relevant today as the globe struggles to find the best balance between accessible or healthy food and efficient or moral food production methods. Regardless of what course the food industry will decide to take, the power it holds over society and our future is…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While there are room for improvements in her writing, Spriggs authoritative tone, logical rebuttals, and appropriately addressed counter arguments prove to make her essay an effective piece for persuading those who may have not followed her same belief system. Furthermore, with the organization of her writing, it's easy for readers to follow her argument from beginning to end, summarizing information and discovering a clear point as to what she wants her audience to think and do. Although some people may still have doubts on the benefits of buying local after reading Spriggs essay, the current push in America towards a greener, more sustainable way of living will eventually prevail. Consequently, this will cause the current way of large-scale monoculture farming to fall out of favor to the healthier, more sustainable way of local…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Michael Pollan's piece “Big Food Strikes Back” in October 9, 2016 The New York Times Magazine begins with critique of a lack of the discussion about food system during 2008 U.S. presidential campaigns. Nevertheless, the food topic—being multi-dimensional—is inevitably a part of a larger, and more discussed, themes such as public health, climate change, and nation's' energy requirements, to name a few. Furthermore, the author in this article pinpoints the U.S. food systems' problems. The production of monocrops, which are subsidized by the government, result in high emissivity of the greenhouse gasses and have shown a negative impact on public health and ecology.…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Praise Of Fast Food

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1. The title, "In Praise of Fast Food", made me think it was going to be a defense of fast food restaurants like McDonald's and Burger King. Instead, the essay talks more about the distinction between 'natural' and 'artificial' foods, and how natural isn't always better. It's a confusing title, but it does evoke the idea that even Big Macs and chicken nuggets are still better than going hungry like our ancestors did. 2.…

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From being named on Time Magazine’s top 100 Most Influential People in 2010 to writing many books about food and eating Michael Pollen goes on to explain how to escape the Western Diet in his essay “Escape from the Western Diet”. Pollen points out how the food and health industries impact peoples diets, how to escape the Western Diet and the 3 rules he proposes. Pollen has many great points but lacks convincing evidence in many of his arguments. Although Michael Pollen lacks some strong evidence he is still able to lure the readers in with solid points such as the two industries, so therefore making his argument somewhat convincing to the readers. Pollan succeeds in pointing out how industries should be blamed for people not being able to…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The fact of the matter is, the locavore movement does not account for the fact that the production of foods, such as red meat and dairy products, is the main culprit regarding greenhouse gas emissions, not transportation (Source D). It falls to the community to make the choice between food from down the road that isn’t produced with sustainability in mind or food from another country that is. While this moral issue doesn’t necessarily help or hurt a community, it does impact its very soul. When choosing to become a locavore, a person has committed themselves to not just supporting local producers, but also to helping the planet. If this community truly is committed to becoming locavores, they must evaluate the carbon footprint of their locally grown food to stay true to the movement’s ideals.…

    • 1212 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although it is not in the actual reading his argument does not lack credibility. “Bryan Walsh is now a staff writer for the magazine, specializing in environmental issues” (Swift 469). He also refers to other credible sources as well. “A study in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition found that a dollar could buy 1,200 calories of potato chips or 875 calories of soda” shows another credible source (Swift 471). Although he did not lack credibility it was not his strongest point.…

    • 539 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a society we have seen more muckrakers emerge since Upton Sinclair than ever before. The Jungle was only the beginning of an exposé on the food industry that is still relevant today. Great writers and journalists continue to try and educate the public on just where their food is coming from. Michael Pollan presents the reader with his own work of food journalism in the form of Omnivore’s Dilemma, in which he defines industrial logic and how this idea motivates industry to produce the food we receive today, then offers the alternative of local food chains to combat the distrust in supermarkets. Industrial logic is the force that persuades the agriculture market to transform into one that relies increasingly on industrial means to mass produce…

    • 1772 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Diet Argument Analysis

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Even though, it would be smart to ban these foods, people would be overall healthier and the country would be better. This argumentative passage at least makes citizens more conscious of what they eat and should keep these ideas in mind even if the decision doesn’t take place. It worked for me and the people I know that read these passages. The choice to shut down and get rid of big soda makes sense and is smart for New York because their citizens are probably one of the biggest targets in the “need of dieting” community.…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Locavore Synthesis Essay

    • 446 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Locavore movements have become the new craze of the past decade. Consequently, locavores have helped improve the environment within communities and the economy of the small farm industry, but the nutritional value hasn’t improved like people want it to. Becoming a part of the locavore movement can help the environment tremendously in many different ways. “Eating local is better for air quality and pollution…”(Source A) Travel time is cut which is less pollution from the trucks that transport the goods. The travel time usually outweighs the purpose of buying organic foods since the air is not benefitting from it.…

    • 446 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A. In Michael Pollan’s informative novel, The Omnivore’s Dilemma, the author encourages the idea that food has a greater role than just filling our stomachs. He does this by informing the readers about each of the aspects in which food contributes to, such as environmental and even political roles. In doing so, Pollan separates his novel into sections; each diving deeper into an idea that some may glance over. The author, using these sections consisting of the industrial, organic, and hunting-gathering food chains, discuss the dilemma humans must face when picking their meals.…

    • 981 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    His data and opinion are stepping stone for ethos as he express himself as a well research individual. The evidences although abundance are not convincing. The present of evidences pose many hole in his argument. For instance his data are every energy consumption, so even if food is brought local or national the amount of energy spent is still the same. Thus, His argument also point to one weakness of the opposition and only focus on it.…

    • 1479 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    According to the World Health Organization, “Every year, one out of six people get sick, 128,000 are hospitalized and 3,000 Americans die from foodborne illnesses.” About 80 percent of all cases of heart disease, strokes and Type 2 diabetes could be prevented if people ate healthier and were more physically active. In the article “Unhappy Meals” by Michael Pollan, the author tries to give advice on how to prevent such illnesses. He argues, how if everyone would “Eat food. Not too much.…

    • 1362 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Nowadays, we think that much of our fresh foods and produce come directly from supermarkets since we directly buy it from them. But what we don’t see is the amount of transportation it takes for the food to get there, how much water and land it takes to make the food, and even where it comes from. Just like how supermarkets create such illusions of abundance and variety, the foods we consume everyday hide many environmental and health related effects right in front of our faces. Convenient foods often contain wasteful plastic packaging that end up polluting the environment. Foods that contain meat, dairy, or eggs are our daily staple, but it requires more energy to produce these foods because of trophic level efficiency (Porter, 2003, pp.4-5).…

    • 2013 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays