Top Girls Analysis

Great Essays
How do Churchill and Angelis present the characters in Top Girls to examine the struggles for women in the historical context in which they are set. Remember to present alternative viewpoints in your answer and to examine the aspects of dramatic presentation and stagecraft in your textual study.

Top Girls by Caryl Churchill, written in 1982 and Playhouse Creatures by April De Angelis, written in 1993, are two congruent texts which delve into the ongoing war for women battling against the system of injustice. Both texts share a prevailing motif and exposes the struggle of what it would take to be a successful women, as well as demonstrating the immense maltreatment of women and whether or not it can be explained by the time period.

Top Girls
…show more content…
An obvious example is Pope Joan, who pretended to be a man in order to gain her title and as a result, was “dragged out of town” and “stoned to death”. Churchill effectively used the dialect of Pope Joan to mirror the mindset of people at the time. The fact that she was “stoned” for being a woman showcases the bigoted views that many people held, that she would not be accepted for simply being a woman and so had to give up her female body in order to 'succeed' in her time. A connection can be made with Mrs Marshall in Playhouse Creatures as misogyny exists in both texts and both women face many struggles at the hands of men. Mrs Marshall is often disrespected and never taken seriously; for instance, the Earl of Oxford once called her a “Filthy Whore” to embarrass her and cause trouble for her. By showing someone such as an Earl insulting and degrading the women, the women’s position in society during the era of Restoration and the Earl’s superior social position is highlighted. By using the vulgar words to describe the women, the Earl’s superior social position is contributing to the suppression of women and emphasising the idea that women can simply suffer at the hands of language. An alternative …show more content…
Churchill presented Joyce and Angie’s thoughts and feelings through their dialect and the way they communicate with themselves. For example, Joyce, a particularly unsympathetic character, once refers to Angie, a low achiever, as a “fucking rotten little cunt”, representing the perspective of the working class and showing the underside of Marlene’s “Top Girls” success; for there to be a ‘top’ there must be a ‘bottom’. The use of language in Top Girls is used as an indicator of class status and hierarchy. Women who work at Top Girls – Nell, Win, and Marlene – all speak in a casual and elegant manner that suits them in their competitive circle of professional women. Whereas Joyce and Angie use curse-laden and harsh language to address each other, highlighting their working class status. Both texts are non-linear, with Top Girls being in non-chronological order where the climax reveals the adversities faced by Marlene in order to get where she is. Playhouse Creatures is structured in the way that the prologue is meant to be epilogue. Angelis did this so the audience can be left waiting in

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Misogyny In Hamlet

    • 1032 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the play he designed a character, which represented his mother, to act like a terrible person and a harlot. Hamlets mother was appalled by what she witnessed. The way Hamlet had his mother portrayed should express to the audience his hatred he has towards his mom at least. Hamlet gets aggressive with his mother when he tells her that she sleeps with a murderer and he gets rough with her too. Hamlet calls her a bad mother and a whore.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is imperative to understand the degree of the mistreatment of women to acknowledge literature of the debilitation of female characters in Wuthering Heights and The Rainbow (Juan 25). Women’s rights scarcely existed and despite those men guaranteed to treat them with “substance and liberality” (Juan 25-26), they were rejected from any domestic authority. In Wuthering Heights, the female characters are influential and determined. They are unpredictable, passionate and villainous, and violent. Catherine is destructive, determined and strong- willed woman.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both of these men became so infatuated with their consorts they forgot to run their dynasties and in turn, their empires collapsed. This shows that no matter what kind of man you were, or how much power you possessed, you were not safe from women who wanted to be independent and take anything that they could. We see that Yingying knows the difference between right and wrong when she says, “So finally I composed those vulgar lines to make sure you would come here. It was an improper thing to do, and of course I feel ashamed…” (pg 70). Yingying knows what her role as a woman is and she admits that she did something wrong, and feels bad because of it.…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    … must, like a whore, unpack my heart with words and fall a-cursing like a very drab, a scullion! Fie upon ’t, foh!” (2.2.545-50) By using the word “whore” “drab” and “scullion” William Shakespeare shows Hamlet discriminates against women based on what they have done in the society at that time and how angry he is, when he recognizes he does nothing for his revenge. Hamlet seems to think that not avenging his father 's murder makes him a coward and, therefore, like a woman—and not a nice, respectable woman: a "whore," a "drab," and a "scullion." Similarly, Polonius has the…

    • 1348 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Clytemnestra is a liar and a two timing cheater so are her words true of just a ruse for the audience. Women from this play are misunderstood and are no different than the men. The men are able to break whatever moral laws they prefer and if a women is to do the same she is shunned from society. Clytemnestra committed adultery for the reason of being alone for over a decade and in return Agamemnon was committing the same acts with Cassandra. The death of her daughter caused a fire to light inside Clytemnestra and she killed her husband for his actions.…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Regan, more so than Goneril, loses her morals while in a blood lust search for power. Malicious orders given by Regan such as the order given to have Kent put in the stocks as well as the order given to have Gloucester’s eyes ripped out, is where the lack of Regan’s morals show through. The orders given by Regan stem from the corruption of power and in turn, affect her morals. Traditional gender roles of women are once again challenged through these vicious acts. Regan opposes the orthodox gender roles by representing a more independent and cruel female role.…

    • 1584 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Power Her Face Analysis

    • 2251 Words
    • 10 Pages

    All people cared were beauty, but they criticized the female characteristics they chased at the same time. “ These texts abound with expressions of physical horror at the uncleanliness of women, and denounce the use of cosmetics and wigs as metaphoric disguises hiving women’s inconstancy and duplicity.” (Opera Under the Old Regime) The conservative writers in seventeenth- century France agreed that the moral of women were degenerating and disagreed with any arguments disputing male power. In “Power Her Face”, the madness and manager were talking about should the duke to divorce his wife, and the question has already put in a patriarchal context. It is not about how the duke should divorce her husband, or should both of them divorce one other. In the opera, the duchess randomly had sex with home service or hotel worker and paid them to satisfy her sexual desires, acting just like a man in brothel.…

    • 2251 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The world is witness, in every century women emancipate prove her identity in the society and before the men. Time to time women fight for liberation and exploitation. A Rajasthani regional writer discusses about the identity of a woman; a girl asks her father what the identity of a women. He replies, the identity of a women comes after her marry. Thus, therefore the problems of women are the central theme of maximum woman writers.…

    • 1423 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    She is incredibly influenced by the belief created by systematic oppression. Her dependance on wealth caused her to end up losing all affection towards her husband, George, and led her towards her toxic relationship with Tom. As Ivan Strba said in “Emancipated Women of The Great Gatsby”, “She desires Tom because of his bulky masculinity and his social style, and in a way her sexuality is a counterpart of Gatsby’s romantic passion for Daisy” (Strba 43) Tom physically abused her, using his power to take complete control. “Making a short deft movement Tom Buchanan broke her nose with an open hand. Then there were bloody towels upon the bathroom floor, and women’s voices scolding, and high over the confusion a long broken wail of pain.” (Fizgerald…

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many women face battles all throughout their lives, but the question they should ask themselves would be; how could you let your battles you’ve overpowered affect you in your present and your future life. As women, we have tended to let society mold us, and shape us cumulatively over the past few years. Society has this tight grip on our minds, making us question if we are ever good enough. Women cannot let society have that hold on them. In a poem written my Maya Angelou, she reminds women they too are a phenomenal woman.…

    • 1234 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays