To Kill A Mockingbird Movie Comparison

Improved Essays
To Re-Make a Movie

If a newer film adaption of To Kill A Mockingbird were created, it would need to include many of the characters/scenes that were left out of the first film. Aunt Alexandra, Dolphus Raymond, and the Finch’s Landing are some of the main points of the novel that were left out of the first movie. Although, one may argue that these characters/scenes were left out of the first film adaption because they are unimportant, provide no lessons, and are useless towards the plot. But in truth, Aunt Alexandra and Dolphus Raymond are both characters that symbolize great lessons and would make the movie more intense. As for the Finch’s Landing, if the audience wants intensity, Scout walloping the big mouthed Cousin Francis will definitely
…show more content…
Aunt Alexandra symbolizes a typical Southern woman at the time and really shows what people thought and acted like back in the 1930’s. At the beginning of Aunt Alexandra’s stay in Maycomb, she did not appreciate Atticus talking regularly around Calpurnia, and claimed “I don’t think it’s a good habit, Atticus. It encourages them. You know how they talk among themselves. Everything that happens in this town’s out to the Quarters before sundown”(157). Clearly, Aunt Alexandra is extremely racist and even refers to the black community as the quarters which is short for slave quarters where the slaves were forced to stay. She is also saying that black people such as Calpurnia gossip a lot and that black people cannot be trusted. Including this scene would show the viewers exactly how the typical Southern lady acted and thought. One might argue that adding Aunt Alexandra would be useless because the audience already gets a sense of the racism towards blacks, and she teaches no lessons throughout the whole novel. This is very inaccurate because not only does Aunt Alexandra provide a great example of the regular white person at the time but she is also a vital part in the lesson, “you can never judge someone until you walk around in their shoes”. At the beginning of the novel Aunt Alexandra seemed very stern, bossy, and unfair, but during the missionary …show more content…
With the presence of Dolphus Raymond, the audience would get a sense of how scandalous an interracial relationship was, and how frowned upon it was for whites to live with blacks, at that time in history. The fact that Mr. Raymond had to pretend to be an alcoholic is a great example of the extreme measures people had to take to be in a interracial relationship. Dolphus explains, “When I come to town, which is seldom, if I weave a little and drink out of this sack, folks can say Dolphus Raymond’s in the clutches of whiskey- that’s why he won’t change his ways. He can’t help himself, that’s why he lives the way he does.” (200). Some may argue that adding Dolphus Raymond into the movie would take away from the racial intensity and theme of the story. However, Dolphus Raymond explains that he prefers blacks and claims “I live like I do because that’s the way I want to live”(201). In the time period of the novel, nothing was considered lower than a white man having children with a black woman, so if racial intensity is what the movie needs, the presence of Dolphus Raymond should do just

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The movie To Kill a Mockingbird, based on the novel written by Harper Lee showed the life of a child during the Great Depression and captured the theme of innocence taken away by evil. In most cases the book is always better than the film because life lessons are taken away in greater detail and are much easier to apply to a reader's life. Many movies stray from the book as did To Kill a Mockingbird, but also captured the scenes not shown in the book. Unlike the book, the movie had taken away the relationship that Boo Radley had with the children. One part of the book which was not shown in the movie was Mrs. Maudie's house fire when Boo Radley had draped a blanket over Scout’s shoulders while Jem and Scout were standing in the cold.…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Without a doubt, Alexandra is a conformist as she attempts to turn Scout into a feminine woman, which was standard for the time. Not to mention, Alexandra is a racist. She is constantly complaining about how Atticus is ruining the family name because he took the Tom Robinson case. Alexandra also tries to convince Atticus to get rid of Calpurnia. Alexandra cannot be blamed for her racist mindset because that was customary at…

    • 1332 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She is also starting to realize that scout is not going to conform to her feminine ways and when scout gets into trouble she sees how it important for scout to be herself. “Aunt Alexandra's fingers trembled as she unwound the fabric and wire from around me. ”are you okay darling?” she asked as she worked me free.” (291) she shows that she is worried about scout.…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By the end of the story “To Kill a Mockingbird”, Aunt Alexandra had changed significantly. She has realized that the way Atticus’s kids were raised was well enough to survive and right after all. She witnessed this when Bob Ewell attacked Scout and Jem. She heard of the siblings protecting each other against the brutal attack by pulling Bob off of each other. She later learns to accept the way people do things such as raising their kids(as her brother Atticus has) and how people feel or how they do things like with Cuprina.…

    • 625 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This differs in To Kill a Mockingbird in such that Aunt Alexandra bosses around scout to help her grow up the best she can be. For example, “Aunt Alexandra met us and nearly fainted when Calpurnia told where we were” (Lee 282). This highlights the fact that Aunt Alexandra genuinely cares about the kids and the things she does is out of love. She shows that being a lady means being respectful unlike Hilly. The role of women is shown very differently in these two pieces of literature.…

    • 524 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When the death of Tom Robinson is announced Scout sees how devastated Aunt Alexandra becomes. To Aunt Alexandra this case is wearing down both the family and Atticus, “tearing him to pieces” as she stated. But even through those dark times, Alexandra still holds her head high as she face the group of judgmental ladies of Maycomb to continue her tea party. “Aunt Alexandra looked across the room at me and smiled. She looked at the tray of cookies on the table and nodded at them.…

    • 1493 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dolphus Raymond is a man who breaks common stereotypes by assuming the pretense and character of one in order to slip under the radar of the other townspeople. While most of Maycomb views him as the drunk that lives with the black people, in reality, Dolphus drinks not alcohol, but merely coca-cola. He confesses this to Scout: “Secretly, Miss Finch, I’m not much of a drinker, but you see they could never, never understand that I live like I do because that’s the way I want to live” (Lee 200-201). This shows that what is most outwardly transparent and unlikable in a character may truly be interesting and good-natured. In Maycomb’s society, white men do not usually associate with colored people, let alone live with them.…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “It is not our differences that divide us, it is our inability to recognize, accept, and celebrate those differences,” said Audre Lorde, a Caribbean-American writer, and civil rights activist. In this quote she is saying that if we just agreed that we are different, and we won’t alway get along, then the world would be a more peaceful place. Even in today’s society people are pulled apart from others because of their differences. Even so the society today is better than it was during times like America in the 1930’s, on the Indian reservations, and in Europe between Jews and Christians.…

    • 2223 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Black lives matter, in these two films To Kill a Mockingbird and 12 Angry Men we learn that we need to stand up for what we believe in and take action. Atticus is in To Kill a Mockingbird and Juror eight is in 12 angry men and they have the same personalities in their films. The comparison here is Atticus from To Kill a Mockingbird and Juror 8 from 12 Angry Men. Juror eight was very determined and compassionate about the case. Juror 8 acted as if he knew he was correct but did not have much evidence to back himself up, he stood up for himself based on reasonable doubt.…

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The missionary meeting was a turning point in Aunt Alexandra’s demeanor towards all others. She, “Smiled brilliantly. ‘Stay with us, Jean Louise,’ she said.” (p. 307). Even though Aunt Alexandra was only doing this to change Scout, it was different from how Scout was treated before.…

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages
    • 1 Works Cited
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Discrimination is a huge problem in our society and happens almost everywhere still to this day. Statistics of discrimination say that racism hurts chances for Americans and many more races. Discrimination is so extreme that people will even be denied for jobs they apply for because of their race. In To Kill a Mockingbird and The Help there are many ways that discrimination is showcased, especially between the blacks and whites. To Kill a Mockingbird has racism in many ways especially in the Tom Robinson case which has a devastating ending.…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Alexandra ploys to make Scout more ' Lady like ' and berating Scout for not wanting to wear dresses makes Scout grow to dislike her Aunt. While Atticus worked on the Tom Robinson case Alexandra comes to Maycomb to live with Scout and Jem to provide a 'feminine influence '. Aunt Alexandra, along with the rest of the Finch Household does not approve of Atticus defending a Tom Robinson, a black man. As the Tom Robinson case goes on Alexandra sees how passionate Atticus is about giving Tom a fair trial . When Tom Robinson is found guilty Alexandra notices the effects of racism and how much it bothers her nephew.…

    • 1168 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Alexandra is having a missionary circle meeting because she is very gregarious. Atticus calls her aside to tell her that Tom Robinson has been killed. After Atticus tells Aunt Alexandra the news, Scout determines “if Aunty could be a lady at a time like this, so could [she]” (Lee 318). Scout learns that she can act like a lady. She determines this because Aunt Alexandra maintains her composure even though a drastic event has occurred.…

    • 1184 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Comparative essay The main idea of To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee is that picking on people who are helpless and have not done anything wrong or caused harm is a terrible thing. Whereas The Help directed by Tate Taylor is about racial prejudice and the hate directed toward blacks in respect to their race. Each story has a distinctive storyline but both share similar features and themes. For example both stories are set in the South during times of segregation.…

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The fight for equality has been going on for hundreds of years; A Time to Kill and To Kill a Mockingbird are both examples of black men facing trial during different time periods. This is not the end of the similarities between the two. There are several reasons that To Kill a Mockingbird and A Time to Kill are both famous, critically-acclaimed stories about justice; these reasons make them fairly similar films. They each stand out because of their differences. These films have similar themes and plots, however, their differences allow them to both be important and powerful in a unique way.…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays