Analysis Of Bennett's Essay 'To Be A Man'

Improved Essays
To Be a Man, or Not To Be a Man, That Is the Question In the featured text The Book of Man, the author William J. Bennett, explains his opinion about what a man should be and how a man should live. According to Bennett, man’s role in today’s society is being distorted. The author claims that the lack of foundation in religion makes men become less moral than they used to be, and this may be the reason why gays flaunt their sexuality challenging traditional masculinity. Avoiding the traditional composition of family provided by religion; along with the feminist revolution and women’s empowerment means that women are replacing men in the workforce. This could be a cause of the high rate of unemployed men; furthermore, the author suggests that …show more content…
When Kimmel discusses in his essay, “Bros Before Hos”, how a man should act to get in the “Be a man” box, he classifies the gentleman’s behavior as a gay stereotype. He states that “Never listen to a thing a woman is saying, but express immediate and unquenchable sexual interest. Presto, you’re a real man, back in the “Be a Man’ box.” (467). In this part of his essay, he is speaking specifically about how certain good attitudes are perceived as gay and do not represent manhood. William Bennett would find irony in this statement because it is mainly men who have to show respect and do not take advantage of women. Bennett would think that Kimmel diminishes the role and responsibility that men have with women. Bennett’s opinion of women is not sexist; furthermore, he considers the importance of gender relationship. Bennett in his book says “men do not take advantage of women” (XXI); in addition, In his book he describes the treatment that a man should give to a woman by saying “The Fifth chapter, “Man with Women and Children,” illuminates in important ways that how a man treats a woman and how well he fathers his children constitute the essence of manhood” (XXIV). Here Bennett emphasizes the importance of how to be a gentleman is a synonym of manhood. In addition to Bennett’s disapproval of Kimmel’s opinion about men’s attitude towards women, he would also think that he is mistaken by thinking that there is only one code that could completely describe

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In The Other Wes Moore author Wes Moore unravels how the other Wes and his fate diverged. Wes#1 and Wes#2 narrate pivotal life events that teach them how to become a man and use the skills they acquire to survive poverty and manhood. Growing up in poverty without a father, as well as, learning to become a man is harsh when one does not have a father figure to look up to and a loving family that encourages success. In order, for both Wes Moores’ to be successful they need parental guidance, self-discipline, and positive mentors.…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This article does not personally relate to me given the fact that I did not grow up with brothers or a prominent father figure, but I was interested in it because I never got to see how males communicate with each other up close. Guy Code, put into its simplest definition is, “the collection of attitude, values, and traits that together compose what it means to be a man,” said Kimmel. This article showed me how men and boys interact with each other differently than how my sisters and I and my friends did growing up. Men, from the beginning of time, have unknowingly lived by a set of rules that they, themselves, created and judge each other by.…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The main subject of the chapter is the evaluation of the desires of women to work in the same fields as men, even if it was not necessary to due to a stable influx of income. The author argues in this chapter that attitudes today are still influenced by retrogressive perspectives on the woman’s role in society. A specific piece of…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Girls In Guyland Analysis

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the chapter of Girls in Guyland: Eyes on the Guys, Kimmel implies that girls play a huge role in the world of boys (Kimmel 245). As a female, I fully understand that women influence guys behaviors and help continue the distasteful behavior. Kimmel states that “ Girls are necessary to Guyland. They enable us, legitimate guy’s behaviors, normalize it, and make it seem natural…” (Kimmel 245).…

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The constructionist views of gender and sexuality is the way an individual is born either male or female. With this in mind the constructionist view gender as a social structure and acknowledge that masculinity and femininity as one way of classifying individuals, but they realize that each society and each past society’s time period differs when it comes to defining masculinity and femininity (Ferris, p.246). The constructionist view has changed the way society identity’s an individual because they do not only look at their sex but other contributing factors like other theories. Some of the other theories are the functionalist theory, the conflict theory, and the symbolic interactionist theory.…

    • 404 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If you somehow stumble across Michael Kimmel he’ll most likely give you an in depth and precise breakdown of the marveled “guy code”. In his essay, Kimmel explains that the guy code is a collection of attitudes, values, and traits that together compose what it generically means to be a “man”(Kimmel 542). Throughout his essay he discusses and dissects each aspect of becoming a man and the specific rules one must follow of the guy code. The text begins with a preposterous list of ten rules that are what Kimmel calls a “Real Guy’s Top Ten List” that broadly expand on how a man must act or what one must do in order to achieve society’s impeded manhood. The list refers to various aphorisms such as, “Boys Don’t Cry”, “Take it like a Man”, and “Nice Guys Finish Last” along with many others (Kimmel 541).…

    • 1448 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kimmel Guyland

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As far as the ability to gain insight to this particular subculture of American males, Kimmel’s methodology, while intentionally limited, is very…

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Coming of Age: The Overcoming of Obstacles Bam! My knees hit the ground, and I was in a world of pain. It was my 7th grade year running in a cross country meet for the first time. I was out of breath and on the verge of quitting because of the struggle that I was experiencing. The voice of Ms. Bulleit, my coach, ran through my ear saying “one step at a time.”…

    • 1422 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There was a certain type of pressure that came with being a woman in high school. “The status of womanhood caused pressure amongst the girl groups to evaluate their friendships… it was pressure to their looks, their personality, and their associations” (Simmons, 156). This was not much different from the set of standards that women in my high school were expected of. In fact, they allowed women, “…the maximum access to the booty of womanhood” (Simmons, 154). One can only imagine how damaging this perception of womanhood would deteriorate the self esteem.…

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Are there rules to being a man? Anything specific you must do? What even separates a man from a boy? Even in today’s society we still question still “what does it take to be a man?” in the essay “Bros Before Hoes” Michael Kimmel does his best to attack these questions and attempt to find an answer to these questions.…

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Men -- It’s in Their Nature”, Christina Hoff Sommers acknowledges that society pushes for gender equality and neutralizing gender roles, but she argues that each male has a neurological predisposition that cannot be changed. Sommers introduces her argument through diction with word choice that contributes a negative connotation as she represents society’s view on masculinity. The negative connotation of Sommers’s word choice generates a negative tone in the opening of her argument, but using humor, Sommers lightens this tone to become more humorous but still serious. Syntax is also used through the use of punctuation adding another element of humor to her argument. Sommers argues that human nature cannot be changed no matter how many people want it to and portrays her argument through her word choice, changes in tone, and her use of punctuation to express humor.…

    • 975 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Society tells men, “Don’t show any emotion!” “Don’t show any weakness!” “Don’t cry!”. The “gender police” is always watching you; your peers, family, and friends are watching you. Kimmel discusses how masculinity is always tested with critical words.…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    John Katz believes that in order for boys to become men they must learn how to be boys, first. John Katz states that there is a specific set of “rules” that all boys must automatically follow from a young age. For instance, the rules stated in the text are about hiding your sensitivity and emotions away. If a boy discusses his feelings, fears or problems he is called a “nerd.” The text implies that in order to be a “man” you must be independent and strong.…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the book of “I Am A Men,” by Steve Estes, emphasize how the Moynihan report, written by Daniel Patrick Moynihan, generated substantial controversies regarding race, gender, and poverty. Moynihan argue in his report how African American families were going through poverty and social deprivation during the 1960s. Moynihan believe that many black males did not have the same opportunities as black females in jobs and education. It was this idea of manhood, were black males wanted to have the courage and strength to raise their families. However, due to the lack of opportunities for black males, many black women had to be the breadwinners of the house.…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is simply naïve to disregard the overwhelming influence that the media and literature has had over the public over the past century and more precisely, in our youth. As a society, we constantly twist ourselves to fit the mold presented to us through various media outlets (e.g. TV, movies, magazines, advertisements, etc.) and in literature we encounter in our lives for a multitude of reasons. Throughout time, men have been presented to fit very traditionally masculine traits based on a preconceived narrative as to what it means to be a man and how to present oneself in order to be perceived as manly by others. Media and literature have branded a hyper-masculine image of men that has in time become what is expected for young boys to follow––be it relayed to them or not.…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays