Thomson And Hursthouse's Perspective On Abortion Debate

Improved Essays
As the semester finally comes to an end and I have time to truly reflect on what I have learned so far I find that my stance on abortion has actually become a bit more muddled. I do not view this as a negative simply because it has allowed me to better understand not only both sides to the argument, but question if I am making the morally correct decision and not just the emotional one. My biggest take away would most definitely be the ability to compare and contrast multiple viewpoints in the argument for abortion. I never considered the fact that the status of the fetus could in fact be irrelevant to morality up until this semester. This Ethics course is something everyone should be required to take in higher education, as it forces people …show more content…
It is not required, in most states, by law for someone to be a Good Samaritan, or even a Minimally Good Samaritan. This argument provides the strongest argument for why most individuals, regardless of stance, seem to agree that in cases where the mother has no choice to have a pregnancy due to rape would allow someone to be a Minimally Good Samaritan and have an abortion later in their pregnancy, having no obligation to birth that fetus. Hursthouse, whose ideas I personally support, are evident in a lot of the voices of my generation. Many of the millennials view pregnancy as something that is indeed special, but something that can be flexible as long as there is just cause for your decision. Living life or not being ready resonate as acceptable excuses as long as thought is put into your decision to be sexually active, and you have some sort of idea of wanting to keep an unwanted pregnancy or not. It is generally frowned upon to flip flop on your decision of abortion past the first trimester of having a child. Ill conclude this part by also saying that I found it very odd, when inquired, hardly any persons believe that a fetus has any “future” and subsequently no right to life because of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Name: Mohammadamin Malek Pour Judith Jarvis Thomson on her article about the morality of abortion gives us some simple and understandable examples. First, she considers the fetus is a person, although she thinks this is a “slope slippery arguments”. In her article, she simply argues that the mother has the right to her body and abortion can be permissible. First, she gives an example of a violinist who is attached to you without your permission and you have to keep the violinist for nine months. In this example, she is trying to compare the attached violinist to pregnancy due to rape.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abortion is an immensely controversial topic in today’s society. Jarvis Thomson makes many arguments on the topic of abortion in the writing of “A Defense of Abortion”. In today’s society, there are many different stances on abortion that include a variety of concepts and situations to consider. Jarvis Thomson says that abortion can be permissible. Many people can concure to that saying babies are innocent and do not mean to harm a mother, but a mother has a right to her body.…

    • 1769 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    All Persons Have a Right to Life The idea of abortion is always a tough subject to talk about. Some people believe it is morally right to have an abortion but some people like Judith Jarvis Thomson think it is wrong to have an abortion. Thompson does just argue that abortion is wrong, she claims that abortion can be justifiable. Judith is right in her belief that abortion is wrong because the fetus is an innocent person and killing an innocent person is always wrong.…

    • 1137 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Also, there are some cases in that perhaps an abortion would be better for the fetus because the pregnancy was not on purpose, and once it is born, it cannot be given the best…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A late-term abortion is generally morally impermissible because at this point the fetus has developed into a person, is almost ready to be born, and the mother has already supported it this far to the point where getting an abortion would be unjust killing. Also Thomson states, “there may well be cases in which carrying the child to term requires only Minimally Decent Samaritanism of the mother, and this is a standard we must not fall below,” meaning that not all abortions are permissible and if giving birth only requires us to be minimally decent, then we should give birth to that child (Thomson, 8). Thomson also states that the mother does not have the right to ensure the death of its offspring, that means that the mother cannot kill her child if it were to be born after a failed abortion. Leaving open the possibility of impermissible abortions is a good move on Thomson’s part because there are always going to be extreme cases in which an abortion should be morally impermissible. To say that abortion is permissible in all cases would be irresponsible and would only lead to a loss of credibility for her entire argument because there is no clear cut answer for this…

    • 1387 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Inviolability of a human life is something that essentially all people hold to be true. But in the case of abortion the waters become muddied and all discussion turns from peaceful discussion too hateful rhetoric. What Judith Thomson does allows some leeway so that a form of discussion can commence. She tries to break down her opposition’s main talking points by allowing for one of the highly contingent positions to be true for the sake of discussion. She does this so that she can state that even with the allowance that a fetus is a person from the moment of conception is does not allow an anti-abortion argument any more validity.…

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    -Judith Jarvis Thomson is a moral philosopher, who wrote A Defense of Abortion in1971. This piece of writing is still causing uproar even in the present time over the continuous argument of abortion. She is for abortion in the right circumstances, and in order to fight the people against her, she wrote this piece of writing. In this text, she states that a fetus is not a person and does not have the right to life, but in order to fight against objections towards her she agrees that a fetus is a person, only for the sake of this argument. She is saying that the usual argument against abortion is “all persons have a right to life, a fetus is a person, therefore they have right to life, therefore abortion is wrong.”.…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abortion Viewpoints

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Abortion is the process one undergoes to intentionally prematurely end a pregnancy; it has become one of the most controversial and most commonly debated topics in this country. The issue is controversial because it is based on the question of whether or not we have control over the life of an innocent unborn child. The nation is divided on the subject of abortion; it has become one of the highlight issues of today’s modern politics. The peoples’ varying perspectives are driven by their moral values, which has made for a biased, non-bi partisan and emotionally driven debate.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Bailey Washington Mr. Reynolds Philosophy MWF 8:30 1 December 2016 Thomson vs. Hursthouse In this paper I will be comparing and contrasting Thomsons A Defense of Abortion and Hursthouses Virtue Theory and Abortions. Also in my paper I will be sharing my opinion on abortion and which view I agree with.…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Satire Essay On Abortion

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Besides being the most explosive political topic in the past twenty-five years, abortion has become part of America daily life. We continuously have an opinion towards this topic, either for or against it. Opinions regarding abortion are divided, causing turmoil among us. According to our society and…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Philosophical critique on the traditional argument against abortion Robert Bertram - UBC ID: 24675373 Phil 333 (001) - Biomedical Ethics The University of British Columbia The concept of morality in relation to abortion is a significant cause of conflict. These moral ambiguities are put into question by Pope John Paul II’s excerpts on the “unspeakable crime of abortion” with regards to the validity, committed fallacies, and the fetus’s content to the right to life (Paul II, 1995, pg. 1). Paul II's Evangelium Vitae (1995), states that aborting a fetus is the "deliberate and direct killing...of a human being in the initial phase of his or her existence". In the paragraphs to follow, this essay will reconstruct the argument, and analyze Thomson's, and Warren's objection to Paul II's statement.…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Patrick Lee’s and Robert P. George’s, On The Wrong of Abortion, it is argued that abortions are objectively immoral. To support this conclusion, Lee and George state that, the fetus is a complete person in an immature phase of development, that the fetus has the potential to develop into a “person” and that abortions are intentional killings. Pro-Choice defenders argue that a human fetus is not a human being because it cannot live on its own, that they are not ‘people’, and that the mother has the executive decision of not wanting the child in her uterus. According to Patrick Lee in another one of his works, The Pro-Life Argument from Substantial Identity: A Defence. Bioethics , He claims that “What makes it wrong to kill you or me now would…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Judith Thomson, in “A Defense of Abortion”, argues her thoughts towards abortion, by using forms of analogies and acknowledges the right to life a fetus has, but also argues that the unborn baby’s right to life does not over ride the pregnant women’s right to make choices and have control over her body. There will be analogy examples in which there are different stated scenarios of a pregnant woman where you will find yourself comparing the scene to an analogy. In order, to justify whether an abortion can be performed or not under certain exceptions varying on the conditions. Thompson’s arguments about abortion deal with the status of being a person of the fetus and, in addition, those who oppose towards abortion spend most of their time trying…

    • 1865 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Brilliant Essays

    She suggests that because a pregnancy is such a great sacrifice, that, while women should carry a child to term after becoming pregnant, we cannot require them to do so. This argument also requires that the fetus’ right to life is subject to the mother’s whim and does not carry as much weight as the first two arguments. Thomson concludes the article by saying that she is not attempting to delineate the circumstances in which a pregnancy might be morally permissible and those in which it isn’t, but rather to make it clear that even if we consider a fetus to be a person, that abortion can still be morally permissible. This weakens her argument a great deal, instead of providing a proscriptive criterion to base the morality of abortion on, she simply provides what may be a series of fringe cases to establish that while abortion is normally wrong, it isn’t always so. Thomson’s argument on abortion is fundamentally deontological.…

    • 1880 Words
    • 8 Pages
    • 1 Works Cited
    Brilliant Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An ethical dilemma is a complex situation that challenges our moral values and beliefs. We are presented with choices/options each day, and our decision to pick one option over the other is usually based on our ethical stance, beliefs, and values. Once these decisions are made, there are consequences, which could be positively or negatively impactful. Abortion has been a very sensitive topic over the years and once again one of the topics that takes center stage during this election year. There are many sides to the argument.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays