Thomas Jefferson's Moral Dilemma Of The Louisiana Purchase

Superior Essays
It is easy to wonder if Thomas Jefferson would ever regret the means by which he would be remembered, for what is regarded by many as the greatest purchase in America’s history. Thomas Jefferson’s moral dilemma of The Louisiana Purchase came from the fact that he had supported and believed in a strict interpretation of the Constitution. He worried whether the purchase would be legal, believing that he was not authorized to make the purchase, but did so anyway. One can also easily wonder how a man of great integrity could go against his own philosophy and strict interpretation of the United States constitution. By making the purchase of the Louisiana territory, Thomas Jefferson had to set aside all his beliefs and principles for the greater …show more content…
minister to France Robert Livingston, Thomas Jefferson stated, “The day that France takes possession of New Orleans…we must marry ourselves to the British fleet and nation.” (www.history.com/topics/louisiana-purchase) Thomas Jefferson suggested purchasing New Orleans from Spain, but Spain had secretly given Louisiana back to France under Napoleon Bonaparte. This frustrated Jefferson because he knew that Europe was increasingly growing and becoming the strongest military. Thomas Jefferson wanted to avoid all conflict with foreign countries. This would be difficult in his eyes because Europe had the largest landholding in North America at the time. Thomas Jefferson’s goal for America was to be able to expand, and to create an “empire of liberty.” (Boyer et al. 2011) Soon after, Jefferson sent Livingston to France to try to negotiate the purchase of the Louisiana territory. At first they refused, but after James Monroe was also sent they decided to agree, especially after Napoleon Bonaparte decided that Louisiana was not worth its cost. The Louisiana territory was 828,000 square miles. According to Funk & Wagnall 's New Encyclopedia, the price agreed on was $15 million, of which $11,250,000 was to be paid outright by the U.S. to France. The balance of $3,750,000 was to be paid by the U.S. to its citizens to satisfy their claims against France. …show more content…
According to author Tim Faulkner, “The expedition opened up new territory for the fur and lumber trade and pointed out the best lands for future settlement and agriculture. It allowed a young country to blossom into greatness, because more land had equated to more resources and therefore, more power.” (http://history.howstuffworks.com) The country learned many things through this expedition. This expedition helped us discover new land, waterways, trade, plants, animals, and people. The expedition of Lewis and Clark was once of great importance, but most importantly, it helped set the stage for new settlement of the west. So, because of the purchase of the Louisiana territory, the United States not only grew, but in my opinion it helped become to what is still to this day, the greatest county. All because of one man’s significant decision to go against what he believed in. This just proves that great things can happen by taking a

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    This can be corroborated by “Jefferson’s Great Gamble” by Charles A. Cerami which emphasizes: In fact, as Marbois later wrote, he felt the decision was already made (to cede Louisiana to America). That was probably because he (Marbois) had always known that Louisiana could not prosper as a French colony unless France also controlled a prosperous Saint Domingue. And that island was proving to be Napoleon’s worse disaster to date…

    • 1853 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Kevin Luke Mr. Muller HIST 1301-4M3DC, Fall 2016 20 November 2016 A Moral Dilemma Thomas Jefferson was elected president in 1801, and had no intentions of expanding the United States of America at the time. Little did he know he would be faced with one of the biggest choices ever made in the history of the country. Previous to Jefferson becoming president, Spain ceded the Louisiana territory to France. The territory had the potential to double the size of the United States at the time. Now, Jefferson had sent Robert Livingston and James Monroe into France to discuss acquiring New Orleans, but instead find out that Napoleon Bonaparte, in order to finance his war in Europe, was willing to sell all of the Louisiana territory to Jefferson and…

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Louisiana Purchase was an offer from the French that opened up many beneficial opportunities for the growing United States. Land west of the Eastern seaboard was territory claimed by the French; however after the Seven Year’s War France had lost its dominance over the land and transferred control to Spain. France had later found itself in need of funding for the war they were fighting in Europe. The United States, with their growing population and need for expansion, found the opportunity extremely beneficial in both doubling the size of America and offering numerous trade opportunities. Nevertheless, from evidence provided in the transcript of the Louisiana Purchase and President Thomas Jefferson’s secret message to congress…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He bought Louisiana to avoid future war, collect new resources, and lastly it the purchase would expand land. On April 30, 1803 the land of Louisiana that was owned by Spain then given to France, was bought by Thomas Jefferson, president of the United States that current time. Thomas Jefferson who was a strict constitutional follower was shamed and argued upon saying that he shouldn’t of have bought the land from a foreign country. Thomas Jefferson bought it from French minister Charles Maurice de Talleyrand. Jefferson knew that he had messed up on buying it but had many reasons to do so.…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even though Jefferson had claimed to be for small government he was willing to go above this if it meant protecting the country. This use of power was barley touched by the Federalist and Jefferson was willing to go beyond his predecessors. Under Jefferson the greatest expanse of U.S territory occurred when Louisiana was bought from France in the Louisiana Purchase. The French had been willing to sell after they loss their colonies in Haiti and Napoleon realized he was not going to be able to achieve his American empire. This allowed for America to now have a vast land to expand and move west into.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The move would cause a war with Britain, and Napoleon needed money to fight. By selling Louisiana, he could raise that money,” (Jaffe 31). France’s enemy was Britain, and Napoleon was determined to beat the British. France could not afford to go to war with amount of money that they had, Napoleon knew that even though he would be losing resources, and breaking his promise to Spain never to sell the Louisiana Purchase, he had to the sell the land in order to go to war. Napoleon made it so that the United States was unaware that France wanted to sell the territory, so during the negation, Napoleon would…

    • 1437 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American people have been scarred with tyrannical rule by Great Britain and will rise in any assumptions that their unalienable rights are at risk. Yes, Jefferson expanded the United States to double its size in one sweep, but the process at which this was done should certainly have been overlooked by each branch of government. Especially when one takes into consideration the fact that Jefferson was a firm believer in that the Constitution should be followed under the impression that anything not listed should not be allowed. If this was the case, (most people would wonder), why did he not stick true to that belief and purchase land from a foreign…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Section I, 1. Why was Napoleon willing to sell the Louisiana Territory to the United States? How did Jefferson’s Louisiana Purchase transform America’s understanding of itself and its future? Was it inevitable that the West would become part of a much greater United States? Napoleon Bonaparte, before he decided to sell Louisiana was already facing many problems.…

    • 1666 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Louisiana Purchase

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Jefferson offered to purchase land from Napoleon rather than having a war over it. He sent diplomats to France to negotiate for continued access trade along the Mississippi’s River, while also sending diplomats to Brittan to pursue other policy options. Jefferson sent James Monroe, the secretary of state to negotiate in Paris. Monroe imposed the purchase New Orleans and West Florida for an amount between two and ten million dollars. To Monroe’s surprise however, Napoleon offered more.…

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thomas Jefferson: A Contentious Patriot In the mere beginnings of his presidency in 1801, Thomas Jefferson knew he was to live up to the expectations of the American public. Rumors were circulating that Spain would give up control of the strategic ports of New Orleans back to France, Jefferson feared this greatly. Fervently, the idea of Spain giving the ports back to the original owner of the French ensued to become more of a possibility, so with this the President took action which may have caused him more hardships than he could possibly envision. In the 19th century the reality was French military dictator, Napoleon Bonaparte persisted to be contemplating a plan with the Spanish government, to control the ports of New Orleans once…

    • 1286 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays