Thomas Jefferson's Moral Dilemma Of The Louisiana Purchase

Superior Essays
It is easy to wonder if Thomas Jefferson would ever regret the means by which he would be remembered, for what is regarded by many as the greatest purchase in America’s history. Thomas Jefferson’s moral dilemma of The Louisiana Purchase came from the fact that he had supported and believed in a strict interpretation of the Constitution. He worried whether the purchase would be legal, believing that he was not authorized to make the purchase, but did so anyway. One can also easily wonder how a man of great integrity could go against his own philosophy and strict interpretation of the United States constitution. By making the purchase of the Louisiana territory, Thomas Jefferson had to set aside all his beliefs and principles for the greater …show more content…
minister to France Robert Livingston, Thomas Jefferson stated, “The day that France takes possession of New Orleans…we must marry ourselves to the British fleet and nation.” (www.history.com/topics/louisiana-purchase) Thomas Jefferson suggested purchasing New Orleans from Spain, but Spain had secretly given Louisiana back to France under Napoleon Bonaparte. This frustrated Jefferson because he knew that Europe was increasingly growing and becoming the strongest military. Thomas Jefferson wanted to avoid all conflict with foreign countries. This would be difficult in his eyes because Europe had the largest landholding in North America at the time. Thomas Jefferson’s goal for America was to be able to expand, and to create an “empire of liberty.” (Boyer et al. 2011) Soon after, Jefferson sent Livingston to France to try to negotiate the purchase of the Louisiana territory. At first they refused, but after James Monroe was also sent they decided to agree, especially after Napoleon Bonaparte decided that Louisiana was not worth its cost. The Louisiana territory was 828,000 square miles. According to Funk & Wagnall 's New Encyclopedia, the price agreed on was $15 million, of which $11,250,000 was to be paid outright by the U.S. to France. The balance of $3,750,000 was to be paid by the U.S. to its citizens to satisfy their claims against France. …show more content…
According to author Tim Faulkner, “The expedition opened up new territory for the fur and lumber trade and pointed out the best lands for future settlement and agriculture. It allowed a young country to blossom into greatness, because more land had equated to more resources and therefore, more power.” (http://history.howstuffworks.com) The country learned many things through this expedition. This expedition helped us discover new land, waterways, trade, plants, animals, and people. The expedition of Lewis and Clark was once of great importance, but most importantly, it helped set the stage for new settlement of the west. So, because of the purchase of the Louisiana territory, the United States not only grew, but in my opinion it helped become to what is still to this day, the greatest county. All because of one man’s significant decision to go against what he believed in. This just proves that great things can happen by taking a

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    He saw it as a means of allowing Americans to expand to new lands and possibilities that were otherwise impossible without the attaining of new land. Jefferson would find himself defying his belief that the Constitution be strictly interpreted and therefore exploiting himself to the Federalists, who were against the purchase because it would deem their eastern seaboard less important. Jefferson indeed faced multiple dilemmas in the decision to go through with purchasing Louisiana territory from France; defying his beliefs, putting the government in question, and risking Federalist upheaval across the nation. But it seems that, in the broader aspect of things, Jefferson made the correct decision in expanding American land because it allowed increase in production within American farming and therefore made the nation twice as strong as it was before 1803, not just in wealth but in power as well. All great nations start their conquest with expansion, and this was the beginning of the United States’…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When taking on the role of presidency on 1801 Jefferson was faced with a task larger than many other Presidents would have to overcome. “His party, ignoring the natural forces which tied the States together even against their wills, insisted that the legal basis of the bond was in the power of any State to withdraw at will”(Under Napoleon I. 1904, pg 7). This lessened America’s apparent standing to other nations due to the signs of weakness and ironic lack of union. Jefferson saw this and was hard pressed to consul the American wrought ideals of democracy and nationality (Under Napoleon I 1904, pg 7). A strong step in that reconciliation was the purchase of the Louisiana Territory in 1803.…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The United States expanded across North America to the west at a rapid rate most notably in the 1840’s through the 1850s. Many social, econonomic, and political factors lead to the nations growth and acquisition of land. Social interests included families’ desire to seek more land out west along with economic opportunities for interstate commerce and political agendas concerning territorial expansion. The Louisiana Purchase of 1803 from the French government, by President Thomas Jefferson, cost $15 million, and included territory from Canada to New Orleans, and the Mississippi to the Rocky Mountains (Westward Expansion, 2009). The purchase of these territories doubled United States’ size and according to Jefferson it was crucial to the nation’s…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As Secretary of State under Thomas Jefferson, James Madison famously acquired the Louisiana Purchase in 1803. This 530 million acre territory was previously owned by France. Due to Madison’s clever negotiation, the Territory was given to the USA at an expense of $15 million (Louisiana Purchase, n.d.). This landmark exchange nearly doubled the size of the country, giving a surge of excitement amongst the American people to expand the country westward. This action had been strategically taken after Spain had ceded the territory back to France in 1800, and both Jefferson and Madison feared that Napoleon would attempt to reclaim New Orleans from the United States (Steinberg 160-161) (compound sentence).…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Napoleon thought that, 'Hey, I need money, so I'll sell it to these guys and then raid them to get it back'. Jefferson only needed to buy New Orleans, but Napoleon offered it as all or nothing" ("The Original Goal: Buying New Orleans"). So, Jefferson bought basically all of Central America for fifteen million dollars and nearly doubling the size of the nation. After Jefferson bought the new…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Revolution of 1803 In the Revolution of 1803 by Peter S. Onuf the thesis was the events related to the Louisiana Purchase, The territories before the Louisiana Purchase, Jefferson’s Inaugurals speech, and the views of Jefferson on the revolution. The Louisiana Purchase was the purchasing of land from the French. This expanded the United States west ward. “United States acquired 82800 square miles for 15 million dollars,” (91).…

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As America was developing as a new, independent country, many topics were up for debate. The Constitution was created to answer most of them, but many problems arose that people had trouble defining constitutional or unconstitutional. One of the major issues was the purchasing of the Louisiana Territory from France. The Louisiana Purchase was a worthwhile purchase for America because of the new resources it brought, it doubled the size of the country, strengthened the relationship with the Native Americans, and gave America control of both sides of the Mississippi River.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Louisiana Purchase was a land deal in 1803 made between France and the United States that resulted in America expanding further into the New World and doubling their land size. This real estate deal resulted in the mass acquisition of land made under Jefferson’s presidency and later fueled Polk into wanting to expand further through the mid-19th-century idea of Manifest Destiny. This idea, made by John L. O 'Sullivan, was that it is America’s god-given right to expand from the Pacific to the Atlantic Ocean. The synthesis of the Louisiana Purchase and the later idea of Manifest Destiny helped spur many debates over newly gained territories through territorial expansion. These debates arose from issues on whether or not land from the Louisiana…

    • 1755 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Louisiana Purchase Thomas Jefferson was an active hero, a spokesman for democracy, and the third president of these United States of America. As president, he was always faced with diversity; whether it was dealing with the Barbary pirates in the middle east, belligerent British trade policies, and even the greatest acquirement of all time: the Louisiana Purchase. The Louisiana purchase was one of the best procurements that could have happened to this great nation. That is why The purchase of Louisiana held no significant moral dilemmas for President Thomas Jefferson, because it benefited the nation by growing more than double the size of the United states, gave the country complete control of the port of New Orleans, and provided territory…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Section I, 1. Why was Napoleon willing to sell the Louisiana Territory to the United States? How did Jefferson’s Louisiana Purchase transform America’s understanding of itself and its future? Was it inevitable that the West would become part of a much greater United States? Napoleon Bonaparte, before he decided to sell Louisiana was already facing many problems.…

    • 1666 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Louisiana Purchase

    • 1008 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Louisiana Purchase is an event that caused a great deal of controversy during the early 1800s. This vast tract of land was purchased by Mr. Thomas Jefferson before the government had a chance to approve it. Congress did indeed approve this purchase, but it was only after they decided not to analyze the constitution too in-depth. This is the very reason that so many Americans were split on this issue. Despite the controversy, one thing is certain, the Louisiana Purchase has opened our eyes and helped us gain a better knowledge on how our constitution works.…

    • 1008 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thomas Jefferson, one of the most popular founding fathers, the main author of the Declaration of Independence, and the third president of the United States of America was revered by his contemporaries and is still to this day a well respected figure in American history. But, this does not mean that the man had no faults. Often in todays world Thomas Jefferson is looked back upon and has been scrutinized by many for his apparent hypocrisy on matters such as slavery and on what he believed limitations of the federal government were to be. Although some of Jefferson’s past can be dark and questionable, he was no hypocrite, but a man who understood that his decisions would have lasting effects on the new country, and that putting his own personal…

    • 1033 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Jefferson’s Great Gamble: The Remarkable Story of Jefferson, Napoleon, and the Men Behind the Louisiana Purchase, Charles A. Cerami’s recounted the one of the most overlooked events in American history. Thomas Jefferson and Napoleon Bonaparte, two of history's greatest leaders, stood face to face for the western lands of America. It was indeed grueling mission for Jefferson: outmaneuvering the great Napoleon Bonaparte, determining the morality of westward expansion, and most importantly keeping America intact and out of war. Cerami, an economist and historian, featured the drama, cajolery, fear, and betrayal America confronted before leading itself to massive real-estate deal known as Louisiana Purchase. Cerami informed the readers about the significant people and crucial events that eventually led to the Louisiana Purchase.…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The beliefs and values embraced by Thomas Jefferson in his Letter to James Madison can be seen by some as archaic and insensible to a growing society. Although America’s values on the basis of economy and society have shifted somewhat, a few of his ideas can still be interwoven into how America regards itself. Another writing of Jefferson’s will be referenced in the course of this essay, since it has a clearer sense of why Jefferson felt the way he did about agrarian societies. This writing is Query XIX from his Notes on the State of Virginia, the final edition published in 1785. The points maintained in this writing support those contained within his Letter to James Madison, even if he is speaking specifically of the state of Virginia instead of the country as a whole.…

    • 1289 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Napoleon negotiated with Spain for occupation of Louisiana in 1800 in exchange for Tuscany and a written pledge to never sell Louisiana to a third party. French occupation in the west did not just threaten commerce in the United States, but the sovereignty and future of the nation. Knowing that the French armies would be detrimental to the nation, the typically pro-French President Jefferson proposed that “We must marry ourselves to the British fleet and nation” for survival. As Napoleon prepared a massive army in Holland to occupy Louisiana, fate twisted in the favor of the United States and slave born rebellions ravished through French occupied Santo Domingo. Santo Domingo ports were essential for French success in Louisiana.…

    • 1413 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays