Pro Slavery Dbq Thesis

Superior Essays
INTRO STATEMENT. Slave narratives are used to spread the messages of abolitionists but most importantly rebut the arguments of pro-slavery. While reading about the life of a slave, readers get to question whether this institution is truly beneficial or morally wrong. Exposing the horrors of slavery, the narratives elaborate on the stripping away of all human identity. Using the influential and gripping pieces to their advantage, abolitionists exploit the dehumanization, inequality, and discrimination told throughout slave narratives to campaign against slavery. There are many different types of slavery, yet each branch follows a similar rule: slaves are not to be treated as people; they are property. (Douglass vi) Being so, slaves are sold, …show more content…
The type of lifestyle a slave received differed upon which type of work they were bound to do. While houseservants lived a more “lavish” life, fieldworkers were bound to endure high levels of suffering, abuse, and violence. In the middle of these two branches of slavery were the farmservants. Farmservants were not extremely spoiled yet not outrageously abused either. (Document B). The differentiating fields of slavery add to the already massive inequality slaves endure. Slavery as a whole is unfair and unjust, no matter which type of work one receives. However, the different levels of treatment create disunity within the slave community by instilling jealousy in people. While slaves are not coming together, masters ensure that oppression lives on. Society will keep denying the rights of slaves and hold them hostage to a world full of injustice. One common denial of rights was the inability to free speech. The enslaved do not pertain the right to speak out against their masters and therefore cannot receive justice for wrongdoings. Even in the situation where a slave goes to trial, they will be presumed guilty until otherwise proven innocent, yet the possibility of proof of innocence arising is slim. (Document B) This injustice is specifically seen in the shooting of a slave named Demby in Douglass’ narrative. Demby refuses to comply with his …show more content…
They expand on ideas of dehumanization, inequality, and injustice to expose the real horrors of slavery. To win over the neutral parties onto the abolitionist side, the narratives provide a gripping glimpse into the life of a slave that is hard to ignore afterwards. When reading about how truly awful the institution of slavery is from a primary source, no person could ever support pro-slavery

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    It was going to take conflict and battles in order to tear slavery from the roots of the country. The abolishment of slavery came from a undefined unitement between the blacks and whites and moral agreement that slavery was not right. Though usually they never spoke or planned with each other, but by their natural feelings of what’s right and wrong, people, both black and white, worked together to end slavery. It wasn’t done by slavery just being kicked out the door, it was done by a united undermining of the slave trade. The abolitionists made slave owning so difficult and none worthwhile that it became not worth while to most owners to keep slaves anymore.…

    • 1738 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    His motivation to write about his difficult life as a slave was to both inform the American public about the degraded, malevolent nature of slavery and to humanize the slaves negatively affected by the Southern institution. Throughout his narrative, Frederick delineate the horrors of slavery by exposing the candid information that, “led [him] to abhor and detest [his] enslavers” (Douglass 27). Douglass’s narrative inputted examples of the drastic conditions African Americans that targeted an audience for persuasion to declare freedom for the servants. As listeners varied from abolitionists, to…

    • 1200 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this mini series, Douglass purpose of writing this narrative was to show what slavery really is terrible for all people and it affected not only slaves but slave owners as well. Douglass wrote his narrative to explain how slavery not only corrupted slaves but it also corrupted slave owners. One reason why F.D thinks it terrible for both is because the slaves always get beat. Also it can bring a change upon slave owners that can turn their angels into demons like Mrs, Auld. Those who defended slavery believed that the slaves were always happy like how they were back where they lived but, they were not…

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The brutal way that slaveholders abused their slaves was dehumanizing and evil. Slaves were given out of line disciplines and they figured out how to utilize different people groups botches as cases. Families were moved to inverse sides of the nation given no contact. Ultimately they were dealt with more awful than creatures and plainy slighted. The Inhumanity of Slaveholders is a prominent theme in Douglass’ and Jacobs’ texts.…

    • 1041 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From labor to sex trafficking, blacks were transported unwillingly to work for the slaveholders. These black men, never in return were rewarded or given a break for the extensive work hours that was provided. Being tired of the treatment many slaves tried to escape but, if caught the discipline was tortuous. Still African American’s risked the consequences for a chance to start a new life. The history of slavery helped generate the concept…

    • 1474 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Slavery is an evil that corrodes the slave 's life as well as the slaveholder 's mind and behavior. As demonstrated in the Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, An American Slave, the personality of the most pure masters and mistresses can have a negative 180 degree turn after experiencing slavery. Frederick Douglass argues this by presenting the examples of Sophia Auld (a white mistress) and Thomas Auld (a non-born slaver owner) who were influenced by slavery to become dishonest and immoral. The evil of slavery affected both men and women slaveholders. Mrs. Auld underwent on a transformation of corruption when she gained the possession of slaves.…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Today, in the era of freedom, we rely on slave memoirs to live vicariously through the eyes of survived slaves. However, slavery may have been even worse than we assume, as there were times when slavery was in times “too cruel to describe in words.” While at first Douglass’s narrative seemed graver as he directly emphasized slavery’s physical violence, Jacobs struggled just as much or even more as women were subject to sexual oppression and rape. In spite of that, both Douglass and Jacobs’s narratives show slavery’s extreme violence, ranging from brutal whippings to persecution and…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The slaves could not freely embrace a position of inferiority without replicating the exact system that oppressed them within their own communities. The basic and straightforward master-slave relationship was interrupted by ripples of further oppression. The institution of slavery relies on the complete and total submission of those being enslaved to function properly. When the slave communities mirror the attitudes of the slavers, complete submission within those communities is not obtained, as certain members are still latching on to positions of authority and dominance. This is why the African slaves could not form a homogenous culture despite sweeping efforts to unify, the social system of stratification that emerged within their community structurally prevented them from unifying.…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The institution of slavery was “stinging” Douglass and the thousands of slaves with whom he shared his fate. He was unable to recognize the source of these stings until he read The Columbian Orator, which “enabled [him] to utter [his] thoughts” (229). Until this point, the metaphorical insects were intangible, and although Douglass could feel the pain, he was unable to describe the cause of his hardship. In the same way, Douglass’s contrarian ideas are hidden in his writing; a bias against slavery exists but is difficult to pinpoint at first glance. Ironically, as he vividly describes the pain he lived through on a daily basis, Douglass claims the anguish he endures is “unutterable” (230).…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Slavery violates both liberty and justice as part of liberty is freedom and holding innocent people and forcing labor upon them violates liberty. The so called justice that was supposed to be another defining feature of the Americas is nothing but an empty word when it came to slavery as slave owners would beat their slaves regularly and there were plenty of deaths related to the beatings owners gave to their slaves. Equiano did an outstanding job of presenting his argument and presented many valid points if slavery took place in a more modern era, there is no doubt that two key terms of the United States would have to be revisited. As liberty and justice meant nothing during slavery and Equiano’s argument assured that…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays