Thesis Of Slaveism In Eric Williams's Capitalism And Slavery

Improved Essays
Capitalism and Slavery
In the introduction to his book Capitalism and Slavery, Eric Williams clearly states, “Here, then, is the origin of Negro slavery. The reason was economic, not racial; it had to do not with the color of the laborer, but the cheapness of the labor.” This meant that he was attempting to pursue an understanding of the economic aspects of slavery without the association of morals nor ethics. An argument that is indeed controversial in our now humanitarian-based society. In perspective, we cannot understand Williams argument without understanding what he puts forth in his book.
The essence of William’s argument is that a change in the economic structure produced a corresponding change in labor supply. He attested this throughout
…show more content…
This was another aspect that made the book important second to the economic background of slavery. The development of racism came about as a means of isolating the African community from the ruling and dominant white. One advantage that aided in the selection of Africans as a source of slavery was solely based on their inability to blend in due to their skin color. Their status as slaves and their skin color then lead to the discrimination of the African people in the American and Caribbean plantations. As they were deemed ‘disposable,’ the development of an inferiority complex was then inevitable especially with the sweet-toothed Westerners who only viewed their labor as tools to maximize their profits rather than humans. Thus, concludes the under-arching argument set forth by Williams of the origin of racism from …show more content…
This is an argument that David Eltis supports in Chapter 10 of his book The Rise of African Slavery in the Americas. To him, the flow of capital and labor to the tropical Americans from Europe was largely based on socioeconomic status as ‘success or failure would be measured by the same standards in slave and non-slave societies’ (1). He further solidifies his support of Williams argument by stating that, “success or failure would be measured by the same standards in slave and non-slave societies” (1). In this manner, David further supports Williams in this chapter by explaining the development of industrialization. Indeed, the triangular trade contributed to the industrialization in England and created a unified Atlantic world that included Europe, western Africa, the Caribbean islands, and the mainland of North and South

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    What did it share with other patterns of slave owning and slave trading? The size of the Atlantic slave trade was special.Slave gained little hope for freedom and were treated as creatures. Page 623 Guided Reading Question: Causation What explains the rise of the Atlantic slave trade? The explanation behind the ascent of the Atlantic slave trade was because they were the best source of slaves to receive from.They were skilled farmers, and they were immune to tropical and European sicknesses.The Americans would cease to exist from the European infections. Page 624 Guided Reading Question: Connection What roles did Europeans and Africans play in the unfolding of the Atlantic slave trade?…

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Yet racism still didn’t lay claim to that logical hole entirely part of it would’ve came from the founding fathers distaste towards the lack of freedom one gets from being in debt. In short Morgan uses the fears of the founding fathers and need for cheap labor as a justification for slavery in colonial America while shelfing the idea racism being the majority driving…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Determining the characteristics of slavery and defining what it means to be a slave society has garnered considerable attention in American historiography. Peter Kolchin’s Unfree Labor: American Slavery and Russian Serfdom attempts to clarify our understanding of both topics through a comparative study of these two labor systems. By juxtaposing these two institutions, Kolchin is able to highlight similarities and differences. He concludes a labor shortage in their respective societies created the need for bound workers in order to support the landholding elite. He also contends both American slavery and Russian serfdom were “fundamentally noncapitalist productive systems.” (359-361) However, despite these similarities, significant differences…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Slavery In North America

    • 1121 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Racial ideology played a major role in the consolidation of slavery, but not in introduction as evidenced by the fact indentured servitude involved both blacks and whites, showing no racial prejudice originally. Europeans quickly began associating blackness with the devil, immortality and dirt, labelling Africans as ‘unintelligent savages’ and ‘inferior beings’ and used their non-Christian status to defend their actions. Social ideologies were also used as justification of slavery. The South thrived off money earned by slave-produced agricultural crops and attempted to convince North Americans, slavery was beneficial for the whole society, as it gave slaves a purpose and supported the ‘Southern way of life’, which would quickly collapse if slaves were freed. Political aspects also came into play in the reinforcement of slavery; according to US constitution, for tax purposes slaves were regarded as 3/5ths of a person, this was passed onto slave-owners themselves, meaning Southern states held a greater representation in US Congress and therefore a greater balance of power (Dodson, 2003).…

    • 1121 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The invention of cotton gin in the 18th century hardened the key role that slaves played in the American economy. As slavery evolved, an intricate and lasting mythology on the subsidiarity of the Africans was generated to propagate and legalize slavery. However, slavery and the treatment of slaves differed between the Northern and Southern colonies. The southern colonies were more cautious of the institution of slavery. They contended that the Africans were unable to take care of themselves and that slavery was a generous establishment that offered them food, clothes and kept them occupied.…

    • 1279 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He underpins financial realism, adjusting himself against the individuals who believed that everything determined cause and effect, ideological concerns, and the feelings of sadness at the focal point of the abolition movement. In general, Williams argues that it is not an occurrence that slavery and the slave exchange got to be ugly as a generation that took over the remote exchange as the production of the British economy. However, I favor these arguments because Williams not only talks about slavery but he also goes into great detail about the American Revolution. In the future, I would like to explore this book more and learn a great amount of African…

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even though, slaves were thought as subhuman, lesser than the common man these thoughts could have been driven by the economic impact such people had on societies. Robin Osborne, in his novel, challenges the idea of slavery having roots in economic interest, “Slavery was an institution… maintained by prejudice…Athenians did not like the idea of devoting their lives… to labor”. Possibly, these thoughts of racism and inferiority flourished as an issue to the astounding commercial advantages to slavery. Not only Athenians, but other peoples, developed “justifications” for slavery such as certain races are higher than another because “all slaves did” was provide labor and household assistance. Since such people were enslaved, their state in society diminished due to the advantages they provided wealthy citizens with, leaving certain races being seen as less than human.…

    • 1218 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Helper stated, “to say nothing of the sin and the shame of slavery, we believe it is a most expensive and unprofitable institution…” He further claimed that if slavery was gone, non-slaveholding whites would reap the moral benefits because they would be seen as equals. A larger concern for both North and South was the affects slavery had on the economy. Seward said a man contributed positively and efficiently when he free versus being a slave. In a slave labor society, the worker was there against his will. Though he may work hard, there was no incentive for him at the end of the day.…

    • 1293 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He understood that slavery brought a great amount of wealth to the south which is the main reason southern whites did not want to abolish slavery. Frederick Douglas was able to overcome the many negative outcomes of ignoring the roles of a slave by stating a new aspiration in mind, and that was to become a free slave. It was definitely a goal not many slaves wished to think of because of the horrid outcomes of being caught. His main points of going against slavery were that there was no point in living a life being considered property instead of an actual human being, slavery caused good people to do bad things, it was cruel, and slave owners used Christianity as a justification for their actions. It was definitely not humane to live a life of a slave.…

    • 1038 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The slaves in the Caribbean Islands often died and brought forth the argument that slavery in the United States was “better” than in the Islands. Slave owners primarily only cared about what was more profitable in both areas. Slavery was viewed as just a business to them. This was a very harsh statement to me because it is hard to understand how a human being, can see this type of treatment to another human being as acceptable. It states that slave owners had two theories on how to treat their slaves.…

    • 1099 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays