Theme Of Naturalism In The Tell Tale Heart

Better Essays
Many people have a fear of public speaking, heights, or spiders. In the Tell Tale Heart, however; one might find a newfound fear for a roommate stalking you in your sleep whilst planning your murder. This story distinctly uses naturalism, specifically in the case of the narrator. Naturalism plays with the ideas of men as beasts and also with fate versus free will. Both of these themes are displayed by the narrator. For instance, the narrator may be categorized as a beast since he plans this horrendous murder against the old man, for no other reason than the man’s deformed eye. To continue, fate versus freewill is exhibited by the narrator because he feels he has no choice but to kill the old man, yet he could have just as easily left the house …show more content…
Edgar Allen Poe’s A Tell Tale Heart is classified as a naturalism piece. Naturalism often employs the idea of men being ‘beasts’ and in the case of the narrator, he is the beast. It is evident from the very first line that the narrator is not completely sane, he states, “TRUE!—nervous—very, very dreadfully nervous I had been and am; but why will you say that I am mad?” He straight out asks the reader if he is crazy. Of course, beasts are often portrayed as full of rage and anger and violence, and at first it seems that the narrator is only slightly unstable. As the story continues, it is evident that the narrator is indeed, a beast when he states, “Whenever it [the eye] fell upon me, my blood ran cold; and so by degrees—very gradually—I made up my mind to take the life of the old man, and thus rid myself of the eye forever.” At this point it can be determined that the narrator has intentions to kill an innocent man; it can also be concluded that the narrator probably has some type of a mental illness leading him to these thoughts and ideas. Another aspect of naturalism that is presented in The Tell Tale Heart is the idea of fate versus freewill. The narrator, who is obviously disturbed, feels that he has to kill the old man to rid the world of his ‘vulture eye’; his …show more content…
This story heavily employs and emphasizes naturalism to display both men as beasts and fate versus free will within the narrator himself. The narrator is displayed as beast as he begins to describe and pursue his goal of murdering the old man, distinctly because he doesn’t like the man’s eye. Moreover, fate versus freewill is shown due to the fact that the narrator doesn’t even stop to think of another option besides killing the old man, he feels it is fate, while the reader obviously feels there could’ve been another option. Home is where the heart is, mostly commonly this phrase is meant to mean that home is a place of comfort and love. In the case of the narrator, however, the old man’s heart is literally in the floor boards and ultimately leads to his demise. This story was published in the middle of the civil war, when everything was being torn apart within the United States. The story itself leads to the same feeling of inner turmoil. Overall, The Tell Tale Heart is a dark tale of the internal struggle of a man first explaining his ‘sane’ reasons for murder, and then proving to not only to the reader, but to himself, that you can’t get away with

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    I felt I must scream or die!” (Poe 4). Poe’s narrator can’t withstand the agony of the old man’s beating heart and the whole situation so he turns himself in to the police. Using the Seven Theses of Monsters as a framework, Poe’s narrator in “The Tell-Tale Heart” doesn’t fit the criteria because he chooses to…

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This is evident in the short story, “The Tell Tale Heart” by Edgar Allan Poe, where the narrator has an obsession with an old man’s eye--an eye that brought great agony among the narrator whenever he looked upon it. He couldn’t bare seeing that eye any longer, thus, in a merciless manner, he decided to kill the old man because of it. Feeling great remorse by the end of the story, the narrator becomes paranoid and scared. As suggested…

    • 1393 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Do you believe that a respected hero can become a hated villain, or that anyone can become desensitised to murder in cold blood? Macbeth showcases the transformation of a brave and loyal soldier to a murderous tyrant whose sanity is completely lost. At first he is unsure whether to follow his desires of becoming king and is conflicted about murder for personal gain, but later he, or rather his hired murderers, kill just to ease the doubts and worries bothering his own mind. In Macbeth these numerous acts of murder demonstrates that even the bravest heroes are not immune to the temptation of causing death if they can benefit from it, and once they are exposed to it, they will change in nature until they are unrecognizable to their former self.…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The foremost reason the narrator gives for killing the old man is his vulture-like eye. Throughout the story the narrator reiterates how much he cannot stand the eye and that it is the reason he needs to kill the old man, so he can get rid of the eye (Wilson 346). However, the narrator blaming the eye is just an instance him trying to rest the blame of murder on something other than his insanity. Since he harbors no ill-will towards the old man, he needs something to blame for the need he feels to kill the old man, so the narrator blames the old man’s eye (Zimmerman). Another vital instance of the narrator placing blame for the murder on something other than his insanity is in the moments leading up to the old man’s death.…

    • 1825 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This helps to factor in how fear might have contributed to their killing of Simon. They did not have justification in killing Simon but through the fear they built up in their mind they somehow convinced themselves that it was okay. Another example of Golding’s use of juxtaposition is when it says “The beast was on its knees in the center, its arms folded over its face. It was crying out against the abominable noise something about a body on the hill” to contrast Simon with the beast (152). Golding is showcasing the vast differences between their characters by showing how the beast will fight back and be cruel just to be evil while Simon was just trying to tell them about the parachute man.…

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    These three short stories,The Raven, The Tell-Tale Heart, and The Cask Of Amontillado, have hatred, evilness, and vengefulness in them. They have men that each believe killing or being tortured resolves the solution. But was commiting murder, and being tortured really worth it? The first story talks about a madman wanting to kill a old man for having what he calls “A evil eye”. He likes the elderly man but has a lot of hatred towards the eye.…

    • 1276 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Additionally, it cruelty is obviously present on Jack’s side because he is single-handedly planting ideas of performing vicious actions, such as slaughtering a Beast when he knows that there is no “Beast,” into the littluns’ heads in order to woo them to his side and away from Ralph’s civilized views. This action leads the littluns to categorize their future wrongdoings, such as murders, as “not a big deal” because if they learn that it is acceptable to close in on a Beast “and beat and beat and beat,” they will acknowledge the fact that that everything they do is not as evil or cruel as beating a ghastly fiend. Besides, when Jack announces, “If there’s a Beast, we’ll hunt it down,” he is…

    • 858 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Once Laertes found out his father was dead he wanted to kill his father 's murder. Laertes even said himself in Act 4 Scene 5, “Let come what comes, only I’ll be revenged most thoroughly for my father.” (page 215). His loyalty and madness only makes his revenge more certain and he utilizes them as a stimulation to actually carry out revenge. Additionally, once he sees that Ophelia turned mad and eventually drowns herself because her father was killed by Hamlet and Hamlet has left her, Laertes is motivated to avenge Hamlet. In the complex story of Hamlet, Claudius also seeks revenge.…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Macbeth’s blind ambition to be king consumed him, which resulted him in committing immoral acts, such as the compulsion that he possesses leads him in killing his comrades as well as betraying himself. The dagger vision symbolizes foreshadows a weapon of death and contemplating whether or not to go through murdering Duncan, Macbeth is between ambition and guilt, but he decides to kill Duncan regardless of the guilt he carries around. By committing this act it made him carry a lifetime of baggage and the decisions he makes are out of fear. Macbeth continues to kill innocent people, when Macbeth found out that Banquo’s son, Fleance, is going to be the descendant, as well as, Banquo and Fleance did nothing and letting Macbeth do all the dirty work for them. Macbeth does not want anyone to benefit from this process except for Lady Macbeth and himself, so he decides to hire murderers to kill both Banquo and Fleance the paranoia that he possesses forces him to kill more innocent people, he cannot stop killing the innocent, once he starts he can never stop.…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The main moral of both versions is that even the hunted know fear, love, joy, and other human feelings. Perhaps they know it more so than the hunter because only a sick, demented person, deprived of happiness, would kill men simply because he was bored. Yet, in the written version, the hunted somehow turn to become the hunters. Rainsford becomes what he fears; after killing Zaroff, the man who put him through several brutal trials not only for the body, but also for the spirit, the reader can infer that he took over Zaroff’s role in society. Zaroff may have lost his life, but Rainsford lost his soul.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays