Good And Evil In Fifth Business

Improved Essays
Morality In Fifth Business: A Study of Good and Evil
Is there a difference between good and evil? Throughout Fifth Business, Robertson Davies attempts to address this seemingly simple question. Davies writes against the simple system of good vs. evil, instead arguing that there is a spectrum of morality that governs our actions instead of definitive rights and wrongs. Davies conveys this through plot and style devices woven into the narrative of the life experiences of Dunstan “Dunny” Ramsey, who encounters a variety of non-orthodox characters such as his supposed saint Mary Dempster, his friend and rival Percy “Boy” Staunton, and even himself, that challenge what society thinks of as good and evil. Throughout Fifth Business, Robertson Davies
…show more content…
In the public eye, Boy is known, liked, and respected by almost everyone due to his actions such as his service to Canada during World War II and his donations to charities such as that of Joel Surgeoner's (237) However, upon peering deeper into his life, Boy becomes much more of a morally mixed character. He effectively causes the mental decline of Mary Dempster through his throwing of the snowball and later refuses to accept his role in the degradation of her mental state. He uses his company, the Alpha Corporation, as a means to help the poor during the Great Depression, but is almost purely motivated by the vast monetary gain that he stands to gain from others’ financial struggles (237). His rapid rise in social standing causes the destruction of his wife Leola Cruikshank, but he makes no attempt to help save her . However, Boy views himself as the constant moral good for the majority of the novel, as can be seen by his overwhelming arrogance; however, he eventually realizes that his entire life has been unfulfilling due to his constant pursuit of his own selfish definition of “good,” leading to a passage that, in stark contrast to Boy’s outwardly positive appearance, channels despair and a feeling of uselessness that eventually leads to his fall from grace and eventual demise (227). Although Boy viewed himself as a force for good, his actions indicated a much more …show more content…
Dunny is, much like Boy, also incredibly narcissistic, which can be seen by the condescending tone that Dunny takes throughout the narrative, as well as in the object of the narrative itself (6) Dunny’s experiences also indicate a much more mixed view of morality than a simple binary system. He observes, rather than acts, on events such as the downfall of Leola and Boy, while placing himself in the company of morally grey characters, even befriending Lisel a representation of the devil. This all gathers together to paint the picture of someone that, while not being able to be definitively called evil, can certainly not be called good due to his morally questionable actions. He fails to save many of the characters who face crises during the book, including Leola, Boy, and eventually even Mary Dempster. Davies uses Dunny as an example of his case against the system of good and evil because even as the protagonist and main character who attempts in every possible way to convey himself as the moral good in the story, he still fails to convey this sense due to his own immoral actions and inaction as others commit immoral actions or destroy themselves around him. However, Dunstan never repeats Boy’s mistake of assuming that morality is black-and-white; he befriends the devil and makes a saint of a madwoman, demonstrating

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    In the stories and movies of today, heroes are portrayed and recognized as the powerful figures wearing capes and masks who save countless lives and who defeat a terrorizing enemy, yet not all heroes must look the part. Wikipedia defines a hero as a person who helps others by combatting adversity through feats of ingenuity, bravery, or strength, often sacrificing his or her own personal concerns for the greater good. Whilst visiting the small Canadian town of Deptford in the early 1900s, surely one would not imagine it could provide a home to such a hero as Dunstan Ramsay. From the beginning to the end of Robertson Davies’ Fifth Business, the character of Dunstan Ramsay unconsciously demonstrates all the qualities that define a hero. Ramsay establishes his heroism in the novel during his childhood that leads up to the Great War; during his struggle throughout the war that leads to his return home; and after the return to Deptford until the end of the novel.…

    • 1313 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Though Phineas and Gene were best friends, they couldn’t have been any more different. Throughout the novel “A Separate Peace”, these characters pushed through many trials and tribulations including death. Faced with the war and life on the battlefield, the boys were ready and able. However, not one of them was prepared for what would happen right at home. In a twist of events, Gene causes Finny to fall out of a tree and break his leg; a break that would ultimately kill him.…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The ideas of good vs evil, yin and yang, and darkness and light, have been central ideas in multiple cultures throughout the history of human civilization. Evil is seen as a darkness that consumes light, which is the good. Ray Bradbury explores the battle between good and evil in his book, Something Wicked This Way Comes by proposing the concept of peoples defects and shortcomings representing a evil that eventually corrupts the human soul and turning people into a physical manifestation of their sin and that only acts of kindness can combat the creatures of the Darkness. B3The symbolism of evil can be seen as soon as the story begins with the lightning rod salesman sensing the storm that is about to take the town which represents the evil carnival that is about to arrive. One of the main protagonists, Jim Nightshade is the devious of the two main characters, with his name Nightshade meaning literally a poisonous plant.…

    • 1328 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. How does the idea of good versus evil come into play in this story? Use examples from the text to explain your answer. The idea of good versus evil can be seen within the characters.…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He felt stuck and hopeless, with all the constant moving but encountering all the same problems. Low paying demanding jobs with cruel bosses, bullies in school, racism, and the never-ending poverty cycle. The boy looked down at the earth and kicked it hard. He says, “not yet, you can’t swallow me up yet.” He was dedicated to make something of himself and end the vicious cycle.…

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the The Magician 's Nephew by C.S. Lewis Digory and Polly travel to and through many world’s, ending up in the recently created Narnia. They by accident have unleashed a evil upon Narnia— an evil that comes back in The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe— Jadis. They have to stop Jadis from terrorizing Narnia creating a battle between good and evil in this brand new world. The theme of good verses evil comes up again in The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe against the same evil and then again in Prince Caspian. Digory sets free the evil queen Jadis from her world Charn.…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The different type of Religion in Fifth Business Expressed in many ways, religion is a substantial motif in Robertson Davies Fifth Business. Even when hidden in deep meaning, It is represented through many distinct characters, events and themes. It is a crucial part all through out Dunny 's life and every thing he experiences circulates back to his spirituality. However, Dunny is not the only character intrigued by the divine. Amasa and Boy Staunton are characters used to signify two other major types of religion: Fundamentalism and scripture twisting.…

    • 1501 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Dangers of being Certain Though doubt has always held a negative connotation in my mind, a dark shadow that looms over certainty, truth, and progress, John Patrick Shanley, through his film, not only claims but makes us feel quite the opposite: that doubt is in fact a valuable asset in gaining an objective view when determining “good” from “bad” and discovering the truth. Stanley utilises the two main characters in his film to depict the dangers of acting upon certainty without doubt. I will be exploring two research questions within my reflection: “How does relative societal rules define what is good and bad?” and “To what degree does self interest drive us to be bad?” through the comparison of the the two main characters Sister Aloysius…

    • 1848 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Brent Weeks stated, " I think that fiction is an excellent place for us to struggle with question of good and evil and humanity and inhumanity." Throughout time the words good vs. evil always have an affect on history. Why do humans battle good and evil? In fiction we read of some of the most famous battles with good vs. evil. Two of the most classic stories that we read in this course are The Cask of the Amontillado, and Othello.…

    • 1677 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Good Vs. Evil In The Road

    • 2042 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The line between the good and the bad is blurred in a world such as the one depicted in The Road. It is hard to define a “good guy” and a “bad guy” as the novel categorizes them. The child asks his father various times for confirmation of their status as the “good guys”, the people who do not eat other people or victimize those who are weaker. The father although describes them as those who “…keep trying. They dont give up” (McCarthy 53), people who persevere even in the face of utter chaos and destruction.…

    • 2042 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The man’s love for his son leads him to selflessly give up himself, so he can provide the boy with the physical, emotional, and spiritual necessities he feels are important. The strong religious base the man has becomes apparent in how he views the boy. Being trapped in such a dark world could easily bring on the idea that trying to raise a child is impossible or even crueler for the child than death.…

    • 1789 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Author, Christopher Hawke, wrote, “How shallow to presume war exists only within the physical world. Battles are waged for mind and soul, where things far from comprehension are confronted.” David Foster Wallace’s use of characterization throughout “Good People” paints a picture of a protagonist fighting several simultaneous inner battles for his own mind and soul. As Lane A. Dean weighs superficial predicaments like his pending relationship with Sheri and the fate of their unborn child, his inner battles take precedence. The story is a written navigation of Lane’s internal conflicts: honesty versus hypocrisy, faith versus temptation, and “good” versus “bad.”…

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brothel Boy Case Study

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages

    With the help of the villagers, Blair was able to research the life story about the brothel boy, along with the crime he committed. The Brothel Boy is far from a boy, as he is roughly twenty or so years old, who was born and raised in the Brothel. He was the son of a woman who worked in the brothel as a prostitute, but died shortly after the boy’s birth, and a man who was unknown. Therefore, the brothel keeper took him in to raise him. It was extremely apparent that the boy was uneducated and retarded, “The boy was obviously stupid.”…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee ‘The consequences of evilness on others and how good and evil can coexist in a person’ One main theme, which is commonly seen throughout ‘To Kill a Mockingbird’, is the coexistence of good and bad people in society, and how the evilness of people can affect others. The protagonist, Scout, and her brother, Jem, think that everyone in Maycomb is good, from their childish perspectives. Throughout the story, Jem and Scout both start to develop and they learn how to not be affected by the malice of others. They learn through their father and from experience.…

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It is inevitable to experience a series of conflicts throughout life. Anthony Burgess portrays different types of conflicts that Alex goes through in the novel “A Clockwork Orange”. Although the book depicts significantly horrific events, every human can relate to the overarching problems that Alex faces. The idea about being a good or bad person frequently arises throughout the novel. As Alex is out with his buddies causing chaos in the town, he starts to contemplate the choice of being a good person versus the choice of being a bad person.…

    • 1757 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays