Identity In Tanizaki's Joji

Improved Essays
By championing modernity, Tanizaki’s Joji also facetiously contradicts the heroic subject invented by modernity. The conventional narrative wherein the protagonist rejects the modern world he was born into in favour of an identification with the past is transposed by Tanizaki who portrays Joji choosing to engage with the spaces of modernisation, by frequenting the cafes, dance halls and department stores with Naomi. In doing so, Tanizaki has created an embodiment of the restless youth of Japan, who dismiss traditional culture as obsolescent, a tiresome ‘set of formalities’.

Tanizaki’s later work Some Prefer Nettles, also addresses themes of identity. Published in 1928, the plot documents the stagnation in a marriage after several years of mutual disinterest between husband and wife. In a similar vein to Naomi, Tanizaki again uses a relationship as an agent to set up his plot and develop thematic intent. The main character, Kaname, is faced with a choice as to whether or not to continue the unhappy marriage. In the text, Tanizaki appears to
…show more content…
A compact becomes a mirror reflecting the self, and Tanizaki’s Old Man is used to imply that in modern Japan, the focus on the exterior self is all-consuming. Tanizaki suggests an interpretation of an essential Japanese identity as being mired in a perception of indefinable self, a self of exterior surfaces which mask the reality. Tanizaki’s use of puppets becomes a clever metaphor for these surface realities. O-hisa, symbolising an idealised, artifactual femininity linked to an authentic Japanese identity, grows less credible as Tanizaki portrays O-hisa resenting tradition’s yoke. In one sense, O-hisa becomes a puppet, embodying a sentimental past and the rejuvenation of lost origins and identity, yet in another, could be regarded as a false prophet for the genus of identity Kaname

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Manchu Girl Analysis

    • 1549 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Kyoko constantly nags Toshio, saying things like “you ought to go to America too,” and often boasts about the American life as described by the Higgins’ family. The constant comparisons Toshio makes between the Japan and American appearance, culture, and habits demonstrates the sense of inferiority that people felt in post-imperialist Japan. Nevertheless, as the arrival of the Higgins’ was inevitable, so was the presence of Americans in Japan. Because Toshio’s resentment towards Americans came from his own experiences with the war, it became further enhanced through the penetration of American culture after the war in the form of American hijiki, chewing gum, MJB coffee and so on. Ultimately, literary pieces like “Child of Okinawa” and “American hijiki” with their extremely sexualized and anti-American atmosphere, were able to effectively express the psychological loss of…

    • 1549 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the introduction of the book Staged Seduction: Selling Dreams in a Tokyo Host Club, Akiko Takeyama discusses the socioeconomic factors that contributed to the creation of neoliberal society, which created women who are willing to spend money on hosts and men who are willing to provide those women hosting services, which developed hosting industry in Tokyo. To discuss the rise of the industry, it is crucial to understand the role neoliberalism plays in the post industry society. In the 1980s, the governmental policies on economic and labor systems emphasized individual freedom of choice, and this neoliberal ideal urged young men, including hosts to seek individual success by working as hosts (Takeyama 7). At the same time, more and more young women were able to obtain a disposable income because of new service industries that allowed them to join the flexible labor; and with the help of economic prosperity brought by the bubble economy, those women shaped an affluent consumer culture, which led them to spend money on hosts (Takeyama 7).…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    You know, there’s so much that you can talk about in this world – trust me, I get told that I talk way too much and yet speak such little. But there’s one thing I really find interesting, and that would be journeys. They’re an ongoing paradigm that really makes you wonder about what sort of world we live in – they constantly challenge the whole ideals and quirks that we know about not just only ourselves, but also the world around us. Take Peter Goldsworthy’s book Maestro for example, it’s constant use of tasteful contrast and setting arouses the concept of growing up primarily through the unique themes of both music and the development of interpersonal relationships.…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Silence In Obasan

    • 1289 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “Shikata ga nai” are words that has occurred in the minds of many Japanese Canadians, “Shikata ga nai” translates to “nothing can be done or helped”. These proverbs are used to define the silence that has consumed the lives of the Japanese Canadians during the prejudice demands of the government during the internment in 1942. In Joy Kogawa’s harrowing novel Obasan, the Canadian government discriminates harshly against the Japanese Canadians during the internment. The Japanese Canadians do not protest, instead they keep themselves peacefully while living in silence in the interior of Canada. Kogawa highlights the theme of silence, the silence that is kept quiet but becomes beneficial and the unspoken silence that is dangerous.…

    • 1289 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Genji Classical Hero

    • 2111 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Genji, the protagonist from Murasaki Shikibu’s novel The Tale of Genji, should be considered a classical hero. Although it can be contested whether or not, on the whole, Genji completely meets the standards of a classical hero, it is also important to consider that the novel was not written with Genji designed as a classical hero. That being said, when comparing the traits of a classical hero to the traits of Genji, there is significant overlap which leads to a strong argument in support of Genji being a classical hero. For the purposes of this paper, a classical hero will be defined as a person who stands others in their society as they exhibit exceptional qualities in areas that their culture values but these heroes also ultimately have a…

    • 2111 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Often, Haruki Marukami’s short stories are one-sided and only demonstrate one side to gender representations. Most of Marukami’s fictional stories exemplify patriarchy in Japan, during which his female characters are positioned as objects for the subjectivity of males. The women used in Murakami ‘sworks are not empowered by feministic views; thus, the female subjects do not stand up for their own well-being. Throughout Haruki Marukami’s stories, female characters are used to represent the realities that several females faced in contemporary Japan, such as: isolation and seclusion, contradictive feminism, and fierce violence. This is evident in Marukami’s…

    • 1379 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Joy Kogawa's Obasan Essay

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In Joy Kogawa’s Obasan, the narrator reflects on her past memories with yearning and melancholy. Her reflection time spans back to “three decades ago,” yet the narrator still remembers her vivid experience on the train. Overall, the simple passage about the narrator’s dream indicates her complex attitude toward the past: melancholy and avoidance, but also yearning for the happiness. The first part of the passage, written from first person perspective plural, signifies the narrator’s complex attitude toward the past. In the beginning, the narrator indicates “we” are “hammers and chisels,” which are inanimate tools, and later indicates “we” “are sent” and “are those pioneers,” which are human actions.…

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    A recurring motif that Mishima uses in the novel is the sea, which is viewed as powerful, independent and glorious much like traditional Japan. Due to Ryuji’s close association with the sea and antipathy for land, Noboru admires him. This is evident through Mishima’s use of strong diction and imagery when describing Ryuji, detailing the “ridge of gold across his shoulders” (12) and how “his flesh looked like a suit of armour” (11). The use of gold incites images of glory and achievement while the simile comparing his skin to armour indicates strength and honour. This portrayal of Ryuji indicates that Mishima values both Ryuji and present Japan because of their links to traditional Japanese culture and the possibility for glory.…

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Chasejamison Akilah Manar-Spears #16 CCS 100/1 Prof. Del Castillo The Revolution Begins at Home: A Societal Projection of One Joto’s Quest for Identity “In Search of My Queer Aztlán” by Luis H. Román Garcia is a beautiful and vulnerable piece of autoethnography: a mix of introspective, narrative, and academic writing that ties his personal experience to the larger social issue of homophobia in Chicano culture. Garcia defines and narrates his own struggle with the concepts of home, school, and sexuality due to his queer Chicano identity. These written experiences introduce the reader to the process and multi-dimensionality of identity, and reveal deeply entrenched family trauma. Analysis of his story, as well as its impact on his sense of…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Heart Of A Samurai Essay

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages

    During the year of 1841, a young boy’s life changes forever after one small change in the weather. The Heart of a Samurai by Margi Preus is a wonderful novel, because it has an amazing setting and characters, suspenseful events, and is during a big time in American history. The story is about a teenage boy named Manjiro who lives in Japan, and is with four other fishermen on a boat doing their normal, everyday job. After a large sea storm, Manjiro and the four other fishermen get stranded on an island and have to figure out how to survive with the lack of resources. An American boat soon appears and Manjiro and the four other fishermen sail to America.…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unlike Tanizaki fall in love Japanese modernism, Kobayashi Takiji depicts the dark world under Japanese modernism. The things that display in The Crab Cannery Ship are totally different from Tanizaki’s Naomi. These distinctions are resulted by the development of capitalism. The poverty gap is magnified in the early stage of capitalization because of the incomplete social system. It can be noted that although the protagonists, Kawai and the workers in the ship, are in the same social level namely working class, they completely live in distinguished circumstances.…

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Known for her stories about adolescents struggling towards adulthood, Higuchi Ichiyō creates a small world full of contrasting young characters in one of her famous works, “Child’s Play”. Also known as “Takekurabe”, which translates to “growing up”, the children of the story cross the line that separates child from adult during a period of individualism and edification. Although “Child’s Play” embraces the purity of the coming-of-age theme, it adds darker elements in order to show the realistic sides to growing up. Despite how the Meiji restoration period provides chances to practice self-interests, society forces upon the children certain roles that it expects them to partake in without letting them decide their fates. As the children age,…

    • 1723 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Kagero Diary Analysis

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Kagero Diary written in the 10th details life in the Heian Period. The author, addressed as The Mother of Michitsuna provides commentary towards her life as a married noblewoman. The Mother of Michitsuna’s writing provides a gendered voice in the text, effectively showing the text is by a woman and she is aware of her womanhood. The author effectively conveys this style through the subject matters focused and illuminated in the diary, and a sense of awareness of her place in society.…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Most of the people, except Yasuo and Chiyoko, on the island kept the traditional views and values of Japanese culture while slow influence of western culture was introduced. Chiyoko embraces this aspect and she longs for Tokyo where “almost all nature had been put into uniform, and the little power of nature that remained was an enemy” (80). The main difference between the city and island is the absence of nature. The city views nature as a foe while the islanders cannot live without it. Shinji is one of the “youths of Uta-jima who had never before left the island” (55).…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Japanese Popular Culture Japanese culture, particularly traditional Japanese culture has plenty of roots in traditional Chinese culture. However, Japanese culture is rich and diverse, dating back to 10,000 BC when the Jomon people first settled in Japan. It is widely known for its traditional arts and its contemporary pop culture. Nowadays in Japan it is still possible to notice kimono-clad women shuffling down the street with umbrellas overhead and oversized sumo wrestlers battling competitors out of the ring. Moreover, a sophisticated cuisine, unique social customs and refined performing and visual arts also contribute to a culture which has become attractive and sometimes fashionable for plenty of foreigners.…

    • 1721 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays