Compare And Contrast Santiago In The Old Man And The Sea

Improved Essays
Hook: The definition of a hero is a person who is admired or idealized for courage, outstanding achievements, or noble qualities (“Hero”). B. Link: In The Old Man and the Sea, Santiago encounters many challenging events in which he overcomes. Through his accomplishments, Santiago’s actions display a man who is courageous, determined, and humble. On the other hand, there is Henry Fleming who enlisted in the war to become a hero, but by the end of The Red Badge of Courage, Henry remains a coward. C. Thesis: Henry Fleming sees himself as a courageous young man, yet he does not demonstrate characteristics of a hero; Santiago, however, does not consider himself a hero, yet is truly a hero.
II. Body A. First Topic Sentence: Throughout The Old
…show more content…
5. Overall, Henry longed to be known as a hero and eventually thought of himself as a hero because of his achievements in battle. C. Third Topic Sentence: Even though Santiago does not acknowledge himself as a hero, it is evident that he shows many characteristics of a heroic leader. 1. In the Old Man and the Sea, Santiago is determined to be a great fisherman and he doesn’t let his fears get in the way. 2. For example, Santiago thought about how other fisherman fear not being able to see land in a small boat during hurricane season, but being alone didn’t scare him (Hemingway 60-61). 3. Santiago was content with being out at sea alone, but he still wished for his young friend Manolin to be with him. 4. Santiago was given heroic proportions and was powerful in his trade. He never gave up against the marlin or the shark. Against the shark he says, “fight them until I die” (Burhans). 5. For three days santiago was at battle with the fish of the sea enduring physical discomfort from lack of sleep, sitting in the beating sun all day, his hands cramping, etc. But despite his old age and the pain he endured, Santiago continued to fight through his hardships in order to get the …show more content…
Fourth topic sentence: Even though Henry Fleming viewed himself as a hero, throughout the book, he did not demonstrate qualities of a hero. 1. Instead Henry exhibited cowardice, lied to his comrades, and ignored those in need around him. 2. For example, during battle, Henry ran away like coward. “He too, threw down his gun and fled. There was no shame in his face. He ran like a rabbit” (Crane 39). 3. Then towards the middle of the book, Henry encounters a tattered man who needs a friend to talk to and is in great pain from the wounds on his body. Eventually, Henry abandons the tattered man for his own good (Crane 59-66). 4. Then on Henry’s way back to the regiment, he gets hit by one of his fellow soldiers riffle and the “loud soldier” thinks that he has been shot in battle. Wilson admires Henry as a fighter and says his wound and says that is a “badge of courage” (Smith). 5. During his conversation with Wilson, Henry does not acknowledge how he actually got the wound. Instead he lies to the “loud soldier” to show that he received a “badge of courage.”
III. Conclusion A. Santiago endured many characteristics of a hero, but did not acknowledge

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    “Many lives will be save, because I was able to see through to the soul of the world,”(Paulo Coelho 61). This quote explains that Santiago saw to the soul of the world so he could save everyone. This helps to develop Santiago’s courage, because deep down he knew he had to take the risk to save many lives, and if he was wrong about the omens he would be killed. This develops his character in a way that shows that he has matured, and knows when it is a good time to take a risk, as well as showing the courage that he…

    • 857 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The scratching pain of the contact made him draw a long breath through his clinched teeth” (70). After taking this blow and lying about how he receives it, Henry has to live with the guilt of lying about how he got his mark of courage. The mark ironically becomes a mark of guilt and cowardice, instead of one with courage. Through irony, Crane constantly restates the point that the expectations of society have no real value on the battlefield, only the abilities of…

    • 1699 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In Santiago, the central character of the Old Man And The Sea, Ernest Hemingway created a, ‘’Code Hero’’ who personifies courage. In the novel Santiago states, “Fish, I'll stay with you until I am dead” (Santiago). This quote means that Santiago will not give up on the fish. He will continue to hunt and capture the fish until he dies, because he won't give up no matter the circumstances or how much trouble the fish is giving him. Santiago saying he will stay with the fish till he dies makes him very courageous in many ways.…

    • 175 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Henry Fleming is a young teenager who dreams of feeling the triumph of war. He is very self motivated and has thoughts of the field of battle. Henry decides to leave his home and mother to join the Union Army. Henry has wants to be a hero like in the Greek myths, so he enlists in the Union Army. His reasons for wanting to win glory are not fully supportive, but all the cons and negatives do not bring him down.…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Red Badge of courage starts off by introducing readers to the main character, a young man named Henry Flemmings. Henry, being an impulsive teenager, decides to enlist in the Union army in order to fight the south during the Civil War to prove that he is a strong and brave man. Throughout his training henry is eager to go into battle to prove himself, however this feeling does not last long once he is faced with the immediate danger of battle. During Henrys first battle he becomes very nervous and fearful that he might die so he decides to run away from the battle. After a while Henry decides to come back to find many soldiers wounded.…

    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Within "The Red Badge of Courage", Henry, the main character, prominently displays ever-occurring acts of courage. As the prelude of war is presented within the story, Henry exudes confidence about fighting in the war. However, when he arrives and officially engages in the war, he is startled and seemingly frightened upon what he then experienced. This is understandable considering that he new to the true idea of war and later he begins to adapt to how the war is presented in a sense of casualties and other horrid events that followed. His first act of courage would be his drive into the war against the confederates and while previously he was somewhat cowardly, he would later find the initiative to fight as his squadron was labeled as being…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    1. " The youth kept the bright colors to the front. He was waving his free arm in furious circles, the while shrieking mad calls and appeals, urging on those that did not need to be urged, for it seemed that the mob of blue men hurling themselves on the dangerous group of rifles were again grown suddenly wild with an enthusiasm of unselfishness. From the many firings starting toward them, it looked as if they would merely succeed in making a great sprinkling of corpses on the grass between their former position and the fence. But they were in a state of frenzy, perhaps because of forgotten vanities, and it made an exhibition of sublime recklessness.…

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Coined by Stephen Crane, The Red Badge of Courage meticulously delineates the subtle yet tremendous psychological changes within a youthful soldier named Henry Fleming. The story took place during the American Civil War, a deplorable time period when Romanticism replaced Realism. Various qualities and sentiments such as trepidation, cowardice, humility, courage, and wisdom are discovered throughout the novel. Most importantly, The Red Badge of Courage illustrates how Henry achieved his manhood by portraying his transformation over the course of the book. Even though Henry did achieve his maturation and manhood at the end of the book, he was indisputably a craven neophyte of the war when he first enlisted.…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sometimes you’re not always who you want to be. Henry wasn’t who he wanted to be during the beginning of The Red Badge of Courage. He was very self-absorbed and selfish, but he thought he was going to go through with fighting alongside the other sergeants. I believe by the end of the novel Henry had grown into adulthood. He showed signs of maturity, he wasn’t fighting to save himself, but to save others, and he started to except his own flaws and mistakes.…

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Henry Fleming was a youth that had wanted to enlist. Some of his personality traits are one that needs courage. He lacked courage that was needed for him during the war. This would come to him during the time of him facing the battles. Henry is an idealistic and completely self-absorbed teenager.…

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even when Henry hears that his army is winning, he still runs in fear. Henry finally slows down and hears of a new battle beginning. He then returns to the same battle field he ran from earlier. On his way to the battle field he sees many wounded men returning from getting medical assistance. Henry meets one of these wounded soldiers who calls himself "a tattered soldier.”…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Topic Sentence - The youth admires courageous men and wishes he himself could have some moving him along the path to becoming a man. B. Main Point 1 - To gain courage you have to want it, when the youth decides he wants to change his attitude he changes his destiny. C. Quote - “ At times he regarded the wounded soldiers in an envious way, he conceived persons with torn bodies to be peculiarly happy. He wished that he to had a wound, a red badge of courage” (Crane 52). D. Analysis - As the youth sees soldiers who have fought and been courageous it helps him take the next step to gaining some of his own.…

    • 1353 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I have chosen to analyze the essay, “Heroism: Why Heroes are Important”. The article was written by a Professor of Philosophy, Scott LaBarge. He unquestionably felt strongly that a person having a hero is vitally important. He goes in depth about his personal hero Thoreau, and he claims that he wouldn’t know where he’d be without him (1). He talks about how deep this connection from his hero is through being convinced “that living deliberately meant becoming a philosopher” (1).…

    • 1273 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After the old man comes home, he told the boy:” They truly beat me.” (Page 122) This may seems contradictory to what he said before. However, accepting the reality is what brings him upon the masses. It is always easy for people to claim victory, but it’s really hard to accept the fact when one he fails. After the fierce battle with the sharks, Santiago accepted that the sharks have beaten him.…

    • 641 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Santiago is an elderly fisherman, owns a small boat and fishes without a companion, yet he still traveled out farther than any of the other boats. He let the fish take him so far into the gulf that he did not see any sight of land, yet only said one statement about this, “ Even if he were as young as the other fishermen with a bigger boat and with a crew, he would still be on the only boat out there since no one goes out that far. That shows a lot of courage on his part and he only talked sparingly about the boy not being with him, sometimes saying things like, “I wish I had the boy” (45). Also, how he continues his work knowing it would not end up well for him. He knows his physical ability is not at its peak and that he is also mentally weakening as well, both because of age, and he also knows it will be difficult and treacherous with him being alone.…

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays