Their Eyes Were Watching God Critical Analysis

Improved Essays
All around the world there have been many cases of sexual and physical abuse against women. Such is the case in “Bluest eye” by Toni Morrison and the movie “Their Eyes were Watching God” by Zora Neale Hurston. Likewise, in Natacha Clerge contemporary review that shares a similar perspective. In all three works there is a horrible turn of events that leads to desperate measures.
The two main characters from “Bluest eye” and “Their Eyes were Watching God” have a very difficult life that’s full of different emotions. In the “Bluest eye” a young girl and insecure of her physical features, Paula, constantly gets reminded of how “ugly” she is. She gets bullied, ignored, and her mother, Pauline an isolated, and insecure, calls her a “nasty little
…show more content…
Paula, from “Bluest eye” one day is washing the dishes. Her father, Cholly was abandoned by his parents, and then later his aunt who raised him died when he was a teenager, he has a crazy and embarrassing life. He finds Paula while she’s washing the dishes and brutally rapes her. Later when her mother finds her unconscious, she doesn’t believe her and ends up beating her. Paula ends up getting pregnant. Like Paula, Janie also experienced physical abuse. She had enough of being Jody’s little puppet wife and she confronts him in front of the towns people. Out of anger Jody savagely beats her. Their marriage broke down and she is happy once more. She goes out with different men, but when she meets Tea Cake, she immediately feels a spark of mutual attraction. She dates him and then marries him nine months later after Jody’s death. They move to the everglades and a hurricane hits. As they flee Tea gets bitten by a rabid dog. Tea goes crazy because of the bite and then starts accusing Janie for cheating and starts shooting at her with a pistol. In the heat of the moment and the need to protect herself, she takes the pistol and kills Tea. She did what she had to do to protect herself, unlike Tania from the article” Violence against women and the AIDS epidemic in Haiti” by Natacha Clerge. She says 'I have sustained violence in all shapes and forms during the six years of my life with him

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    We also recognize that Janie’s willingness to even provide the exterior life demanded by others is slowly coming to an end. This becomes apparent during a conversation between Janie and Phoeby regarding the attitude Janie should be displaying as a mourning wife. In response to Phoeby telling her she should act more upset in front of the townspeople, Janie says: Let 'em say whut dey wants tuh, Phoeby. To my thinking mourning oughtn 't tuh last no longer than grief" (93). Thus during the transition between Joe and her next husband, Janie emerges as a new woman, ready to dictate which life she lives. It is in this state of readiness that Janie meets Tea Cake. In every respect, Vergible “Tea Cake“ Woods is Joe Starks 's character foil, his feminized nickname “Tea Cake” offers a gentler kind of masculinity and “his surname represents a healthy black identity compared to the sterility implied in Joe 's” (Susan Edwards Meisenhelder, ). One should note that although Tea Cake is all Janie seems to wants in a relationship, she is still very sure to establish her dominance early on by setting the boundaries regarding where and when they meet. Anyways, regarding Tea Cake and Joe, Hurston stresses this contradistinction by painting Tea Cake as emphatically black and by highlighting his resistance to the hierarchical values Starks embraces from dominant white culture. By teaching Janie how to play checkers, shoot, to drive, and by inviting her to work alongside of him, Tea Cake breaks down the rigid gender definitions Joe sought to impose upon Janie, the restrictions of her interior life. By doing these things, Tea Cake brings Janie into the cultural life of the black community and builds a relationship with her grounded on expression and reciprocity which encourages Janie to “Have de nerve tuh say whut [she] mean '" (165). As a result of all this, Janie has been able…

    • 1919 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An allusion is an indirect reference to something famous or ta a person, place or happening in history. People use them every day whether its intentional or not. Most people can relate to Bible allusion because they are well known. In Zora Neal Hurston’s book “Their Eyes Were Watching God,” she uses allusions to explain the plot and Janie’s role as the protagonist. Zora Neal Hurston the stories Saul’s daughter and David, Methuselah and keys to the kingdom as allusions in her novel.…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Their Eyes Were Watching God is the compelling tale of Janie Crawford, a remarkably unique woman for her time. Intelligent and strong, Janie refuses to fall into societal traps set for young women regarding marriage, duty, and contentment. In appearance, she is described as extraordinarily beautiful, with long hair in braids and an attractive figure, and has no problem catching the attention of men. Janie is habitually adventurous and curious, and not pleased by doing the same thing for too long. The times she is forced into complacency, she becomes miserable and restless. This can be observed when she marries Logan Killicks and is expected to be a housewife, and also when she runs away with the charismatic Joe Starks…

    • 416 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As Pecola ends up descending into madness by the end of the book and her story, many of the factors that hurt her were results of systemic racism as she was unable to be comfortable in her own skin since she was a black girl and not as “pretty” as Shirley Temple or Maureen Peal, and when she ended up pregnant and taken out of school, she was too blind by her wish for blue eyes and her promise by the interracial “Soaphead Church” to properly realize what was going on and how to properly recover from it. This situation is described at the book’s end as “A little black girl yearns for the blue eyes of a white girl and the horror at the heart of her yearning is exceeded only by the evil of fulfillment.” (Morrison, page 204) In addition, the only example of violent racism in the book serves only to be a motivator for the acceptance of systemic racism by Cholly Breedlove and it is partially the cause of Cholly and Polly’s unstable marriage that persists until Cholly runs away from his problems at the end of the book. Thus, Toni Morrison tries to teach through her book the lesson that both the violent and non-violent results of systemic racism can be…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Janie a young African American lady was faced with a choice between, love, romance, happiness and stability, sensibility and family approval. One man an old farmer asked for her hand in marriage. Janie knew if she said yes she would be taken care of but not always happy. A young man with lots of money how ever, stole Janie 's heart and gave her the choice to risk her future and run away with him. This risk would allow janie 's romantic desires to run wild and let her child like freedom sing. Janie chose everlasting joy over a reality of security.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In Hurston’s book “Their Eyes Were Watching God”, the tone shows deep appreciation and celebration of the affluence of African-American culture. Many scenes dwell on colorful stories and playful conversations among neighbors in black communities. More than anything, Hurston’s text is compassionate toward all of its characters. Although Janie -the main character-condemns some characters for their unforgivable sins, the text takes the time to explain the thoughts and emotions of every major character giving readers the context necessary to understand why each character acts. Readers can see the often-logical, and emotional motivations for each character’s…

    • 96 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    At the end of “The Bluest Eye”, Claudia reflects on the differences between she and her sister, Frieda, and Pecola. She explains that the two siblings "had defended [them]selves since memory against everything and everybody...Nobody paid [them] any attention, so [they] paid every good attention to [them]selves," (Morrison Bluest 191). Unlike Pecola, who quite literally goes insane by the end of the novel, Claudia and Frieda can adapt to their environment, preserving their sanity and achieving success. Sethe and her daughter Denver are similar to the two girls because their house “124 was spiteful. Full of a baby’s venom…by 1873 [they] were its only victims” (Morrison Beloved 1). The supernatural aspects of the novel are made prominent from the beginning, as this quotation starts the book. Sethe and Denver are confined within the home and encumbered by the supernatural character Beloved. In addition to being burdened by their living environment - which is consistently emphasized throughout the novel - they are also oppressed by their community’s social standards. An example of this is in Sula, where “Nel and Sula’s estrangement offers Morrison an opportunity to examine women’s lives in and out of marriage,” (Furman par. 30). The fact that there are differences between the two women when they are in a relationship…

    • 1623 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the book, Their Eyes Were Watching God, the role of silence is very exposing. In almost all the relationships in the book they are changed by silence. If that means the person gains more power by being silent or loses power and is too afraid to speak up. Not only in this book but in life silence has much more of a role than just not talking and sometimes it goes unnoticed but it always has an effect.…

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Experiences and overcoming conflicts can either help one achieve self realization or hinder their view of himself. In Zora Neale Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God and Jhumpa Lahiri’s The Namesake, both Janie and Gogol Ganguli struggle to find their true identity due to a lack of support from their relationships, societal discrimination and negative experiences. Ultimately, both Janie and Gogol are able to overcome these obstacles through determination which helps them achieve self-realization.…

    • 1845 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Within her first marriage, Janie’s view takes shape through the details of being forced to cook and expected to work as hard as a man while simultaneously receiving no affection in the relationship. These specific details of hard labor and the absence of love reveal her unhappiness, yet they contrast her aging grandmother’s ideas of security through marriage. Later in the story, following the death of her second husband, Janie once again encounters contradiction to her viewpoint as she pursues another relationship – the people of the town gossip about her and condemn her actions. Janie describes her relationship with Tea Cake through details such as his use of manners when addressing her at the store and his continual love during his visits which she views as sincere. The specific details of his formal conduct and devotion in love help to shape Janie’s view of Tea Cake as a perfect husband who will respect her and love her, which help transform the opinion of the reader as they acknowledge Janie’s circumstances and motives through her eyes. Through the specific details of her previous marriage as well as the details of her relationship with Tea Cake, the author shows Janie’s feeling of justification and satisfaction as she finally finds true love, developing sympathy from the reader as they witness her struggles and…

    • 1654 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Everyone wants to fit in. They don’t want to draw attention to themselves, and just carry along blended so they don’t get called out for who they are. Nowadays conformity is so common due to the fact that society has outlined some stereotypes for women, men, and many other groups of people and if one does not belong in a prescribed group, he or she receives criticism and in addition to the downgrading commentary, the stereotypes personally hinder him or her from what he or she wants in life. In Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston, conformity is a prominent issue as Janie, the main character, is constantly oppressed as a result of her “heretical” actions and desires, which essentially show how one can only achieve happiness by…

    • 136 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sweat tells the story of Delia Jones, a humble, timid woman trapped in a marriage with an abusive man who takes pride in mistreating her. The story opens up on a spring night in Florida, with Delia busy going about her job as a washwoman. Delia has been married to a hard drinking man Sykes for fifteen years, and he has never treated her right. Hurston starts to describe Sykes as a “womanizer” and how nobody in the town likes him and how they thought about hanging him. Delia's neighbors all comment Sykes and Bertha and sympathize with Delia, aware of the abuse she has been exposed to. Sykes bring a snake into the house, hoping to scare Delia out. And one day, she finds it in the laundry basket and runs out to the barn in fright. Later that…

    • 858 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Bluest Eye Themes

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In The Bluest Eye, we don't see how Pecola life turns out but we do see how all the light in her world suddenly disappeared. Cholly’s childhood shaped him into becoming abusive with everyone around him, ruining his daughter Pecola's life and reputation by raping her and impregnating her. Geraldine was another character that was thought to be more like a white person instead of black even though she had a black blood in her system and her action slowly spread to her only son Junior. Even though Pecola’s life is not fully written out is up to you to write Pecola’s future and how she is affected after the lose her baby and love…

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Home and family environment in The Bluest Eye heavily contrasts against what was traditional in 1941, which is presented through the reoccurring motif of Dick and Jane’s vibrant, content family. Contrary to the idea that home is a place where a sense of value is sustained and established, home to Pecola is a place where she is mistreated, predominantly by her own parents. This is portrayed through Pecola’s mother’s relentless care for the white family who she works for compared to the neglect of her own family. The setting and scene in which Morrison details Pecola witnessing the evident favour of someone else’s child from her own mother provides the reader insight into Pecola’s feeling that there is no safe place for her to be loved and valued. The sexual assault that Pecola experiences when own father comes home drunk and rapes her not only impregnates her physically, but also has significant repercussions on her emotional wellbeing, takes away her innocence and aids her spiral into insanity. Upon reflection, Pecola states with a timid and sullen tone the ‘dirty’ incident, illustrating her assumption that … This is heightened by the irony that a father is one who little girls look to for guidance and approval. Hence, the lack of strong familial influences in Pecola’s life has reinforced the absence of sense of home…

    • 1821 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Cholly “dropped his seeds,” his sperm, “in his own pot of black dirt,” his own daughter (Morrison 6). By introducing Pecola’s suffering, the author makes the reader question who is to blame for her rape throughout the novel. Pecola’s parents could be seen as the ones responsible for their daughter’s suffering. Morrison takes away some of the blame by making the reader consider their difficult upbringing as a possible reason for their neglect. Cholly grew up without either of his parents. At the age of thirteen, he has a traumatic incident with his first sexual experience when two white hunters force Cholly to rape Darlene. Cholly is humiliated and at the end he “[cultivates] his hatred of Darlene” for “not [being] able to protect” her (Morrison 151). The hatred towards Darlene expands to hatred for all women. Cholly’s bad experience is the reason he is seen as an oppressor to his wife and eventually his daughter for not being able to have a real emotional connection with his children. One day, Cholly questions “what could a burn-out black man say to the hunched back of his eleven-year-old daughter” as she washes some dishes (Morrison 161). He is confused by knowing that Pecola loves him and he cannot return the love back. The confusion leads to Cholly raping her. Pecola’s first sexual encounter is taken away by her own father. She never had the time to wrap her head around the…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays