# Whole-Problem Theory Vs Socrates Theory

1011 Words 4 Pages
Introduction:
In Parmenides, Zeno and Parmenides also Socrates joins in the conversation; they are talking about the theory of forms in which they are discussing. I will be discussing that the whole-problem theory can be defended, but to a certain extent. I will start off with Zeno reading a book to Socrates and their discussion about the theory of forms. I will then move on to my criticism, on why I agree with the idea that the form won’t be the same and I will disagree with the point of the forms not being equal.
Exposition:
Zeno begins by reading a book and then Socrates asks him to repeat the first hypothesis of the first argument that the book mentions. Socrates then asks him “if things are many, they must then be both like and unlike, but that is impossible, because unlike things can’t be like or like things unlike?”(Cohen 642). Then Zeno confirms that, that’s what he said. Socrates then continues on to say that if it’s impossible for things to be both liked and unlike, then
The first one is the extent problem, the next one is the whole-part dilemma and (the last one was presented by Dr. Corner) and it’s the third man argument. The extent problem is where it’s the extent of forms. For example “beautiful paintings and beautiful sunsets are beautiful because they participate in the form of beauty”(Corner). The next one is that the third man argument in which A and B share something in common. If A is large that would mean that it also share the concept of being large with B. This then introduces the concept of separation, in which “form of F is separate from the things that it causes to be F. The form of F, which also causes things to be F, is itself F”(Corner). The next problem the theory of forms faces is the whole-part dilemma. The dilemma would keep on dividing the forms. It would partake a part; from the part that is a whole and that would no longer be considered to be whole, but a part of a

• ## Socrates 'Arguments On Meno's Paradox'

Socrates has falsified all of the interpretations of the word that Meno provided him with and decides he wants to search, with Meno, for the true definition of the word. Socrates says to Meno, “So now I do not know what virtue is; perhaps you knew before you contacted me, but now you are certainly like one who does not know. Nevertheless, I want to examine and seek together with you what it may be” (Plato 70). In saying this, Socrates is admitting to Meno that he is unsure of what virtue means and, in fact, deciding that Meno does not know either. He asks Meno to join him in his pursuit of the true definition of the word, and in response, Meno presents his paradox.…

Words: 750 - Pages: 3
• ## Essay On The Purpose Of Education

In this paper I am explaining how education and our current school systems are not doing a good job of teaching people what is really important in life. I will do this by, first, sharing the views of education of the philosophers Martin Luther King Jr. and Socrates, and how Socrates would view King’s work. Secondly, I will deduct how Plato and King would feel about the education being taught today and lastly, I am going to share my own experiences and thoughts about the main purpose of education today. In King’s “The Purpose of Education,” King is trying to explain to people that when it comes to being educated, intelligence isn’t enough. He begins by speaking about how college men basically feel that college is only intended to help them plan out their own future careers and lives.…

Words: 823 - Pages: 4
• ## The Controversy Of Virtue In Plato's Meno

To begin the Protagoras, a friend and Socrates chat, then Hippocrates comes along. Hippocrates wants to become wise and wants to study under Protagoras, a Sophist. Socrates goes with Hippocrates where Protagoras is. Socrates questions why Hippocrates wants to learn from him but has no real answer, therefore, Socrates questions Protagoras to discover what he knows and teaches to his disciples/pupils. In the dialogue between Socrates and Protagoras, each questions the other on whether virtue can be taught.…

Words: 1918 - Pages: 8
• ## Stevens Luke On Power Analysis

Following this view, the classical objections have many problems. A case in this point, the first problem is about ‘ how to justify the relevant counterfactuals’. It means that he needs specifying the mechanisms such as A abstained from acting to prevent B from doing so. Furthermore, other problem is ‘ how to identify the process of the exercising of power. So, the three-dimensional view of power represents three features which are the exercise of power involve inaction that observable action, the concepts of power may be unconscious and power may be exercised by groups or institutions.…

Words: 1323 - Pages: 6
• ## Plato's Meno: A Theory Of Recollection

“ - Meno, 81c-d. Thus, follows the conclusion in Meno that education cannot teach knowledge, but rather aids a student to recall what the soul already knows, i.e. the unchangeable Knowledge of Forms. Even though we get an introduction to this theory of recollection in his first writing, you might say it’s a devotion or just a mere fascination… but if you’re familiar with his work you may know you might notice we get a reintroduction to this theory in his fourth and last writing which is Plato’s Phaedo. We know that Phaedo tells us about Socrates’s last days and his trial in court, but we must also know that it shows us how Socrates did not surrender his exploration of the nature of the soul.…

Words: 1396 - Pages: 6
• ## Republic Seven Socrates Education Analysis

In the Euthyphro, Socrates says “So we must examine again from the beginning what the pious is, since I won’t willingly give up until I learn this.” (Euthyphro Pg. 62, 15d). Socrates, the teacher, is asking Euthyphro, the student, to teach him. This allows for a better understanding for Euthyphro. As for the speech that was given during his trial, Socrates was by no means giving an apology.…

Words: 787 - Pages: 4
• ## Socrates Response To Plato

Sydney Barton Philosophy 1102 Midterm Exam In The Republic, Plato uses the main character Socrates as a mouthpiece for his own ideas and beliefs, just as he did during the entire middle period of his writings. In book I of The Republic, Socrates seeks to discover what justice is and why it is necessary for one to be just. Socrates asks Cephalus and his son Polemarchus their thoughts on his inquiry, finding error and contradiction in each of their responses. However, their responses to Socrates’ question on justice only acts as a preface to the sophist, Thrasymachus’ view on what justice is and why it is imperative for the human person to be just. Thrasymachus tells Socrates that justice benefits the stronger, or someone with a significant…

Words: 785 - Pages: 4
• ## Thoreau, Plato, And Frankl: Course Analysis

So my two Philosophers are Plato/Socrates and Frankl. The second question; what is “doing philosophy is all about”, the third question is why the philosophers we have read think philosophy is important and lastly what will I take forward or what made the most impact on how I will live my life. Discussion The first book we read was Plato’s “The Last Days of Socrates” it has stayed with me through this course. Plato’s “Crito” has so many of Socrates…

Words: 1527 - Pages: 7
• ## George Berkeley Analysis

George Berkeley, A treatise concerning the principles of human knowledge In this essay I will be discussing a few sections from George Berkeley, A treatise concerning the Principle of human knowledge. I will explain the arguments being set out by Berkeley within the text, then I will proceed to make an objection of my own, which I will respond to on behalf of Berkeley. George Berkeley starts off introducing us to his theory “to be is to be perceived”. Within the first few paragraphs of the text Berkeley essentially explain his theory of how an object or person is only there when it is being perceived by an individual. He goes into further detail stating that external objects are perceived through our senses, so our senses in themselves must…

Words: 1469 - Pages: 6
• ## What Is Justice In Plato's Republic

It goes back to the talk that Socrates has with his colleagues about their thought of justice. Is it better to be just or unjust? The first part of the book is a conversation of three regarding that topic. Defining…

Words: 1356 - Pages: 6