Confederation Vs State Power

Superior Essays
The formation of the new country brought many controversial issues to the surface of the budding government. The end of the American Revolution marked the independence of the nation and the beginning of the country built on freedom, but there was a roadblock. How was the country going to be structured? The Americans had their eyes set on democracy, the idea that promised to ensure everything that they wanted in a country. However, democracy struggled to be defined as the members of the new country wrestled with its controversial components. Americans struggled to determine how the issues of liberty versus order, federal power versus state power, and freedom versus slavery and discrimination were going to be resolved. The final answer to the …show more content…
After the United States became an independent nation, they sought to form a government that was different than the monarchal system they had separated from in Europe. In this regard, Americans were hesitant to adopt a strong federal government, yet a system of primarily state power did not seem functional. The first system of government, outlined in the Articles of Confederation, was a failure at balancing this argument. The Articles gave the states almost complete power and divulged virtually none to the federal government. This showed the severe unbalance between state and federal power and resulted in a faulty system of government that ultimately failed. In fact, since the Articles of Confederation gave no federal power, there was no way to solve the major issues of the time and almost led to the destruction of the country. The major issues included the depression after the American Revolution, Congress not meeting regularly, and the English troops still stationed in the Midwest (Class Notes, “The Early Republic”). The Constitution replaced the Articles of Confederation in 1787 to balance this issue. The constitution divided the federal state power by making three branches of government and divulging some power to the states. The executive branch, headed by the President, was given the power by the votes of the people, giving them power. The legislative branch divided consisted of people …show more content…
This issue, despite all attempts, failed to live up to the American ideal. When the Constitution was written, the issue of slavery was left mostly untouched because no decision could be made about how to resolve it. Some Americans believed that the country could not be a democracy is slavery existed, and others believed they could coexist. This issue, however, was one of the few that could not be resolved with compromise. It was one or the other, the way of the abolitionists or the slave holders. The issue was first approached with attempts at compromise: the Three-fifths Compromise and the dissipation of the Transatlantic Slave Trade (Class Notes, “The Early Republic”). However, it became apparent after the Deep South seceded from the United States that there would be no balance between democracy and slavery. Thus, the Civil War ensued. After the Civil War ended and the United Sates reformed as one nation, amendments were added to the Constitution to ensure “equality” among whites and blacks. These Amendments, the 13th, 14th, and 15th, made the two races legally equal, but due to the threats and actions of extremist groups such as the Klu Klux Klan, there was no actual social equality (Class Notes, “Between the Civil War and WWI”). The unbalance continued as Western Expansion began. Americans believed that it was their God-given destiny to expand and to spread the Word of God:

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    When the United States had just declared their independence, it was clear that governmental structure needed to be established. In 1777, the Continental Congress adopted the Articles of Confederation, which all states would ratify by 1781. The Articles of Confederation would prove to be a weak constitution, giving too much power to the states and not having a strong enough central government. This realization led to several changes being made until a new framework was implemented. The Constitution established a better relationship between central and state governments, while making sure that no form of government would become too powerful.…

    • 1083 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    However, even though the Articles of Confederation seemed viable at the time, the Constitution was a much superior. Even though the US Constitution took away power from the state governments, it did not give all power to one specific hours. Instead it gave power to separate branches which all had the ability to check the powers of the other branches. This made…

    • 1582 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After America declared its independence in July of 1776, Congress knew this was their opportunity to create something completely out of the ordinary, that would have to stand the tale of time. The following year, the Continental Congress created the Articles of Confederation, which ultimately divided the federal government from the state. This article wrote the ground rules for America's regulation of currency, foreign affairs and guidelines for war, but left out the States, to decipher their policies individually (1*). Ten years later, the Constitutional Convention knew that America needed to be seen as a whole, even with the separation of power. The Constitution was written to unionize the States with the Federal government, and was finalized…

    • 177 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The articles of confederation was the Untied States first attempt at creating a democratic government. Meaning instead of giving power to the central government they decided to divide it up with different states. But it all wasn't good, congress had trouble passing laws due to the fact that 9 of the 13 states had to agree before any laws could be passed (Doc 1). Congress did not have the power to collect the taxes needed to pay for the expense of the national government (Doc 2). Also the states refused to give the national government enough power to work correctly.…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Framers of the United States Constitution ultimately decided to give more power to the Federal government rather than the state governments because the articles of confederation wasn’t running our country in the right direction. The Articles of confederation had no central power, at all. The Federal government then became the main focus of the two contracts, because it was more stable. Under the Articles of Confederation the state held all the power and they gave some power to the federal government, which caused economic, trading and law problems. The constitution then gave more power to the federal government and gave the states less power because that would give a central power for people.…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the formation of the U.S. government, two different forms of government were initiated. At first, the Americans wanted to form a government that was nothing like monarchy, as they didn’t want a repeat of King George. The Articles of Confederation served as the first constitution of the United States, which was ratified in 1781. However, the Articles of Confederation had issues. The main issue was that the national government was too weak.…

    • 642 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After the United States declared Independence from England in 1776, many ideas, plans and compromises were made to create a system of government. The Articles of Confederation was one of the first ideas that established the functions of the national government. Shays Rebellion helped government officials realize that there needed to be improvements and plans created to stabilize the nation. Finally, agreements like the Connecticut Compromise and the three-fifths compromise allowed views from all states to be shared and come together.…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Slaves in the northern states were freed while those in the south were kept to work the land. Blacks were considered three-fifths of a person in voting standards because of the ⅗ Compromise created at the Constitutional Convention. So things still were not equal for everyone after the…

    • 576 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    1820 To 1860 Dbq Essay

    • 1710 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The period in American history from 1820 to 1860 lead to a divided nation on the brink of a civil war. One thing dividing the nation of America between 1820 and 1860 was the rise of many different political parties and the issue of states’ rights. Each politician was working for he advancement of the same country, yet had wildly different beliefs. For example, Senator John C. Calhoun of SOuth Carolina said, “We of the South will not, cannot, surrender our institutions,” when talking about slavery (Document A). While he was preaching the continuation with slavery, Democratic Congressman David Wilmot from Pennsylvania said, “The issue now presented is not whether slavery shall exist unmolested where it now is, but whether it shall be carried to new and distant regions, now free, where the footprint of a slave cannot be found” (Documented B).…

    • 1710 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Under the Articles of Confederation, the government was not completely effective because of the power imbalance, the nation's needs not being met, and financial struggles. Congress did not have strength over the people to enforce laws; the citizens desired a less powerful government after the harsh rule the British government enforced on them previously. They got a weaker government, but the Congress lost its authority to rule over the states. Citizens felt that the government lacked in stability and unable to deal with the nation's problems. A military was a basic need for the states, but because of the cost, congress struggled to pay for one.…

    • 209 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throughout the drafting of the Constitution, the ideals and philosophy behind the ideas of human rights were twisted and molded to fit the needs of both the northern and southern representatives. Considering the issue of black rights during the 18th century, the dilemma between the 2 sides was balancing on a fair. Taking into account that the north was predominantly antislavery and the south was pro-slavery, without meeting an ultimatum, the Constitution would not for the United States. The southern economy was based off of the revenue the free slave labor provided to them and the boost in a population count. The northern states contrasting with the south refused to take any of these benefits of slavery based off of the people 's ethical beliefs.…

    • 1585 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Weakness of the Article of Confederation During the course of the Second Continental Congress in 1777, the Articles of Confederation were adopted for the proposal of a central institution. This meeting started in 1775, gathered many of the most brilliant minds of that period at Pennsylvania. Delegates were sent from the thirteen colonies to represent in the convention. The convention was a series of meeting, on the attempt to solve political and social issues. One of the major concern was the concept of distribution in power.…

    • 1350 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The founding fathers cleverly designed the government in way that would prevent the abuse of power, as experienced under British rule. Back before the United States, the colonies had an odd mix of their own local governments, but ultimately subordinates to the British government and controlled by a king. Eventually, they resented the British policies and fought to gain their freedom, resulting in the formation of the United States of America (Peterson, n.d.). This experience made the creators of the Constitution very guarded, so they decided to separate government powers into 3 branches, Legislative, Executive and Judicial.…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After America’s long journey of seeking freedom from governmental oppression, the newly formed nation was skeptical when it came to the discussion of new government authority. Many Americans were still uneasy about consolidated power, while others were aware of the prevalent national instability caused by the lack thereof. Though, in the end, the Constitution prevailed and has become the cornerstone of American government, the path that led to this enduring document was gradual and filled with apprehension and debate. Both sides of the issue had very clear and valid notions about either their support or opposition to the Constitution, and in the end were able to find common ground through patience and compromise.…

    • 1123 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As The United states began a time of expansion into the west in the late 1830’s, debates over whether or not slavery would be permitted in those territories vacated by the native Americans caused great disagreements in Government and Society. While slavery is the most obvious reason for succession, Westward expansion and the rights of the new states were responsible for much of the violent conflicts that lead to the Civil War. States struggled to find common ground, but the differences between North and South and new Immigration made A series of compromises were created but by 1860 compromise had failed. Southerners feared an increase in free states would create an imbalance of power and create an advantage to the abolition of slavery.…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays