College Is A Waste Of Time And Money Critical Analysis

Improved Essays
The value of a college education has been scrutinized for years, in “Stop Scaring Students,” by Devorah Lieberman and “College Is a Waste of Time and Money,” by Caroline Bird, both authors give their detailed opinions on the value of college and give insight to both sides of the argument. College can be extremely rewarding for some students but they do not always take into consideration the hardships that occur in college, and in return tend to feel overwhelmed in debt and upset that they are not needed, all students should understand these consequences before rushing into college. Both Lieberman and Bird establish their views about the value of college in their text and can be of great help to any student weighing the benefits and the risk.
As can be seen in “Stop Scaring Students” Lieberman argues that students should be encouraged and supported to go to college, because in the long run it is an investment that will pay off. It is clear that Lieberman is an activist for college and strongly believes in the value of a college education, to clarify her views she states “All students need a healthy dose of learning opportunities that build the skills and capacities that will support
…show more content…
To emphasize her views Bird shares her research which shows that not all students belong in college. In her research there is evidence that once students are in college they become depressed, not all students are entering college for a higher education, and the belief that all students will benefit from college is untrue. For these reasons, Bird strongly believes that college is not worth the risk of being unhappy and in debt. Another key point that bird focuses on is the fact that Americans today are more concerned with their job than the pay, they desire a psychic income. Overall Bird is against students believing that everyone is fit for college and they have to go to college to have a decent

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    In the article, “College is a waste of time” by Dale Stephens, Dale gives his persuasive opinions on why college is a waste of time by giving out evidences of how college isn’t fully beneficial and describing people who are successful today without a college degree. Dale describes college as “rewarding conformity, regurgitation, and theory”, instead of, “rewarding independence, learning, and application”. Providing that college is also hungry for people’s wallet, The College Board Policy Center showed that tuitions have increased 3.6 times since 30 years ago. Not everyone needs college to be successful such as Mark Zukerberg who made it big without a diploma. Summing up the article, Dale states that in the end it’s people’s choice to look for…

    • 1046 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    College: To Go or Not to Go? Stephanie Owen and Isabel Sawhill unveiled the constructive and adverse features of obtaining a college degree in the article, “Should Everyone Go to College?” “A bachelor’s degree is not a smart investment for every student in every circumstance” (Owen and Sawhill 222). The author’s stress to their audience that college is not for everyone and…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Today, all high schools prepare their students to achieve one major goal: to attend college so they can have a successful life. There are reasons why people should attend college, but college is not worth all your time and effort. College isn’t worth it because there are other jobs that pay emplo yees well without a college degree, there are better options for education, and it’s too expensive. College isn’t worth it because there are other careers that offer the same or higher salary even if you don’t have a college degree.…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When millions of students are attending postsecondary schools, whether that be community colleges, four-year universities, or graduate schools, it is reasonable to ask for justification of a student 's education. In “Live and Learn: Why we have college,” the author, Louis Menand, proposes several answers to the question of what is the return of higher education. Menand, a university professor, was asked by one of his students, “why did we have to buy this book?” (74). This question was asking Menard to “justify the return on investment in a college education,” and led him to develop three theories, each one being a view a person could hold on the value of collegiate education (74).…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Are Too Many People Going to College?” Charles Murray, claims that there are too many people attending college. Although, this claim is a disputable one, there are two reasons as to why he believes what he does. The first reason Murray brings up is that receiving a liberal education is possible and should be completed in primary and lower secondary schools rather than in a college. Secondarily, Murray also believes that there is a countless amount of people who do not need a secondary education for their career due to those people already having the necessary skills.…

    • 407 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The value of a college degree is a dispute that is commonly contemplated, yet rarely answered. I will attempt to express my attitude towards college education, personally defined as an Associate’s Degree for returning adult students. In an effort to explain the greater benefits of a college degree despite the common rhetoric that it is not financially worthwhile, I have considered the positive and negative effects of doing so. I have examined the following articles, “Learning by Degrees and Live Chat With the Author,” “The Major and the Job Market, the dream and the reality,” and “In the Basement of the Ivory Tower,” to support my stance. When one maintains a desire to progress academically and an open-mindedness to educational demands in the…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    They Say I Say Analysis

    • 2196 Words
    • 9 Pages

    In the book, “They Say, I Say” chapter fourteen discusses the necessity for tertiary education. The fundamental focus of chapter fourteen is to determine whether or not higher education offers the bang for your buck. The chapter initiates disputes beginning with the article, “Are Colleges Worth The Price of Admission?” by Andrew Hacker and Claudia Dreifus. This article conveys a controversial issue of the rising cost of admissions and the descending quality of college education.…

    • 2196 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From the day we start school, it is drilled into our brain that college is the only way to have a good future, but that may not be the case at all. Just ask Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, and Mark Zuckerberg. Although it helps to have a revolutionary idea like these men, it is not necessary. Ordinary people can also achieve success without a college degree. At least, that’s what Charles Murray in his article “Are Too Many People Going to College?”…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this essay, “College Prepares People for Life,” by Freeman Hrabowski portrays the notion that college is an absolute requirement to prepare students for “THE REAL WORLD”. Hrabowski embellishes the fact that without college, students are not going to be ready for the competitive job market and won’t be able to reach a high level of success if they don’t have the college experience. Yes Hrabowski point of view is completely understandable because in today’s society college has become such a norm and a place if you don’t go you will ostracized for, that students have no choice then to mindless focus on something that they are not passionate about. As a joiner in high school I can vouch first-hand the peer pressure from school, friends, teachers,…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The reading wanted to educate the audience that it is not a sensible choice for young adults to attend just any college or earn any degree. Another main point the authors also wanted to express is that there are many factors that can determine the rate of return and rate of interest associated with different college degrees. The authors of “Should Everyone Go to College” also point out that there should be more information instantly available for students. It is agreeing that students should have immediate access to this information. The overall cost of the college or program, financial aid, scholarships, and more extensive details about the degrees and programs that are offered, would be very helpful to students trying to make wise decisions about their future.…

    • 1232 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Learning as Freedom”, by Michael S. Roth, is primarily a response to recent sentiments that higher education is a waste of resources. Roth states that his opposition frequently wonder why people who aren’t going to make lots of money in their future occupation bother with going to college. (1). According to Roth, advocates of this perspective see attending higher education as “buying a customized playlist of knowledge” (1), and nothing more. Therefore, if the knowledge gained will not insure the buyer great financial success, than why expend the resources to go in the first place?…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She claims that "A great majority of our nine million college students are not in school because they want to be or because they want to learn. " This is a hasty generalization which is seemingly collected from select professors and administrators on a “crisscross” lectureship. Bird reaches a conclusion based on insufficient instances. The claim, even with proper research, would not conclude that college is a waste of time and money. She does not provide any evidence, except for unnamed sources of hearsay, as support.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Cost Of College Essay

    • 2132 Words
    • 9 Pages

    They state that current American education system leaves many in crushing debt that follow them for the years after college. The opposition also believes that there are many flaws in colleges that need to be addressed, such as the downfalls of tenure and the various unnecessary expenses colleges undergo such as lavish administrative facilities and large athletics departments (Hacker and Dreifus). They also question the necessity of college by showing that many jobs do not require a college education and that there is still a high demand for workers with no degree in college. They also claim that experience gained from the time that would be spent on college is enough to start a successful career…

    • 2132 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    College Is Not the Key to Success In College is a Waste of Time and Money by Caroline Bird she explains how college was a good place for a few kids that were drawn to their academic work, but now it is stupid for kids to go to college when all they are doing is wasting their time and money. Bird is right, the only reason they go to college is to make their parents happy not for the education part. She explains that young adults in college are sad, mostly because they are just thrown into the real world without knowing what is going to happen next. They do not know what is best for them so they think going to college will help them get a better job in the long run. Most teachers, engineers, and even nurses said they do not use what they…

    • 730 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    College is Not for Everyone Today, more people than ever are attending community colleges and universities. Often, a collegiate degree is a prerequisite to meaningful employment (Pincus, 341). There is even social pressure pushing many to attend. I feel that the university education system has many structural shortcomings, and that institutions of higher learning often do not have students ' best interests at heart.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays