The Pros And Cons Of Flogging

Improved Essays
Flogging was once imposed as a form of judicial punishment and a means of discipline in schools, prison, military forces, and in private homes. Flogging is also called whipping or caning, which is a beating used with a whip or a rod with the most common blows being directed towards the victims back. The tools and methods of flogging have varied. Children have been beaten with things such as sticks, rods, straps, whips, and other objects. At school or home but else where what was widely used was the lash which had nine knotted cords of rawhide attached to a handle. The backs of condemned were lacerated frequently and salt was then poured into the wounds to increase the pain. England created the Whipping Act in 1530 this authorized the whipping of thieves, blasphemers, poachers, men and women …show more content…
Jacoby states in his article that criminals will just learn how to become a better criminal if sent to prison. Well this can also be said for corporal punishment for some this will only make the criminal think to themselves to just not get caught next time. They will then work on bettering them selves as criminals and so forth. While others may just feel so humiliated after they may go out and commit more violent crimes. Where as through our current justice system a small time offender may get something as simple as community service. Yes even then they would still just learn how not to get caught next time but no matter what the punishment is that will always be the case the offender will just figure out where he messed up last time and not do it again next time. But at least with something as simple as community service this wouldn’t humiliate or degrade the criminal to the point to where he would want to commit a more violent act. So there is no need for such a cruel and unusual punishment to be implemented within our criminal justice

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Response to "Bring Back Flogging" Jeff Jacoby is a strong advocate for bringing some of the corporal punishment ideals from the Puritans back into modern society. Additionally, the reasons Jacoby gives are agreeable and have an abundant number of sources to back them up. I personally agree with the author's stance on corporal punishment as well as his reasonings for such an opinion. These reasons being: (1) The price of keeping criminals incarcerated is expensive especially with how many inmates there are and (2) The prisons are bursting with overpopulation.…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Jeff Jacoby's essay "Bring Back Flogging," he argues against the American public's acceptance of the current state of the criminal justice system by comparing its consequences to an alternative method of flogging. By employing irony throughout the whole essay, he builds up his argument to defend a seemingly outdated method of punishment—flogging—over imprisonment, encouraging the audience to find a reasonable solution to the violence and ineffectiveness of prisons. Jacoby's unfavorable word choices about ineffective punishments and brutality orient Americans towards adopting a cynical view of jails. Later, he presents budget data and odds of catching criminals, supporting his argument with two of Americans biggest concerns: safety and…

    • 1383 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since February 1994, Jeff Jacoby has been an op-ed columnist for The Boston Globe, where the essay, “Bring Back Flogging,” was published on February 20, 1997(Jacoby 196). In this essay, Jacoby claims the argument that prison time is so inhumane and he also shows that there are many flaws of imprisonment. Therefore, he wants to persuade his audience that flogging is an effective method of punishing criminals. In order to completely understand Jeff Jacoby’s argument, I will show how he convinces his readers by analyzing his essay. Unlike general essay, Jacoby’s thesis is implied, but the readers can easily the main idea of his essay through the title.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    By the time people enter into jail or prison, they have normally been a part of the system numerous times. Trying to rehabilitate or give consequences for people’s actions that late in the game does no good in regard to enabling them to change their life style. People have to be reached much earlier than when they enter into the criminal justice system. That is why there should be more programs for youth and programs that encourage education. If youth remain in school and are also given vital resources like safe places to live, food, and positive environments then they may be less likely to commit crime.…

    • 1735 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unfortunately, no one could ever analyze the difference in results between these two forms. This is because punishment has not been the only aspect of community that has drastically changed in 200 years. No one can guess what the criminal rate would be if whipping and burning was still the main means of punishment. Would police abuse this power? Would criminals commit the same acts if it meant public pain and embarrassment?…

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This was an improvement since prior to the investigation, men were dying every day. Tortures ranged from starving to death to the use of thumbscrews (a gripping device where thumbs or fingers were slowly crushed), stocks (public humiliation, throwing rotten food at the victim), pillory (wooden frame with openings to secure the head and hands), a bull’s pizzle (a whip made from bull’s penis), skullcap (a device for the head) and of course execution if they didn’t die before. After the Gaols Committee’s investigation, keeper Warden William Acton was tried for the murder of Thomas Bliss, a carpenter and debtor, after he was tortured for trying to escape over the wall with a rope. According to White, “He’d been captured, beaten with a long club made from a bull’s dried pizzle, stamped on, loaded with heavy irons including ‘the sheers’ that forced his legs wide apart, kept in a filthy airless room, tortured with thumbscrews and with an ‘Iron-Scull-Cap’ ‘which was screwed so close that it forced Blood out of his Ears and…

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I Want To Be Free Essay

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages

    When John was an adolescent, he was just another kid living in the outskirts of St. Louis. He flew through high school without a hitch, going as far as getting a some scholarship money. As John advanced into college, many of his companions, though once good, turned to those curbed to a life of crime. One night while driving home one of his best friends from his childhood, he got pulled over, and his “companion” had, unknowingly to John, stashed heroin in his car. John, by not snitching on his friend, put all the work he’s put into his life, to a stop.…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Dbq Slave Labor

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Slaver owners punished slaves through whipping, shackling, hanging, beating, burning, abuse, branding, and imprisonment. Slaves were punished most often because of disobedience, but sometimes abuse was used simply to reaffirm the dominance of the master. Women endured sexual abuse. This act was simply rooted in the southern culture. Slave masters of the south believe that black women were just property and they could do whatever they pleased to them.…

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    While many criminal acts are symptomatic of psychopathology, some may not be. There are "normal" people who commit crimes, but research has shown that most crimes are commited by a majority with some disorder and abnormal. When it comes to dealing with criminals, I think it's important to treat the case on an individual basis. In some cases, some criminals deserve punishment to deter them from repeating the offense such as murder or rape, others would do better with treatment such as chronic marijuana users. Also, I believe labeling of particular offenders "criminal" is not a good idea for the interest of society and for the interest of the offender such as a young man who is sent to prison for smoking marijuana.…

    • 289 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The punishments are no different from one offender to the next. Judges are imposing the sentences that they are mandated to give and offenders are still making the choice to re-offend when no longer in…

    • 1217 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As many of you already know the United States has the highest percentage of its population behind bars compared to any other country. This may be related to the fact that a majority of petty crimes require mandatory sentencing. Politicians such as District Attorney Dan Conley believe that mandatory sentencing is an efficient way to protect the population from corrupt individuals as well as decreasing crime rates. However, housing all of these individuals is not cheap, the funding for this endeavor is taken directly from the taxes all of us have to pay. While I agree that petty crime offenders should compensate in some way for their crimes, further destroying their lives is not the answer.…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When Eliezer was whipped, his spirit was taken away. When Eliezer saw Idek and the Polish girl together, Idek said, “Just you wait, kid… You will see what it costs to leave your work… You’ll pay for this later….” Eliezer was being a “nuisance” to Idek so Eliezer got whipped as a punishment just like someone would do to an animal. In addition to both of those examples, all of the Jews were tattooed with numbers as their names on their left arms (42).…

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Are Shame Punishments Necessary? The problem in our society we are having now are judges wanting to find cheaper alternatives to incarcerations because it costs so much money. In June Tangney’s essay, she doesn’t agree with shame punishments. In her essay, she states points about how if people who have done nonviolent crimes receive shame punishments, they will be too embarrassed.…

    • 1518 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Prison overcrowding has become a major problem in the United States. As per, Issues and Controversies, “The United States has only 5 percent of the world’s population, but holds 25 percent of the world’s prisoners.” Housing the growing prison population is putting a strain on the federal government’s budget, costing roughly $80 billion a year. Crime rates are down, but prison populations are a growing concern. In light of these facts, we need to explore ways of reducing crime that does not involve incarceration, but still protects society.…

    • 1504 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Why Prisons Don’t Work,” Wilbert Rideau claims state prisons will never improve the lives of criminals and lower crime rates in other states. There are four reasons to consider for dramatic shift to make prisons legitimately functional: 1) Resulting with a “silver bullet” instead of turning a criminal’s life around, 2) Keeping a prisoner long enough can make a man embrace inmate life, 3) Not focusing on the main threat of the young potential criminals, 4) Not giving enough opportunity of giving a convict a second chance at rehabilitation. People who come into a prison may never come out of the rest of his unchanged life. Putting a “silver bullet” through criminals does not keep society safe.…

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics