William Easterly's The Tyranny Of Experts

Good Essays
The Tyranny of Experts and Its Implications William Easterly’s book The Tyranny of Experts is a complicated analysis of the problems of the development of Third World states. His conclusion is that Western nations seeking to make an impact for the better on the economic development of the Third World cannot do so without supporting democratic goals for these countries (Easterly Chapter 14). Dealing with the often dictatorial leaders of the Third World may improve economic development over time, but it will not better the poorer people of these countries nor enhance their lives. His argument revolves around four topics: the Blank Slate versus learning from history, nations versus individuals, conscious direction versus spontaneous solutions, …show more content…
Easterly’s book is driven by the thesis that democracy will lead to development, not the other way around (Easterly Chapter 1). However, in this writer’s view, Dave Roodman has a point to make. Western leaders in the twenty-first century have to take many Third World countries as they are which does mean that sometimes policy decisions have to be made with dictatorial and unethical heads of state. These leaders can be difficult to work with and it is hard for many Western countries to accept the fact that in order to help the development of a country, they might have to sit across the table from a leader who constantly executes his own people. This is the most pragmatic response. Easterly is certainly correct when he says that democratic government is the best way to increase development at a faster rate in many Third World countries, but there is the constant problem of the fact that a democratic revolution on the scale of America’s or France’s takes a long time to develop and many of these constituted countries are very young indeed. The only other way to achieve this level of democracy is a Western takeover of the country. When the West conquers modern nations, it attempts to make these countries democratic based on Western models. Thus, if the West wants quick development in these countries it has only two solutions: deal practically with the unethical leaders or invade and bring a democracy to a country. Clearly these theories advance as many problems as solutions. What is clear from Easterly’s book is that these questions about development in underprivileged countries today are ones that every Western leader and philanthropic organization must wrestle

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Due to this Huntington claims that we need multiculturalism in order to compete with other civilizations without out diversifying the United States and west it can create conflict with other powerful civilizations. Again I must agree with Huntington. A multicultural civilization will make for a thriving society. He says that the western civilization creating conflict with other civilization can be the greatest threat to world peace, and an international order. Huntingtons book was an interesting read his ideas of civilization although I was unable to talk about all of it mostly revolves around the western civilization what I got from his writing was that he felt without the west world would not be as developed as it had.…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Dejah Small Introduction to Government and Politics 1327 9:00AM December 5th, 2016 Paper Option 2 Centralized Governments and The U.S. Constitution Throughout the course of history, there has been controversy over the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution. Both documents having had its issues of not having a strong enough foundation or violating the idea of a stronger national/ centralized government. First off, a central government has the authority to control an entire nation, and is sometimes referred to as a national government. The importance of a central government is so that they can have control over the states, and so that there is enough power to enforce laws among the states. A central government shows more efficiency…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This is a major problem in not only the government, but in society today. How is anyone or anything going to build stronger if there is not a diverse group of voice. Perspective is key. Anti-federalists thought there was more to the nation than what the government granted. “As long as we can preserve our unalienable rights, we are in safety“(Foreign Wars, Civil Wars, and Indian Wars—Three Bugbears).…

    • 415 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Democracy, as most nations in the world have it today, is not properly suited for the Middle East. Their deep roots in Islam and the western world influence on them makes it hard for democracy to become stable. I believe this region needs to be left alone by the western world when it comes to politics. The past century has seen constant intervention by the western world in their quest to ‘fix the problems’ and to ‘make the middle east a stable nation’. The Arab World has the chance to become a big powerhouse and to thrive like we saw before the Crusades.…

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    One solution is educating voters more on their party’s views opposed to their official’s views mostly. He also indirectly talks about rewriting the Constitution due to its outdated content and context. Rewriting the Constitution seems to be his most drastic idea but is also the most effective and efficient way to go about reformation of the flawed U.S. government. The problem with his drastic solution is the reaction of people. Change is not something welcomed in general society.…

    • 875 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    He states that “benevolent an autocrat may appear for the moment, unrestrained power will always turn out to be the enemy of development” (351). While authoritarian leaders can bring some growth development, at the end it is the individuals’ rights that bring development. Authoritarian leaders can destroy opportunities for growth with their unlimited power; therefore, free development is the answer for growth development. The most convincing debate from the four above is authoritarian versus free development because many people look at the little success of authoritarian leaders and conclude that autocrats create development growth. Development cannot grow if one person controls the whole country.…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It is difficult for a corrupt leader to vote in the union focusing on the benefit of the nation instead of his own pocket. Smartly enough, western countries take advantage of it thereby creating a cycle of inefficiency in poor countries. The concept of global governance is common to that of a world government therefore if we put all our hopes in a certain group of people to govern the whole world, we might get cheated in the end. Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Marx, for example, believed that the best way to re-balance society was through the ballot box. That is, until a government denies the people the political expression they are entitled to through modern democracy, this includes free speech, free assembly, and freedom of the press. It is then the job of the people to demand change through nonviolent revolution. For this to work, there needs to be enough anger, and enough people who are willing to stand up for change. To draw from Zizek’s work, these movements are like “rage banks”, and the people need to invest enough “rage capital” in order for it to succeed.…

    • 1777 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Democratic Stability

    • 2278 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The problem of democratic instability roots from the idea of a faulty institutional design. Modern states all have institutional mechanisms between the opponents and the supporters of democracy (Magagna, Lecture 24 January 2016). The conditions of democratic change along with stability and instability is what is critical to the explanation. Firstly, market logic displayed that as society became more commercial and market relations became more centralized, democratic ideals will also be promoted at the same time. Nevertheless, the market logic does not always apply.…

    • 2278 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    States are usually reluctant to use their own military because the state loses its resources, yet when states are willing to use their military, there are questions of hidden agendas (Pellicer 313). A world government dismisses the concerns of states acting with hidden agendas. The world government acts with an agenda for the world In the case against a world government, states must give to receive and there is no assurance for a fair system. States can gain and loose with the creation of a world government. Walter Cronkite called for a world government, but he also said, “To do that, of course, we Americans will have to yield up some of our sovereignty” (Jasper 11).…

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays