Troubling Equivalence Of Consumer Analysis

Great Essays
What is the difference between citizens and consumers? The answer to this question may seem apparent upon first glance but with some thought, many parallels can be drawn between the two. The authors, Michael Schudson and Cass Sunstein, have both pondered citizens versus consumers through their writing. While Schudson simply compares the two in, “The Troubling Equivalence of Citizen and Consumer,” Sunstein brings the influence of social media into his chapter, “Citizens”. The internet has diminished the differences between citizens and consumers. How does social media shape the environment for citizens versus consumers? Social media influences the manner in which people make their decisions, turning citizens and consumers into essentially the …show more content…
Public figures and politicians have social media accounts that citizens can turn to in order to develop an opinion of that person.. These judgements of social media profiles are similar to a review of a product by a consumer. Schudson states that voters look at a candidate’s policies to determine what the effects of the policies will be on their family, similar to “price comparison shopping” by consumers. In addition, he writes that, “voters are also very much influenced by past experience with a candidate, as they are with past experience with a product” (199). This review of a person and all aspects of that person by a voting citizen is a decent parallel to the review of a product by a consumer looking to purchase a product. Social media can be a dangerous threat to governments. Sunstein explains the Chinese government’s attempt to shut down the influence of social media by paying individuals fifty cents to counteract a bad comment about the government on social media. Once an idea begins to gain popularity and go viral on social media, citizens begin to boycott or rebel against the government and it is hard for a government to stop the actions being taken. Social media has a strong influence on citizens and their decisions end up being similar to a consumer who does or does not like a certain …show more content…
Sunstein states that consumers follow the “‘consumption treadmill,’ in which [they] buy more and better goods… because they help [consumers] keep up with others” (158). He then goes on to mention citizens in this light, writing that they “seek to slow down this treadmill, so as to ensure that social resources are devoted… to goods and services that really improve [their] lives” (158). In this one example, consumers can be seen as competitors that are always trying to keep up with the changing industry while citizens can be seen as practical, only buying the necessities to improve their lives. This can be true in some aspects, however, as a result of political and celebrity public figures posting on social media in the same manner, citizens tend to make decisions more as a consumer, following the influence of their political figures’ posts. Schudson attempts to find a clear separation between citizens and consumers, but he cannot. In the end he concludes, “Just what the most salient differences are between the world of politics and the world of consumption seems to me far from obvious… in the age of environmentalism, consumer boycotts, and political regulation of the safety of cars and toys and pajamas” (203). Through these examples, Schudson concludes that politics are regulating the consumer market, and consumers are politically boycotting. The two aspects of consumers and citizens overlap in many

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Consumerism has become such an common and integral part of society that it’s importance is not even debated. However, the question of how it came to be so important is not as clear and there are many opinions on the root of its rise. Two authors discuss their opinions on the origin of shopping’s importance, and their arguments differ on whether the consumers or manufacturers caused the rise of the shopping era. Thomas Frank in “Commodify Your Dissent” states that manufacturers and retailers are putting out products that promote change, rebellion, and “out-of-the-box” thinking because those are societies ideals at present day. In “The Signs of Shopping,” Anne Norton argues that society has become free and individualistic due to manufactures…

    • 1290 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In A Consumers' Republic: The Politics of Mass Consumption in Postwar America, author Lizabeth Cohen focuses on how the American culture of abundance and consumption influenced many political, socioeconomic and cultural changes in the decades proceeding the end of World War II. She argues that mass consumerism is deeply rooted in the modern American experience. Cohen first uses the prologue of A Consumers' Republic to introduce her own personal story, having grown up during the beginnings of the age of mass consumption. She claims that the purpose of including her personal story was not to demonstrate it's uniqueness, but instead insinuates that it was something along the lines of a common experience in the middle of the 20th century.…

    • 909 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The yippies say: Do It!” to explain how society praises going against the old norms of society. Lastly, he argues how corporations use this rebellion aspect to their advantage against consumers. As an example, he states “Consumerism is no longer about "conformity” but about “difference.” (Frank 153).…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Jack Solomon’s article, “Master’s of Desire: The Culture of American Advertising”, he portrays that American nationals are partitioned upon elitism and populism. The contradiction between elitism and populism is the effects it portrays with today’s society of advertisements and media, and how it affects society itself. The logical inconsistency of this impact is all over the place. Today’s society is continuously revolving around the concept of advertisements and media, where we are consumed material each and every day. American advertisers show us a perspective that Americans believe to have the American dream of society nowadays.…

    • 661 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Modern times offer a very diverse way of expressing oneself. The expression of a single person who consumes more than they need may not be enough to hurt the environment; however, the overproduction of harmful waste from big business is big enough to impact the environment. Critically acclaimed author Anna Lappé describes the climate crisis through the food production industry in a sector of industry where people rarely scrutinize in her article “The Climate Crisis at the End of Our Fork.” In a very different, yet scarily similar way Carolyn Merchant metaphorically describes the problems with modern human tendency and desires through the image of a shopping mall in “Eden Commodified.”…

    • 1123 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is irrefutable that, to a considerable extent, legal and non-legal actions are effective in administering justice for consumers. Consumer law has continually evolved in order to maintain its ability to protect consumers within the ever-changing modern marketplace - progressing from the common law notion of caveat emptor to an intensive legal framework recognising the fundamental need for consumer protections. While much of this contemporary framework - comprised of statutory bodies, law courts and tribunals, and working in conjunction with a myriad of other non-legal avenues - is highly effective in its delivery of justice, there remain areas of concern currently inadequate in safeguarding rights. Thus, although legal and non-legal measures…

    • 1199 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Inequality exists within a consumer society in Bauman’s terms of the ‘seduced’ and the ‘Repressed’. The later being discriminated against their inability to consume as well as the ‘seduced’ due to chronic illness, disability or age affecting their ability to earn enough money to indulge in consumerism possibly resulting in a devalued self and exclusion from those who can consume successfully. However, it should be noted that Bauman’s claim is an assertion with no physical evidence to prove his theory. Supermarkets have come to dominate consumer society in terms of where members of a consumer society shop.…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essentially, Baudrillard argues that consumerism is a “self-propelling system of which there seems to be no way out”. (Todd 48) This never-ending cycle of consumerism is reflected numerously throughout the…

    • 1108 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There are many different beliefs about which group of people is responsible for making sure that the production of goods are ethically produced. As a result of the drastically different notions, this topic is very controversial. Many people feel as though factory owners and slave owners are the ones responsible, while others believe that consumers are the ones to blame for the atrocious treatment factory workers are forced to endure. Furthermore, three sources, “How Your Addiction To Fast Fashion Kills,” “How Sugar Changed the World,” and “Bangladesh factory collapse: Who really pays for our cheap clothes?” all demonstrate the constant struggle workers--whether slaves or factory workers-- have to go through in order to live an average life.…

    • 1826 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is a common (and one would consider normal) sight in most American preschools or day cares, a little girl will be playing with her baby doll, rocking it and crooning lullabies, while a few feet away from her a little boy is waging an epic battle with his toy solider. The concept of nature versus nurture is a question that has plagued sociologists and psychologists for centuries, what causes a person to act a particular way? Sex influences how society expects a person to behave and think, in accordance to what gender role the person is expected to fulfill. These social expectations permeate into every aspect of a person’s life, from what color a baby is to be enshrouded in (pink for a girl or blue for a boy) when they are born to how an adult is expected to respond to an obstacle or conflict. Brands like Degree and Secret have become adept at identifying and…

    • 1260 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Brilliant Essays

    Galbraith sought to demystify consumerism within the U.S., and discredit the core argument that “America 's enormous production of consumer goods is justified because people want, enjoy, and demand them” (Phillips 38). In an effort to undermine the naturalization of consumerism advanced by such scholars Galbraith witnessed in the U.S., Galbraith is noted by Phillips as “undermin[ing] at least two widespread beliefs: (1) that consumer desires are genuinely autonomous, and (2) that they produce significant satisfactions” (Phillips 38). Galbraith believed that the generation of consumer wants were contrived, and that they were generated by the “productive process through which they are satisfied” and with advertising serving as the main conduit (Phillips…

    • 1612 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Brilliant Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this essay we are going to be exploring the view that a consumer society produces both winners and losers. A consumer society is a society in which the buying and selling of goods is the most important feature of social and economic activity, where what is consumed is more important than what is produced (Allen, 2014, p. 121). This essay will first discuss the claims and evidence to support that supermarkets produce winners in society. Secondly, I will discuss the claims and evidence to support that supermarkets produce losers in society. I will use Bauman’s theory of the seduced and the repressed and Wrong’s concept of zero-sum and positive-sum game, to conclude given the evidence, that supermarkets end in a zero-sum game, meaning the disadvantages out weight the possible advantages, rather than a positive-sum game, where everyone to some extent gains.…

    • 879 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ordinary Citizens

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages

    We utilize modern technology to communicate with every remote corner of the world at any time. From newspapers to television, to magazines and billboards, the media communicates with the public everywhere. Ordinary citizens offer firsthand opinions, political figures offer government insight, and entertainers offer alleviation. Although many consumers believe that all opinions are beneficial, the reality is that many individuals are led by ignorance and self-interest and lack democratic values.. With personal experience and varying backgrounds, ordinary citizens grant us firsthand accounts on an array of subjects.…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The field of communication is greater than simply a study of mediums. Some theorists argue that communication itself can be viewed as an action or process where our interpretation of reality can be “produced, maintained and transformed”. Central to our examination of communication studies are issues relating to media spaces where approaches to power are realized. Within modern day capitalism, social media has become so universally pervasive that its ideology and commodification are all but naturalized in our society. By exploring concepts of hegemony, commodification and ideology, social media serves as a lens to demonstrate the influence and power of this medium in a capitalist society.…

    • 1121 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Fight Club: How Consumerism Affects People Jeff Bezos (Amazon CEO) says “What consumerism really is, at its worst, is getting people to buy things that don’t actually improve their lives” (IMDB). On a daily basis we are exposed to a plethora of advertisements. They are force fed to us in such a way that attempts to hide from them are proven futile. Not only are advertisers trying to sell us their product, but they are also selling us their standards. They tell us how to live our life, what’s expected of us, and we blindly follow their commands.…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays