The Pros And Cons Of Asylums

Improved Essays
The treatment of mentally ill people has evolved over time as the medical community had increased its understanding of the underlying causes of the disabilities. Asylums, places that housed the mentally ill in the 19th century, used harsh, painful, and inhumane methods to treat their patients. These methods of treatment began to change after Dorothea Dix, a teacher and nurse in the Civil War, began visiting asylums and reporting it to the public what she had witnessed. Dorothea Dix studied these patients and the treatments used on them for nearly her whole life, then helped a movement along to help asylums be better. Her criticisms of the asylum system would begin to change public opinion which was leading to laws being enacted to reform the …show more content…
Most if not all of the patients were held in cages, closets, pens, and stalls often times in cellars. Most of the patients who were disobedient were chained up naked and beaten/ lashed with rods and other sorts of items. After some time, asylums soon became institutions, where instead of just holding and punishing the mentally ill, they began trying to treat the disorders as well. One of the most common ways to “treat” a mental disorder was electroshock therapy, this is still used and there’s controversy on if this method really works to “cure” mental illness. Another treatment used on patients was mesmerism, more commonly known as hypnotism, then it was used to cure what was considered mental disorders; this is used today on people with sleeping disorders, nicotine addictions, and various other issues. Less common, but more therapeutic than hypnotism, was art therapy. Patients got to use art as a way to, mostly, express themselves. Art therapy is still used today, and is typically effective, but each person is different. One rarely used method, but perhaps the most reasonable of all, was talk-therapy. Talk therapy was almost the exact same therapy as if you went to a therapist to talk about your mental illnesses such as depression or anxiety.

A later method of treatment used was surgery. The most infamous and brutal surgery that a patient would undergo was a lobotomy. A lobotomy, if you don’t already know, is essentially a surgery to damage part of the brain, in hopes to change the person’s personality and be mentally sane. Due to the surgeon 's lack of sterile tools and medical technology, many patients were left worse than before, if they hadn’t died from

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    1. Dix’s values of the mentally ill impacted their treatment. In the United States she helped create more than 30 hospitals. She told people that individuals with mental disturbances could not be cured. Before this People didn’t care what happened to the mentally ill. They put them in prisons and some were kept in cages.…

    • 153 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Dorothea Dix’s case, she was focused on the treatment of mentally ill.…

    • 111 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They’d burn themselves up.” (healthresearchfunding.org). Dorothea did not believe mental illness should be a crime, and she didn't believe that it wasn't un-curable (science20). Because of this, she showed the ghastly reports of the inmates' lives, which sickened her spectators in Massachusetts and lead to funds being set aside for the state mental hospital in Worcester (history.com). Later Dorothea traveled to other states, including Europe and Canada to accomplish the same goal (history.com).…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most people who were mentally ill in hospitals were treated as prisoners. They were put in dungeons, chained, and beaten. Urbanization allowed for more institutions for the mentally ill but the conditions in which they live did not improve. They were still being treated as criminals and most did not have access to light or heat. In the early 1800’s, Dorothea Dix watched this mistreatment occur in Massachusetts and began to establish over 30 hospitals that focused on the treatment of the mentally ill.…

    • 316 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This has created new problems that have never happened before. In the late nineteenth century, Dorothea Dix and Reverend Louis Dwight had a campaign that got a lot of the mentally ill out of prison. Because of this campaign, there were mentally ill hospitals everywhere, and the numbers of confined people with mental illness sharply declined. However, there was a lot of abuse within mental institutions and a lot of involuntary imprisonment of people. When antipsychotic medications were established, it showed great promise; however, the drug was overused and this resulted in horrific treatment protocols.…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dorothea Dix was at a young age relatively in charge of keeping house and taking care of her younger siblings due to her mother’s crippling depression and likely other mental illnesses and her father’s abusive achollisim. While her mother likely being her first and most formative experience with mental illness, she was in no way her last. Having always had a fascination with the mentally ill Dorothea took a teaching position at the East Cambridge Women’s prison where she was shocked to see the inhumane treatment of the women there. Not only were some many of the inmates mentally ill people who had committed no real crime housed alongside actual criminals, the women there were subjected to harsh, corrupt, inhumane treatment. Many of the women…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Before the 19th century in the American society, criminals were executed, whipped, and held in dark cells. The insane wandered around the asylums and were not cared for properly. Reformers wanted to establish an official institution for the insane and criminals that was humane. They believed that reform and rehabilitation was possible in a controlled environment. As part of the humanitarian reforms sweeping through America, asylums and prisons were for criminals and the mentally ill.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Art reflects life: as society and its institutions change, art remains as a record of historical thoughts and practices. The way in which society views and treats those suffering with mental illness varies depending on the contemporary theory for its cause and its place among society. As man progressed from the superstitious dogma on mental illness surrounding the Medieval period, theories and cures towards mental illness increased in their analytic methods, though it certainly took centuries to overcome the stigma surrounding it. Albrecht Dürer’s Melancholia I (Figure 1), William Hogarth’s A Rake’s Progress: The Madhouse (Figure 2), and Vincent van Gogh’s Self Portrait with Bandaged Ear and Pipe (Figure 3) reflect their period’s treatment…

    • 1485 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Though prior to the movement mental illness was thought to be a curse or evil spirit, Dorothea Dix petitioned in 1843, after examining many patients with mental illness, that mental illness was linked to a physical, scientifically provable phenomenon. Despite her efforts, many regions still did not accept the establishment of mental health facilities. Lewis Dwight was another reformer for prison systems who founded the Boston Prison Discipline Society which ended up eventually spread the Auburn system to jails – a system that promoted group work during the day and silent work at…

    • 1322 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Asylum Dbq

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The treatment the patients living within asylums received was "reduced to the extremest states of degradation" and there was a sadness within the quality of their life (Dix). This resulted in overcrowding and calm patients turned insane. The mentally ill changed from calm people to violent when they were left in the asylum to fend for themselves. They would go from clean functioning people to unrecognizable filthy looks savages…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Throughout time mental illness has been looked upon in numerous ways from people. The time period in history can tell us a lot about the ways people were living and how they believed behavior affected certain mental illnesses. In my writing I will describe a man who is mentally ill during the early 1700’s. I will also describe an African American in a Georgia asylum and also a middle-class woman in a water treatment spa in upstate New York. I will detail what each of these individuals does on a daily basis such as their hygiene, what kind of clothing they wear and also how the person may interact with others.…

    • 1566 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The objector for the solution would be the all the foster home managers or simply just the business. Since the program that will solve the solution of child abuse will replace or get rid of many/all foster homes. The people working at a foster home will obviously lose their job because let’s just say foster homes won’t be necessary anymore if the program is established. Foster care workers will obviously not agree on placing the new solution, they don’t want to lose their jobs.…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Revolt By Going Insane? Can you imagine living in a society where coping with any mental illness is dealt by locking you inside a small room with nothing inside and nothing to do? Unfortunately, that was the case for most women in the 1800s. In the story “The Yellow Wall-Paper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, the narrator describes her experience with her mental illness and how she was forced inside a room that amplified her hysteria. Her story became a great novel that acknowledge women’s oppression in society and a piece of art that help engage the conversation for women empowerment.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This essay analyses whether or not Australia is ethical towards the people who are fleeing from their country to a country where they are safe and protected. Throughout this essay secondary sources such as websites will be used to determine whether the Australian government is being equally fair to Refugees and Asylum seekers. ‘A refugee is a person who has fled his or her country and cannot return because of a well-founded fear of persecution due to their race, religion, nationality or membership of a particular social group’ (NSW Government department of education , 2015). As shown in (Dictionary.com, 2016)…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger the main character Holden Caulfield is sent to a mental institution due to the emotional devastation his brother, Allie 's, death had caused him. Cares about his brother so much that he isolated himself from society and his family who put him in the mental institution. Mental institutions continue to advance to help people like Holden Caulfield overcome mental disorders. Mental institutions were created for the reason to help people who have mental disturbances or mental disabilities. “The [Mental] Act [2001] defines mental disorder as mental illness, severe dementia, or significant intellectual disability,” (Citizens Information).…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays