The Tragic Gullibility In William Shakespeare's Othello

Superior Essays
Every person has flaws; certain imperfections that make us human. Once we are conscious of these flaws, they can no longer be used to our detriment. But, if we are ignorant, these flaws can be manipulated by malicious enemies who wish to destroy us. William Shakespeare’s Othello is a testament to our vulnerabilities as humans. Othello is a virtuous military hero, who turns into a weak, revengeful murderer at the hands of his trusted, but evil ensign. Othello’s gullibility, crippling insecurity and heightened jealousy overcome his virtuosity. Ultimately, Othello’s downfall is a result of these same tragic flaws that he fails to recognize and stop Iago from exploiting.
Othello’s gullibility is one of his fatal flaws, and contributes to his
…show more content…
Although, Othello shares a common religion and sense of patriotism with those around him, he is visibly different due to his skin colour. He is one of the only black men in Venice and Desdemona is a beautiful white girl with many suitors. He’s constantly reminded of this insecurity throughout the play and begins to feel unworthy of Desdemona’s affections. Being referred to as a “blacker devil” by Emilia “an old black ram”, and a “Barbary horse” by Iago, only amplify his already crippling insecurity and make him more even more self-concious. As a result, the idea of Desdemona wanting someone else, someone easier on the eyes, does not seem completely out of reason. Othello’s insecurities are too close to the surface, and all it takes is a few words from Iago to tear apart his confident exterior and release the madness within. It is easy for Iago to manipulate Othello because he already believes that Desdemona’s love for him is too good to be true. By wearing his insecurities on his sleeve, he lets Iago take advantage of him, and this is why he is responsible for his own …show more content…
This jealousy stems from his inability to put reason over emotion, resulting in his passions ruling his actions. As the play progresses, the audience has no choice but to watch in sympathetic horror. He is manipulated and twisted by Iago’s lies, forcing him to face emotions that consume him. The image of Desdemona and Cassio making love in his bed, fuel his jealousy and ultimately drive him mad. He becomes so enraged with the women he loves that he strikes her in public and calls her a “devil.” As the play progresses, his rage continues to grow until he states that “she must die, else she’ll betray more men.” Later in that same scene, he smothers his wife to death. In reality, the only evidence Othello has of his wife’s infidelity is a handkerchief placed by Iago in Cassio’s house and the words of an ensign he believes he can trust. His ability for reason and logic become hostage to rage and resentment and the darker aspects of Othello’s nature take over. If he had not been so enraged, he would have been able to piece through the accusations of infidelity and realize Iago was deceiving him. If his passions did not trump his perspicacity, he would have recognized the strong bonds of love between him and Desdemona. His jealousy is driving him to madness, yet he never stops to contemplate why Iago is defaming Desdemona or the broader framework of the accusation. Othello consumed by jealousy, loses his sensibility

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Desdemona reflects Othello’s good qualities including his bravery, strength, and intelligence. Alternatively, Iago incites jealousy within Othello and watches him erupt. Iago reveals Othello’s insecurities, and prior to Iago’s interference, Othello could control any situation. In Act 1, Othello diffuses a situation in which multiple combatants had already unsheathed their weapons. “Keep up your bright swords, for the dew will rust them” (1.2 59). His discourse immediately calms the tension. Similarly, Desdemona reflects many of Othello’s positive qualities. She falls in love with Othello, the War Hero – a hero who is no stranger to danger. After Iago starts to interfere with Othello’s relationship with Desdemona, Iago has control of Othello, since Othello regards the word of Iago as gospel. Iago exposes Othello’s jealousy and naïveté and easily convinces him that Cassio slept with Desdemona. Even though Iago tells Othello it is a dream, Othello believes that his wife cheated on him proclaiming, “O monstrous! Monstrous! […] this denoted a foregone conclusion” (3.3 427-429). Othello turns from calm to a raging cauldron of jealousy. Othello experiences mixed feelings between these two characters. Iago represents vice; Desdemona represents virtue, and Othello is easily tempted by the vice of…

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Identity In Othello

    • 1074 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Throughout his whole life, Othello has had to deal with racism and stereotyping to the point where he has internalized the negative perceptions of his blackness. Karen Newman, an English professor at Brown University, describes how Iago’s deception of Othello was was rooted in Othello’s own prejudices against his racial identity (133). Iago put words to Othello’s deepest insecurities about his interracial marriage, including the belief that the“fair” Desdemona would prefer a white man, and Othello is convinced that “Haply for I am black/ And have not those soft parts of conversation/ That chamberers have.../ I am abused, and my relief/ Must be to loathe her” (Shakespeare 3.3.260-265). Othello’s projected facade of “honorary white”, as University of Pennsylvania professor Ania Loomba labeled him, is starting to disintegrate; he starts to believe that he possesses the unrefined black stereotype instead. Loomba describes Othello as “hopelessly split” between displaying his cultural assimilation and finding his true identity (177). This dichotomy dramatically alienates Othello and increases his uncertainty in the nature of his own…

    • 1074 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fallacies In Othello

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages

    First, the father of Desdemona, Barbantio; calls Othello a “foul thief’ due to Othello being a ‘moor’ and a secret marriage plotter (Act 1, Scene 2, line 61). Iago reports to Barbantio that his daughter Desdemona has married a foolish man by the name of Othello thus ignoring her good father; this in turn causes a drift between Othello and Barbantio’s family. Also, Iago calls Othello a ‘moor that changes with posion’ due to their upset relationship (Act 3, Scene 3, Line 326). Understandingly, Iago plots games against Othello due to Othello gaining popularity in Venice and Cyprus, Iago has a upset and frightful relation with Othello. Lastly, Desdemona’s original lover Roderigo dislikes Othello very much because he stole his girlfriend away from him, he says that “Tush, never tell me! I take it much unkindly, That Thou, Iago, who hast had my purse, As if the strings were thine shouldst know of this” ( Act 1, Scene 1, line 1-3). Roderigo become very jealous of Iago in the staring of the tale due to a ‘moor” marrying his beloved girlfriend; this is the starting of an evil approach in Roderigo thus marking the start of his upset relationship with Othello. The great Othello whose tales are famous tends to have upset relationship with his peers and friends thus marking the very jealous tragedy to start and…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Iago’s jealousy leads to the death of Desdemona and other characters. Iago overtime develops a complex idea that will bring Othello down and complete the determination of revenge, all this because Othello gave a promotion over to someone else. Iago is so determined to bring Othello and other innocent people down just so he can succeed in getting his revenge for Othello. This shows how far people will go just to get/accomplish what they want. Iago and Roderigo tell Desdemona’s dad that Othello and Desdemona had gotten married without anyone knowing. Iago says, “Call up her father, Rouse him. Make after him, poison has delight” (68). He eventually has another plan to bring Othello down by approaching Othello and saying that Cassio and Desdemona has been hooking up and that she is cheating on him. This is when Iago’s revenge starts taking effect. Iago secretly sets Desdemona’s handkerchief in Cassio’s house so that Othello would find it and come to realize that Iago was telling the truth about her cheating on him. actually is cheating on him. This only gives Othello more reason to kill Desdemona and get jealous. Iago and Othello are kind of similar, they both are jealous of something in life that makes them do irrational things, no matter what the cost is. As a result of the whole play, we can see that jealousy can really affect a person and make them to be something/someone they are not. Jealousy can make a person do crazy and inhuman things that can lead to people getting hurt or even…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Act Three of Othello by William Shakespeare, Iago begins the second part of his plan to destroy those who wronged him. To those around him, Iago seems harmless because we associate evil with an evil appearance. In this story, Iago looks just the same as every other soldier. His evil is not recognizable, and he can easily act with deceit. The entirety of the plot is built upon miscommunication, distrust, and especially lies, and Iago uses those to his advantage.…

    • 1011 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When Desdemona’s father, Brabantio, starts the kerfuffle over his daughter’s marriage to Othello, he is completely flummoxed as to why his daughter would marry someone of another race. Brabantio believes that Desdemona’s original feelings are “And she, in spite of nature, / Of years, of country, credit, everything, / To fall in love with what she feared to look on!” (Shakespeare 1.3. 114-116). Desdemona’s own father presumes that she is petrified of Africans, which commences Othello’s uncertainty. Iago furthers his insecurities by claiming that Desdemona may be having an affair with Othello’s previous lieutenant, Cassio. Iago professes that he cares for Othello, and that he notifies him of the alleged infidelity because he fears that “Her will, recoiling to her better judgment, / May fall to match you with her country forms/ And happily repent” (Shakespeare 3.3. 276- 278). The references towards Othello having a different appearance than the Venetian men creates a feeling within Othello that those men are better suited for Desdemona than himself. Iago points out these fears and brings them to the forefront of Othello’s mind. While ruminating over the…

    • 1338 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When Othello is introduced in the play, Iago informs him that Desdemona’s father, Brabantio, has found out about their marriage and is speaking ill of him. Instead of becoming angry, Othello shows his lack of concern by saying, “Let [Brabantio] do his spite” (Othello 1.2.18). By playing upon Othello and Desdemona’s differences in race and social standings, Iago makes Othello believe that his wife is sleeping with Cassio. Iago knows Desdemona has control over Othello’s heart and social standings, and an affair would cause him to lose his position and respect in society. The audience pities Othello as his mind deteriorates, but this turns to anger when he vows to kill Desdemona; hits her; and calls her a “devil” (Othello 4.1.171-232). Othello believes he is in the right to murder his wife, as this will prevent her from hurting others as she hurt him. It is when Lodovico tells Iago to “look at the tragic loading” that the audience remembers that Othello is not a villain. His tragic downfall is his own doing, but it would have never happened if Iago did not seek to ruin to his…

    • 1678 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Collisions In Othello

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Before the pervious sense Othello demands to see the “ocular proof” of Desdemona’s cheating. “No, Iago I’ll see before I doubt, when I doubt prove and on that proof there will be no more of this.” When Iago continues to manipulate Othello he finally accuses Desdemona of cheating without seeing any “ocular proof.” He changes his perception of Desdemona because he fears for his reputation. The force of jealousy has changed the way he sees his wife. He also, throughout the play refers to “Honest Iago” never doubting his word. Jealousy has changed Othello’s morals. Before, he would have assumed Desdemona would fall in love with another man. His morals have therefore become questionable. This suggests how much the forces have conflicted him as even Desdemona no-longer knows what he is thinking. “Even though my noble moor is true of mind and not made of such baseness as creatures are it would be enough to put him to ill thinking.” Desdemona believes her husband is not a jealous person but is worried about how he will react to her losing the handkerchief, her sign of faithfulness. “Heaven keep that monster from Othello’s mind.” This suggests Othello is capable for immoral acts and turning into monster. This is contrasted with his noble status at the start of the play. Othello’s contradictory responses to wanting proof of Desdemona’s infidelity shows how his morals have changed; making the audience question his character. The…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To sabotage Cassio, the defendant led him to drink and subsequently become violent. He then coerced Rodrigo to brawl with Cassio. Afterwards, he stabbed Cassio and Roderigo, resulting in the latter’s death. This led to Cassio’s dismissal, which in turn led to him going to Desdemona and begging her to seek Othello’s forgiveness. These meetings are the weapon the defendant used to release the jealousy in Othello. Due to extreme jealousy, distrust and Iago’s vile machinations, Othello did what any man would do to a cheating wife; he killed innocent…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Othello’s many shortcomings, from his insecurities, personality, and pride, were the ultimate reasons for his and Desdemona’s downfall; Iago simply accelerated the process. Othello’s vulnerability to those around him—from pressures of being a black man in a white society, to his all-trusting naiveté in a man who despised him, to his clouded judgment and rash behaviour with his final confrontation of Desdemona; drove him to the brink of insanity and was the cause of his death. Othello represents the incompatibility of marriage that comes with some due to the complete fault of one…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    His false sense of suspicion and jealousy leads him to make this drastic decision even though sometimes he doubts the truth of the information that he is getting from iago and other sources he is so obsessed with revenge and jealousy he can not even see the logic in the situation. Although he is overcome with jealousy there are other motives behind his plot to kill her. One being him wanting to defend his honor . He believes that if he murders desdemona he will be standing up for “mankind” for women who betray their husbands by being unfaithful . As Alvin Kernan states in his source , “Oblivious to Iago’s scheming and the transparent innocence of his wife and lieutenant, Othello is ultimately a victim of his own naivete and implacable ignorance” ( Kernan) He is so caught up in the drama and scheming of iago’s plot he fails to see the logic of the situation resulting in catastrophic results. Iago worked his way into his mind and manipulated the situation to where Othello wasn 't even thinking straight . At one point in the play Othello is so overcome with his own jealousy and plots of revenge he goes into a fit and seizes. Not once but two times this happens showing how strongly his irrational emotions are influencing his actions and behavior . Even at the end of the play we see that Othello realizes the fatal misjudgment he has made. As Alvin…

    • 1309 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Othello’s honourable and honest-nature, integrated with his insecurity of being an outsider, racially and culturally, found him to being easily preyed upon for Iago’s ploy. As previously mentioned several times, Iago portrayed himself as an honest and loyal friend, which he employed against Othello, stating, “The Moor is of a free and open nature,/ That thinks men honest that but seem to be so,/And will tenderly be led by the nose/ As asses are” (1.3.390-393).Just as Othello was so easily deceived because of his open nature, Iago used Othello’s racial insecurity, to enhance his plot of twisting his love for his wife, Desdemona. In other words, Iago used the same tactic Brabantio, Desdemona’s father used when he found out about the secret marriage, as Iago comments, “She did deceive her father, marrying you;/ And what she seem’d to shake and fear your looks/ She lov’d them most” (3.3.208-210). Moreover, despite what it appeared to be, Iago fooled Othello, using his racial insecurity in order to question for him to question his wife’s faithfulness, when in reality, Desdemona would never be unfaithful. In the long run, Iago took Othello’s love for Desdemona, and crumpled it into heavily-built jealousy, burned by Othello’s vulnerable…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Othello is one of Shakespeare’s great tragedies. It takes place in Venice and focuses on the romantic relationships of its characters. The play opens with its main villain plotting against the protagonist. The villain, Iago, has promised, and been compensated, Rodrigo that he will get Desdemona to fall in love with him. However, things take a drastic turn when Desdemona eloped with Othello The Moor. This is the first controversy in the play due to the gender roles put on by society. As a women, Desdemona is considered her father’s property and society dictated that the father alone must chose his daughter 's husband. Instead of marrying one of the rich Venetian men that her father expects her to marry for his own gain, she marries Othello for love. Her father is outraged at their union and tries to enact his male dominance over her by pleading his case of his ‘stolen’ daughter to the Duke. In response, both Desdemona and Othello describe a beautiful story of love and loyalty to one another and the court dismisses her father’s claims. Their peace is short lived, however. Even with her defiance to her father, Desdemona is a perfect, stereotypical wife. She is both loyal and dedicated to her new husband but it is revealed that Othello is not. His faith in his new bride is easily shaken by the men around them. Othello is led to believe, based on lago’s jealousy filled plot, that his wife has been disloyal and is persuaded to kill her. lago plants a handkerchief--the first gift Othello ever gave Desdemona--in Cassio’s room to “prove” her affair. In societies views, she has dishonored him and mocked his dominance and the only way he can restore it is by punishing her and killing…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Othello’s overwhelming thoughts of doubt and betrayal, planted by Iago, cause him to lose sight of his responsibilities, in being a poised and rational leader. Before his corruption, Othello proves to be a respectable and honored war hero, through his sensible and wise guidance. However, once Iago causes Othello to make decisions purely out of jealousy and revenge, Othello relinquishes his responsibilities and moral obligations. This is witnessed when Othello begins to plot Cassio and Desdemona’s death because of his…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With Iago being the sole manipulator and contributor to Othello’s downfall, Othello’s incomprehension towards Desdemona’s loyalty played an equal part to the fall of the hero. This is so in Act 2 Scene 1 where Desdemona professes her loyalty and love to Othello, “And so much duty as my mother showed to you, preferring you before her father, so much I challenge that I may profess due to the Moor my lord.” Even though she professes her faith and loyalty to the ‘moor’, Othello is continually opened to Iago’s poisons, leading him to question Desdemona’s loyalty overtime to the extent where he calls her a ‘strumpet’ in Act 4. Only after when he realises that Desdemona’s handkerchief was in Cassio’s possession did it allow the green-eyed monster to take possession of him, making him blind with hatred and revenge. This however AC Bradley states, “The Othello who enters the bed-chamber with the words, 'It is the cause, it is the cause, my soul ', is not the man of the Fourth Act. The deed he is bound to do is not murder, but a sacrifice. He is to save Desdemona from herself, not in hate but in honour; in honour, and also in love.” is correct to a degree where it demonstrates the Othello’s incomprehension. As he commits the act of murder in love, this statement shows to a huge extent of Othello’s incomprehension towards Desdemona’s loyalty, where he commits murder not in hate, but in love, showing his blinded attitude towards his ever loyal wife. Othello 's motives was ironically flawed where even in Desdemona’s death does she remain loyal, “Nobody; I myself. Farewell, Commend me to my kind lord: O, farewell!” showing her motive to protect Othello which such a realisation leads to his own death, “I kiss 'd thee ere I kill 'd thee: no way but this; Killing myself, to die upon a kiss.” showing his remorse and regret for…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics