The Importance Of Friendship In My Brilliant Friend

Improved Essays
The novel, My Brilliant Friend, is renowned for its portrayal of strong female friendship. This work, set in 1950s Naples, follows the lives of two young girls, Lila and Elena. Told from the point of view of Elena, a well-behaved studious girl, the story follows the girls from elementary school to rebellious Lila’s wedding day. It explores numerous themes, from social class to femininity. But, one aspect of the girls’ friendship that stands out is Elena’s dependence on Lila. Throughout the novel she is devoted to her friend, basing her successes and failures on Lila’s response to her actions. Indeed, from her point of view, their friendship often seems unrequited and Elena habitually feels that Lila is leaving her behind. However, while it …show more content…
When she departs for Ischia, she misses her friend from the start. “I spent the time on the terrace, dressed, writing a letter to Lila every day, each one filled with questions, clever remarks, lively descriptions of the island…. I waited for letters from Lila, we had promised when we said goodbye, but none came.” (Ferrante 209-210). Unfortunately, Elena interprets this silence as Lila abandoning her, leaving her behind. However, Lila’s silence can also be interpreted the other way around: Lila feels as though Elena is leaving her behind. While Elena is off enjoying a vacation on the beach with an English speaking family, Lila is trapped in the same neighborhood she has always lived in, being forced into a marriage that she doesn’t want. In an attempt to hide her desperation, Lila does not respond to Elena’s letters, unsure how to hide her own jealousy and fear about the future. Indeed, it is clear when Lila finally writes Elena that she is desperate for her friend to return, and she expresses as much upon Elena’s arrival: “it’s something I can only do with you, thank goodness you’ve come back. I thought I’d have to wait till September.” (Ferrante 234). This quote refers to Lila and Stefano’s plan to get married, and though it can be argued that Elena was just a pawn in Lila …show more content…
Elena was privy to Stefano’s proposal, many of their disagreements, and Lila’s innermost feelings for Stefano. Moreover, Elena was also a major influence on the wedding preparations. Though most aspects of Lila’s life come easy to her, getting along with her in-laws is not one of them. Due to this fact, she begs Elena to join her and her future in-laws while wedding dress shopping. While Lila disagrees with every dress that her in-laws select for her, Elena manages to convince everyone to agree on the same wedding dress, one that even Lila adores. Afterwards, Lila is so impressed by Elena’s abilities at peacekeeping that she asks Elena to continue helping with her wedding plans. “So do me the favor of coming with us whenever I ask you.” (Ferrante 294). While Elena to some extent sees this as being used by her friend, Lila doesn’t appear to have that intent. Instead, she seems to genuinely need her friend’s help in planning this wedding, and perhaps in going on to the next stage in her life. Feeling ostracized by her future husband’s family and unsure of how to plan a wedding, she leans on her more educated and worldly friend. She even depends on Elena when the wedding falls apart. Indeed, Lila is enraged when Stefano decides to let Silvio Solara give a toast at their wedding. She locks herself in her room and refuses to emerge, despite the pleas of her family. Unable to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Tita and Engracia both suffer verbal and emotional abuse from their mothers, but Engracia decided to face it and not let her Ignacia’s words get to her while Tita instead decided to run away. Both Nacha and Mama Elena the same strict and cold emotions towards their daughters and expect way too much out of them. However, Nacha did not believe in the old rule that the youngest daughter could not be married nor have children. Engracia forgave her mother when she passed away, and did not hold any anger towards her, but respect because of all the life lessons she was able to learn which only made her…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first reason Mama Elena's actions were not coming from good intentions is because she showed her no affection that a loving and caring mother would do. When Tita was seen crying by Mama Elena, she does not comfort her. Tita was upset that she had to prepare the wedding for her sister and the man she loved. Her mom thought of her as ruining Rosaura wedding and did not stand for it. The narrator says “Mama Elena read the look on her face and flew into a rage, giving Tita a tremendous slap that left her rolling in the dirt. ” (27). This quote shows that Mama Elena could care less about showing love to Tita because she did not ask her…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Respectively, Mindy’s predominant Italian lineage considers family to be of utmost importance, but gender roles have been immensely traditional and, in a way, sexist. Being in a culture that is, “... governed by a clear recognition of status and hierarchy…,” (O’ Hair, 2014, p. 129) her father is recurrently viewed as the “breadwinner” or “patriarch” that dominates the entire family while his wife is encumbered with domestic responsibilities. However, Mindy has found that the magnitude of “relationships” play a far more vital element in one’s life than family, for it has been due to the faults of the bitter and divorced marriage of her parents and an skewed kinship that forged her perspective to deviate from her culture. Hence, she has felt distant from family members such as her ten cousins, whom she could not even recognize often nor know if they are still alive. Without the cordial linkage within relationships, the family will eventually become fragmented as a consequence. It is this progression that has seceded Mindy from the significance of family and has additionally manifested the gravity of her character as a direct and sovereign woman. Her value for unswerving honesty and individuality overwhelms the need to be polite merely to please others, which has…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In My Brilliant Friend, Ferrante reveals that the change from childhood to adolescence is scary and upsetting because the breakdown of innocence occurs. In the first chapter of Adolescence, Lila’s experience of “dissolving margins” (2) is symbolic of what occurs in every child during puberty. Furthermore, Ferrante symbolizes change with the motif of fire, which is seen in the fireworks display. During the display, Lila feels disgust towards the changes she sees in her brother and repulsion towards the human body, which “seem[s] to her attributes of monstrous beings” (39). Lila’s disgust of the body is representative of the disgust most children may feel about their own bodies, and the unveiling of the changes in Rino is symbolic of a loss of…

    • 270 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Separate Peace Quotes

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Have you ever read a book that showed true friendship throughout the whole book? In this essay I will be writing about how true friendship is shown in the book. A friend is considered to be person whom one knows and with whom one has a bond of mutual affection and a state of trust and support between each other. In A Separate Peace, there are two characters in this book which are Gene and Phineas that have a great bond with each other which is considered to be friendship.…

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The first step they are trying to approach in their life if marriage. As soon as Mama Elena had heard about this, she had furiously rejected this idea. “ For generations, not a single person in my family has ever questioned this tradition, and no daughter of mine is going to be the one to star” (Esquirel 11). Tita had undergoes a conversation with her mother about Pedro coming over to have a “talk” with Mama Elena. Tita’s mother knew what was going to happen and was not excited about that idea. Tita then had received a fierce command tone from Mama Elena reminding her about the family’s tradition and Tita’s role of it. Tita now has to give up this idea of marriage and now has to watch her sister Rosaura get married to Pedro, her lover. This is how Tita lost her right of freedom and now she has to earn it…

    • 1225 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When Tita was about to be fifteen, she saw for the first time Pedro Muzquiz, which became the love of her life, but their love could not be accomplished due to Mama Elena because she did not Tita to have a boyfriend. Mama Elena told Tita that she could not have a boyfriend because in the family there was a tradition, which was that her job was to take care of her until she died, Esquivel states, ‘“If he intends to ask for your hand, tell him not to bother. He’ll be wasting his time and mine too. You know perfectly well that being the youngest daughter means you have to take care of me until the day I die”’ (Esquivel 10). Tita disagree with this tradition because for her there was no future. Meanwhile her other sister did get the chance to have a life and not taking care of her mother. When Tita knew that she had to serve for life to her mother, she started to argue that it was not fair, but for Mama Elena Tita’s opinion did not count. This tradition does not make any sense because why would only one girl would take care of the mother, while the other daughters were having a better life. Tita grew up emotionally because for her there was no future and at the young age she had, she had the illusions of having a husband. But for Tita this was no impediment, she broke her family’s tradition and at last she stayed with Pedro. Tita did what she wanted, she always did things on her way, which she struggle but obtained what she proposed…

    • 1337 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, in TRIFLES we have isolated Mrs. Wright, who lacks friends and social contacts, her commitment results in the alteration of two other women’s attitudes toward their rights and independent decisions. As a result, we have Mrs. Hale’s words “ we call it- knot it, Mr. Henderson.” which conveys the meaning of creating a kind of connection and sympathy between women. Likewise, we can identify the bond between Loureen and Florence in POOF which helps Loureens to overcome her anxiety and stress by her friend’s support. We can see such a sympathy in POOF that women used to imagining the ways with which they can get rid of their husbands. The importance of this unity is vivid enough in the history of feminism as all their achievements is as a result of group activities and widespread…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Mama Elena Quotes

    • 181 Words
    • 1 Pages

    In Chapters September, October, November, December, Mama Elena had cursed Tita for being in relations in Pedro. Mama Elena eventually dies, leaving Tita and Pedro to do as they please with their love. Rosaura tries to keep their tradition alive by keeping her daughter from marrying John’s son, but she eventually dies and the young adults are free to marry.…

    • 181 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mama Elena is an abusive woman because she beats Tita frequently. “Mama Elena read the look on her face and flew into a rage, giving Tita a tremendous slap that left her rolling in the dirt by the rooster, which had died from the bungled operation.” Once, Mama Elena beat Tita to the point that Tita had to spend a week recovering. “The night of the wedding reception she had gotten a tremendous hiding from Mama Elena, like no beating before or since. She spent two weeks in bed recovering from her bruises.”…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a small child she was practically raised by Nacha while Mama Elena was just an authority figure. Nacha fueled Tita’s passion for cooking which also molded who she grew up to be. Mama Elena ruled with an iron fist and treated Tita like a servant making her do tasks like washing her mother in the bath as well as cooking. Mama even furthered the odd cruelty by prohibiting Tita from marrying as the family tradition says the youngest daughter needs to live a life away from love to serve the mother until death. When she was older, a man named Pedro came into her life but because of tradition Mama Elena had him Marry her older sister, Rosaura. The marriage crippled Tita making her fall ill and have a mental breakdown. A Doctor named John Brown from the United States came to help her get better but only found love. The love they found however may have seemed genuine but, lacked passion causing it to fail. Tita leaves John Brown and goes back to her true love, Pedro. Tita finally lives the life she’s longed for with children, a husband, and her late sister’s daughter Esperanza who was saved from the same life Tita had…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Right now, Lina hears about how they are being moved. Her family is on the moving list. Andrius is not on the list. At this point, she is showing her soft side to Andrius. “We walked hand in hand, neither one of us speaking. My pace slowed. ‘Andrius I’m...scared.’…

    • 644 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this case, tradition is repressing Tita from experiencing what a normal young woman should experience. She is not allowed to get married or have a kid because of this tradition. Being the youngest in the family wasn’t always easy. Tita has to take on a lot of responsibility to be able to take care of Mama Elena until she dies.”Tita got a terrible spanking for that, and she was forbidden to play with her sisters in her own world.”(Pg.8) Because of this Tita doesn’t get to experience freedom and to live her life because Mama Elena needs help on her daily life routine. Alternately Tita has to cook the foods exactly how they are, or else she gets punished by Mama Elena, that also doesn’t allow Tita to experiment or use creativity, but it also allows Tita to express her love for Pedro. The main time that this was specified was in March, when she made Quail in rose petal sauce. Mama Elena doesn’t like any of the interactions that go on between Tita and Pedro, that is why in June, Mama Elena sends Pedro and Rosaura away from the ranch when Rosaura had the baby. This shows how strict and dedicated Mama Elena is on…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unfortunately, Mama Elena was not able to be successful in winning against her social normality. When Mama Elena was young, she wanted to marry a negro. This was unacceptable to both her parents and society, so her parents arranged a marriage to a man who is now known as Tita and Rosaura’s father. Mama Elena found out she was pregnant with Gertrudis because of the negro she loved. She planned on running away with him to start a free life with him. Unfortunately, he was shot and killed so she could no longer live her life the way she wanted. When Mama Elena married her ‘chosen to be,’ she had 2 other children, which were; Tita and Rosaura. Mama Elena was the least successful because she was unable to win in challenging her societal role as a woman. She was unable to change her course of life to what she wanted and to become…

    • 1067 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Identifying envy in friendships between women can be tricky, especially when the so called friends tend to fake their actions and intentions quite well in order to gain what they initially desire. The “Friendship” between the ladies in Desdemona: a play about a handkerchief by Paula Vogel should not even be called that, as it is something that for all intents and purposes non-existent. Through various distinctive ways, the women proved over and over that there is not even a genuine care between them. When envy exists between women, a true friendship can never even be born. The ladies, Desdemona, Emilia and Bianca were longing for each other’s lives, men and things to the point that they were literally willing to risk anything, including committing…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays