Analysis Of Soren Kierkegaard's Ethical Dilemma

Decent Essays
In the section, Is there a teleological suspension of the ethical? Soren Kierkegaard uses the biblical passage of Abraham to analyze the difference between the ethical realm and that of the religious. Abraham’s passage serves as a metaphor that raises questions on the validity of the arguments imposed by both the ethical and religious sides. Was Abraham justified to murder his son? Under what accounts is he to be labeled as a murderer and under what light is he seen as a man of faith? In this section, Kierkegaard makes a distinction between the ethical and religious realms and helps answer the questions that arose from the Abraham story. The difference between being in the ethical realm and transcending into the glory of the religious realm lies in faith. Those who have faith suspend the telos in the hands of faith, knowing that even in the face of adversity and uncertainty, they will end up preserving their telos. …show more content…
Faith is above the universal. Faith requires that extra step in believing that God will save you despite having feelings of doubt and anxiety. These feelings are not absent in those in the religious realm, but what draws them apart from the ethical realm is that despite having these doubts, they still jumped towards God. Abraham is justified on the grounds that he is superior to the universal and has surpassed that stage because he “stands in an absolute 0relation to the absolute” (p.85). At one point, the individual had doubts and was tempted by the outside distractions (making him once subordinate) but because he had faith, he was able to suspend his purpose (teleo) on God, trusting in him his destiny. It is at this point where he enters the realm of faith and stands in front of God. “[Abraham] is higher than the universal” (p.85), because he goes beyond the universal and rational thought to the realm of uncertainty. His actions are irrationally rationalized by

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Life is not an inevitable historical process of betterment, he declared in the text, but is rather defined by the individual's leap of decision, for every human being is faced with an unavoidable Either/Or of deciding for a life defined either by the aesthetic and the ethical or by Christianity. The aesthetic is marked by flight from commitment, by relativism and hedonism; the ethical bows before the universals of humanity, morality, and religion. In that each tears apart the claim for and the reality of an actual life and thereby falsities of human existence, Kierkegaard argued, both end in despair. Only the decision for Christianity- the ''leap'' into confession of sin, profession of faith, and following after love-holds together the claims for our lives and the actual reality of those lived lives themselves and thus leads to authentic…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Podmore (2009) explains how Kierkegaard’s struggle with despair reveals a profound psychological of understanding sin. He then goes on to establish how Kierkegaard’s equally insightful theological understanding of grace, answers Kierkegaard’s existential struggle with despair. Only when one is laid bare before God, hiding no part of the self or the horror of its sin, can one receive forgiveness and (self-) acceptance before God. This forgiveness and acceptance nourishes and heals the brokenness that sin produces in our souls (Podmore, 2009, p.…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    King Abimelech's Analysis

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Once again, Abraham lies in an alien land and uses Sarah to safeguard his life. Similar to the fate of the Pharaoh, the deity threatens King Abimelech’s life because of Abraham’s deceit. However, this time, the deity states that Abraham is a prophet and informs the king that Abraham has the power to pray for him and save his life. King Abimelech gives Abraham sheep, oxen, and male and female slaves just as the Pharaoh had done in Egypt. Thus, from one narrative to the next, as Abraham journeys through alien lands, he gains not only material resources, including livestock and slaves, which improves his social-economic status, but he also receives land and silver (20:16) and increased socio-religious status and power through his covenant with the Lord and the Lord’s conference of the position “prophet” upon him.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this brief excerpt from Joseph Nye's, Hypothetical Situation, we see a very unethical action soon to take place just as we intervene. A local military officer is detected about to execute three villagers for the death of one officer who was shot the night prior. We intervene and we are given the choice to shoot one villager to save two. A quick glance at this and you experience a sense of a philosophical dilemma. There are various ways to go about solving this dilemma and each one of them has its benefits and risks.…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Teaching faith to assist the “salvation” process is a lofty ideal for schools”; this is one of the main statements of Teaching Faith in the Twenty First Century: Pointers for Christian Schools, by its author Barry Hill (pg. 18). In this article, Hill attempts firstly to describe faith itself by unraveling the etymology and historic definitions of the word faith. The definitions that the author uses are referrals from several 20-century writers, as well as from seven different languages at distinct historical timespans. Based on the most common definitions of faith, Hill constructs and displays nine different aspects of faith and later what he calls the six “faces of faith in schools” (pg. 21).…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Judaism vs. Islam In this essay I will review my understanding of the major beliefs and practices of two of the great Abrahamic religions, Judaism and Islam. I will attempt to take the position of proponents of each religion, and delineate areas of agreement and disagreement. What makes this comparison so compelling, and relevant, is the great human suffering that has resulted, and continues to result, from those who cloak their aggression and hatred under the veil of each religion. Judaism is quite liberal on the issue of the exact nature of God.…

    • 1068 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the first two chapters of the textbook “A Practical Companion to Ethics” written by Anthony Weston the author places a strong amount of concentration on the relationship between ethics and religion. Weston wants the reader to understand that although religion has guided us into what we view as morally right it is not the end all decision. Ethics is a rather difficult topic as humankind is constantly evolving and changing, and people often develop rather strong opinions on what is considered to be “right”. It is always possible to be virtuous without religion, however not without set morals or rules. During the Module 1 selection of the book Weston provides lots of clear evidence as to why ethics should not and does not require a religious backing.…

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Defense, Critique and Integration of the 4 Apologetic Methods Defense of Fideism To approach apologetics is to seek to fulfill the command of Scripture “always being prepared to make a defense to anyone who asks you for a reason for the hope that is in you” In light of this, the believer ought to approach apologetics as the overflow of their relationship with Jesus. Approaching apologetics from the fideist perspective is to embrace the mystery and paradox of knowing God in faith, rather than through an extended philosophically rooted line of reasoning. Instead of using human means to explain the reality which is far above human understanding, fideist seek to share their encounter with Jesus, the ultimate reality, rather than attempting to…

    • 2020 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Introduction: In Overhearing the Gospel, Fred B. Craddock makes the case for Kierkegaard’s communication method of indirect discourse (Craddock, 2002). The author seeks to answer this following question: “How does one person communicate the Christian faith to another?” (Craddock, 2002, p. 4). Craddock sets out to analyze the aspects of Kierkegaard’s method of communication and clarify the problems the 19th-century Danish philosopher’s indirect discourse approach faced in communicating the gospel during his lifetime (Beddingfield, 1978).…

    • 1331 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Korsgaard, who preaches the Neo-Kantian theories of philosophy, also makes a point that living beings, both human and non-human, can have intrinsic moral worth without having high rationality. She argues that humans face the problem of normativity, which emerges because of the reflective structure of human consciousness. Our reflective capacities make us less impulsive and allow us to take decisions in a more matured manner. When we determine whether a particular desire of ours should be reason enough to act on, we engage in a deeper level of reflection. Korsgaard points out that humans face the problem of normativity in a way that non-humans do not, by explaining how a lower animal’s perceptions of the world are its beliefs and its desires and impulses are its will.…

    • 1748 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1) With duty-based ethics it’s about obedience of law, performing an act morally because it’s out of duty. The act is based on the fact that it’s our obligation, we do the duty out of oughtness. Virtue ethics is different from duty-based ethics as one is not acting out of oughtness or duty, but out of motivation and feelings. Acting on moral character. Virtue ethics would be to perform an act for example out of love for a mother who is ill; you take care of her because of the love you have for her not because it your duty.…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is often confused what faith is and what it is not. Indeed it is an abstract term which its definition will change depending on who you ask. Throughout the works of two authors, Faith by Terrence W. Tilley and The Essential Tillich by Paul Tillich, the term faith gets evaluated and explained in a more in depth fashion. Everyone has faith; it does not have to be a religious belief, but in fact it can be a relationship with something, a center of value, or a motive. Faith, to me, is an abstruse concept where the components of belief, hope and morality unite to form a synonymous definition.…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The use of animals in research is widely accepted, particularly within the scientific community. However, with the rise of new technologies and growing concern over animal welfare, the ethics of animal experimentation and the extent to which it is practiced has increasingly come into question. Although animal experimentation is regulated to prevent excessive suffering, opponents argue that these measures are insufficient. Proponents of animal research argue that knowledge gained from it and the various applications for it justify the unethical manner by which that knowledge is obtained. This argument neglects critical moral considerations rooted in deontology and utilitarianism which condemn the unethical use of animals for the advancement…

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nguyen 1 Randy Nguyen Brother Owen J. Sadlier, OSF. Logic 12/15/17 In the world we live in there are reasons for everything, and we all have a certain type of faith that we believe in within ourselves. Reason can be best understood with principles such as intellectual, moral, religious and practical inquiry. Faith is very comprehensible by reason, and they are both are like the sources of authority upon the beliefs we believe in such as the Christian faith.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    17 dela Cruz, Pamela S HA-1 THE THREE ESSENTIAL DIMENSIONS OF FAITH Faith is a way of life and it is about completely believing and trusting God and all of His plans for us. Faith is vitally essential in our Christian life because it encompasses every part of an individual; his/her mind, will and heart. 1. Believing (Mind) The first dimension of faith is the most basic one and this includes recognizing the truth about Jesus Christ and his own teachings to His people.…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics