Greenblatt The Swerve Analysis

Good Essays
There has been a long tradition in manuscript and print culture, and that tradition is associated with the act of writing, transferring the product of the human intellect and imagination on a tangible that will carry it to distant places and distant times. The book as we know it extends past the life of its author the life of its language, it was written, and the style of art of its content. An Analyses of Greenblatt’s the swerve argues that the defiance of religion is what leads to the change from manuscript culture to print culture. The printing press allowed for the world to develop from manuscript culture to print culture but this change would have happened regardless of the technological advances due to the protestant reformation. In …show more content…
This poem itself goes against the church, Therefore it should have never been archived in the monastery, for a manuscript of its contents to be surrounded by other manuscripts should be compared to keeping a criminal who has been convicted of unlawful actions to be left in regular society. The discovery that Poggio had in the monastery should be categorized a swerve in which it definitely was the moment in history when the world began to change to become the modern world we now live in. Greenblatt discusses how the concentration of intellect and education was centered on the printing presses and cities that have invested interest in any sort of print. The spread of print was associated to the creation of the printing press, but this was not the main driver in the change from …show more content…
Greenblatt indicates throughout the story the revolution of consciousness caused by the poem leads us to the modernity we now live in. Though Greenblatt argues the curiosity that inhabited the mind of Poggio led to the spread of print culture I believe it was the studious personality and obsession with learning is what Poggio spread which in fat then began to spread. The poem of Lucretius let out that pleasure could be found in reading text. The technology that was advancing during their time was a smaller influences for the change in the culture around them. The friends of Poggio spread the text of Lucretius but what they were really spreading was the beginning stages of having a hobby, and this hobby happened to be reading text. Poggio becomes the protagonist who breaks the barrier in the transition period, the medieval manner states that curiosity is banned by the roman church, but Poggio transitioned the curiosity to the desire for intellect acquired by books. Greenblatt highlights the monastery where the church had monks creating manuscripts and archiving of intelligence was the foundation entirely for the continuous creating of text

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Although it seems obvious, it was so valuable to learn about the importance of reading and writing, and how to do both. Growing up, I loved reading. But the steady advances of technology easily overshadowed my creative desires. Webster taught me that reading is imperative: that I must make time for it, that novels don’t have to be classics to be good literature, and that I can read poetry and enjoy it without having an essay of analysis ready to go. People always say that reading is so important, but because of the way reading was placed alongside the writing in our workshops, I realized that reading teaches you how to write by example.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The invention of writing allowed an easier access to book and an advancement in inventions. Even though reading a book is not a direct form of communication, it could allow for a great conversation with one that has also read a similar book. Yet, according to McLuhan, books began isolating those who grew fond of them. He also continued on to point out that because of the isolation and books, there came “the new cult of individualism.” (McLuhan 13). However, technology such as the internet has improved international communication by allowing people from all over the world to communicate and enjoy the same moments.…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Attention-Deep Reading

    • 1340 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Dating back to the collapse of the Roman Empire, the written word perpetually focused on accommodating the unique appetite of readers. As people became more literate and demanded a quick and private reading environment, a “revolution in the structure…

    • 1340 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Mikhail Bakhtin Dialogism

    • 1304 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Interlude: Read with your Ears In this chapter, Foster points out the mistake of reading with “our” eyes. Instead, the use of the “inner ear” benefits strongly configuring the thought process and the significance of using past recollection. The “inner ear” that Foster mention involve sorting information from specific words or phrases to bringing readers to a particular past knowledge: “whether...information comes from print or film...simply read [from] the text” (217). The “inner ear” Foster is referring to is the implement of intertextuality which include “The Law of Universal Connectedness: Every novel grows out of other novels” (218). In another word, writers and readers are influence by one another either by another book, movie, or…

    • 1304 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    King James Thesis

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages

    He was notably educated in poetry by George Buchanan. He was influenced politically with the idea that the king is beholden to the people for his power. Later he rejected those theories in favor of a belief in kingship by divine right. At an early age he learned to read and write in several languages. He was smart and one of the first to deeply understand how books could be a form of media and used he that to spread his ideas when he published his own books.…

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This change in the attitude of writers and people is called Romanticism. The Romantic Development is a standout amongst an essential literary time frame ever; influencing the writing, music, and craft of the period. It supported spontaneity and acting with feelings, not basic common sense. In the more traditional style of writing, scholars tended to their books to the privileged, yet now journalists tended to the basic man and his issues. There was a new feeling of spirituality.…

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Loran Rolfe 12.2 2 February 2018 Mrs Klopper English Reflective essay Final draft The Words That Form Us Book have the ability to change the world. They reflect the very nature of humans desire to learn more, feel more and discover more. As the world heads further and further away from appreciating the power of words and the beauty that is encapsulated by poetry and novels, books have become forgotten and undervalued. It's important to remember that there is beauty in the words, if we look hard enough for them, and that these words are the very tools that shape our minds and epitomize our world. The importance of books and words is a central idea in The Book Thief by Markus Zusak.…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    However, Harold Schweizer questions the readers’ intents when he states “suffering can become the occasion of an endless act of comprehension”. Reading literature does not equal comprehension or understanding. Readers must first understand how their life shapes their perspective and then they must let other perceptions dominate their thoughts in order to understand the writer’s perspective. Barbara Tuchman explains that books are the foundation of life’s disciplines because “books are humanity in print”. We read books to understand other people’s culture, struggle, and perspective, but only if we desire to understand.…

    • 1523 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Throughout history, society has influenced the way humanity thinks about and understands the world around them. Few people search to find the truth for themselves and merely end up following the way of life seen all around them. A new movement sprung up in the late 1700s called Romanticism, celebrating creativity and imagination over logic, reason, and the limitations society placed on thought. Romanticism began around the end of the Enlightenment period, a time that focused heavily on science and logical reasoning.Through the poetry written during this period, one can see the message that was so desperate to be heard. From Romantic poets such as Walt Whitman and Emily Dickinson, one can learn to value independent thought, and emotional insight,…

    • 1358 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Instead, they brought science revision books, feverously reciting the information. Fiction had only served as an enjoyment, a luxury for them when it was not as important to do last minute revision. But when the exams drew near, they used the time to study instead of relax. An interest to find out why compelled me to do my portfolio on this topic. The idea of reading fiction in our lives is widely seen as secondary to exams and our studies, from my experience.…

    • 1925 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays