Greenblatt The Swerve Analysis

Improved Essays
There has been a long tradition in manuscript and print culture, and that tradition is associated with the act of writing, transferring the product of the human intellect and imagination on a tangible that will carry it to distant places and distant times. The book as we know it extends past the life of its author the life of its language, it was written, and the style of art of its content. An Analyses of Greenblatt’s the swerve argues that the defiance of religion is what leads to the change from manuscript culture to print culture. The printing press allowed for the world to develop from manuscript culture to print culture but this change would have happened regardless of the technological advances due to the protestant reformation. In …show more content…
This poem itself goes against the church, Therefore it should have never been archived in the monastery, for a manuscript of its contents to be surrounded by other manuscripts should be compared to keeping a criminal who has been convicted of unlawful actions to be left in regular society. The discovery that Poggio had in the monastery should be categorized a swerve in which it definitely was the moment in history when the world began to change to become the modern world we now live in. Greenblatt discusses how the concentration of intellect and education was centered on the printing presses and cities that have invested interest in any sort of print. The spread of print was associated to the creation of the printing press, but this was not the main driver in the change from …show more content…
Greenblatt indicates throughout the story the revolution of consciousness caused by the poem leads us to the modernity we now live in. Though Greenblatt argues the curiosity that inhabited the mind of Poggio led to the spread of print culture I believe it was the studious personality and obsession with learning is what Poggio spread which in fat then began to spread. The poem of Lucretius let out that pleasure could be found in reading text. The technology that was advancing during their time was a smaller influences for the change in the culture around them. The friends of Poggio spread the text of Lucretius but what they were really spreading was the beginning stages of having a hobby, and this hobby happened to be reading text. Poggio becomes the protagonist who breaks the barrier in the transition period, the medieval manner states that curiosity is banned by the roman church, but Poggio transitioned the curiosity to the desire for intellect acquired by books. Greenblatt highlights the monastery where the church had monks creating manuscripts and archiving of intelligence was the foundation entirely for the continuous creating of text

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Briefly introduced, Sven Birkerts was a former lecturer at several colleges in MA and currently a great critic with the Gutenberg of Elegies as his best-known criticism on how reading was drowned in the electronic age. In his essay, The Owl has Flown, Sven Birkets mentions how crucial reading and thinking to one’s life that it would give an impact towards the moral progress. Current education structure is one of the causes that initiate the changes of today’s people reading behaviour, but technology is the most primary. Birkerts makes a clear contrast between people in the earlier day and now, where long ago, books are scarce, all hand-written, and the reader would go over and over again of the same book until he got to comprehend the book…

    • 410 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Barthelme, Donald. “At the End of the Mechanical Age”. The Heath Anthology of American Literature. Ed. Paul Lauter. 7th ed. Vol. E. Boston: Wadsworth, 2014. 3366-3371. Print.…

    • 1358 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He also understood the potential damage that would be caused by the loss of print media and the ideas they contain. His novella is a cautionary tale to those who value intelligence, empathy, and critical thinking. Nicholas Carr’s work is also a cautionary tale for contemporary readers who understand that one’s mind must be regularly engaged and strengthened, otherwise it will atrophy and dissolve like sand through a sieve. Clearly, Carr’s work supports the theme developed by Bradbury nearly 60 years…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Renaissance Dbq Essay

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages

    After the Middle Ages, a time called the Renaissance came into action. This change impacted everyone whether they wanted it to or not. New ways of art, literature, science, and much more were born into the world. The people who were living in this time period had no idea at the time but, everything around them was evolving into new, better ways of life. There came a different view of the world and it transformed everybody’s aspects into something that can never change back. The purpose of this paper is to explain how the Renaissance changed the views of the world.…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Less than a few years after the torrential Black Plague ravaged through central Europe, one of the most influential, and significant time periods in history, The Renaissance, occurred. During this time there were spikes of interest in art, science, writing and poetry, and religion. While many of these interests were significant, the biggest changes were made in the aspects of religion, artistic and scientific, and poetic advancements.…

    • 1094 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    During the Renaissance in Europe, the bases of education were starting to see reforment due to the biased education system which favored Latin which was no longer being used. During this time having access to an education was the privilege of the upper class, while most people in the lower class didn’t receive the basic units of education like reading or writing. The few people who were lucky enough to read and write weren’t getting a proper education. The education system was outdated and was only teaching them Latin which wasn’t of any use anymore. People were outraged because of this and decided to publish their thoughts and send them out into the public as in a way to spread the awareness and challenge the…

    • 126 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    While Chartier examines signature rates to determine the effects of printing and literacy rates of the period, author Andrew Pettegree examines “coherent narratives of print from the 1450’s” through a broad range of never before available, online resources in his book, The Book in the Renaissance. Pettegree explains that through the cost effective and mass production printed material progressively extended away from methodical, theoretical, intellectual and dogmatic manuscripts that previously dominated the book trade of the 15th…

    • 1315 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the articles “ The Epic Love Story of Sam and Dean” by Catherine Tosenberger and “Women, Star Trek and the Early Development of Fannish Vidding” by Francesca Coppa, examples of both textual poaching and intertextuality, or nomadic reading is demonstrated. Based off of discussions in class and Henry Jenkins “Get A Life”, textual poaching refers to the relationship between fans and producers, where fans interpret and re-create new materials by the appropriation of various media content. Nomadic reading describes how fans actively compose new material by incorporating existing texts into their work.…

    • 459 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The modern person’s artistic landscape is so defined by visual narratives both on T.V and in the movies that people can hardly imagine a world without images. People see books as cheaply made movies, and this can ruin the appeal books can give. The catcher in the Rye however has…

    • 1445 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “It’s Time To Say Goodbye to Books,” by Tony Gates, the author persuades the audience how books printed on paper are no longer socially responsible. To develop his argument, the author uses a delayed thesis and literary allusion. He includes these rhetorical devices in order to show the audience how books are not as socially responsible as it was in the past.…

    • 520 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The history of American literature is filled with many great works and authors. From the writings of the earliest colonists and onward, the thoughts, emotions, and standards of society are reflected in the written words. As the years progressed so did the words. The writings from the Age of Discovery and the Age of Reason convey powerful feelings in the foundation of a new nation. While the literature produced by the authors during these time periods changes greatly in tone, the underlying sentiment of religious belief and a trust in God remains.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This realization that change was needed came mainly from upper-class writers that had been looking upon the ancient Roman Republic, because of their obsession with that culture, and saw a totally different society. They saw an education system that formed the Roman Republic’s culture along with gender roles that were opposed to the current culture of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. This caused the upper-class writers of the time to feel obligated to act and set all that had gone wrong in society back to what they considered right. This would include the reinstitution or revitalization of the education system and reimplementation of the gender roles. These two components that had disappeared in the time between the Roman Republic and the fourteenth and fifteenth century. This would include the inclusion of Latin and Greek literature from the Roman Republic that would become known as Humanism. To be able to bring back the currently unpopular gender roles, women’s education would need to be censored and restricted. This would reaffirm the woman’s place as home caretaker, entertainer, and male support agent. This is what was considered lady like and this would be fostered by the control of their…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The transformations in communication can be seen through Renaissance artwork, and even Early Italian artwork. Specifically speaking, in the bronze gilt panel “The Story of Jacob and Esau,” created by Lorenzo Ghiberti in 1435, the artist uses high and low relief techniques to tell an entire biblical story in one panel. Through his use of space—creating a frontal, middle, and background—Ghiberti creates three separate scenes in the painting, which was a new technique used to communicate messages, or in this case a story, to viewers. In addition, Ghiberti uses a vanishing point and creates a center of the artwork, implementing mathematical techniques to achieve symmetry and beauty in his panel. Furthermore, since this panel was part of “The Gates of Paradise,” “the east doors of the Baptistery of San Giovanni [in] Florence,” everyday citizens of Florence encountered these panels when they went to church. This elementary observation argues against one of Green’s main points as to why he believes the Renaissance never occurred; “95 percent of Europeans did not encounter the Renaissance” (Green). In broader terms, the Renaissance artist Ghiberti coupled science or mathematics with art in order to communicate and touch his audience in a different way—something that had never been done before the Renaissance…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Petrarch’s work ranges from letters to Cicero and Virgil, scholarly works, essays to poetry. He is most commonly recognized for the Canzoniere and Trionfi. Pertrach is one of the earlier humanists, and he is also considered the “Father of Humanism”. The presence of Petrarch in the culture of literature is key in two major aspects. The first point is his role as a figure and of his work in the culture, but more generally speaking in the first decades when the poet, with other authors, became part of a new cult. The second point is the influence that Petrarch’s work had on Italian poetry.…

    • 669 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Picturebook Analysis

    • 1942 Words
    • 8 Pages

    To begin the story, the narrator uses “direct address to the reader”: the narrator exposes itself and refers to itself as “I”, which reveals the story as a construction (Nikolajeva & Scott, 2006, p.221). Later, when Henry gives up eating books and becomes upset, the narrator asks the direct question to the reader: “What was he to do?”. This creates intimacy between the narrator and the reader and draws the reader in more. One of the most significant devices is Jeffers’ “pastiche of illustrative styles” (Anstey, 2009, p.34). Collage is evident in places as Jeffers draws on a wide range of recycled background materials, including covers, spines, and endpapers from books; lined paper, squared paper and graph paper in notebooks; index cards and pages from dictionaries, atlases; and even maths books. Through the technique of collage, these materials not only “draw attention to themselves for what they are”, but also require the reader to “see them as part of the composition” (Doonan, 1993, p.82). Many of them are tattered, yellowed, torn, or flyblown. Placing them within the story, Jeffers creates subtle connections and composes new meanings. He turns the cover of an encyclopaedia into a theatre stage, and the school blackboard comes from the cover of a book published by “Board of Education”. A page from a dictionary becomes wallpaper (figure 4) and humorously contains the words “intellectuality”, “intelligence”, and…

    • 1942 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays