The Swedish Parliamentary And Korean Presidential System

Great Essays
Introduction: Parallels in political structure between the Swedish parliamentary and Korean presidential systems of legislative governance provide a baseline where the study of cross structural stability can be analyzed while holding the independent variables such as unicameral legislative bodies, coalition based majorities in these bodies, and executive-legislative interactions constant. In this paper the Tsebelis ' sub veto player theory on “absorption rule” will be examined in the context of legislative stability in unicameral political democracies. While the unicameral nature of the countries ' legislatures creates environments of decreased legislative stability, this instability is unevenly counteracted by factors of executive dominance …show more content…
Compared to Sweden’s relatively constrained parliamentary executive, Korea presents a presidential system in which it 's executive is on the brink of extraordinary levels of legislative power. Minor stability provided by multiparty representation in the legislature is partially diminished in both countries by the powers and limitations provided to the Korean and Swedish executives respectfully.

Sweden: The Swedish government is formed via a Speaker of the Riksdag nominated Prime Minister, and that Prime Minister 's subsequently appointed cabinet members. The Prime Minister nomination is confirmed in light of no majority opposition in the Riksdag, and for this reason is often, but not always, a representative of the majority coalition 's senior party (Currently the SDP). The Prime Minister has no set term limit, and can serve his position until he no longer has majority support in the Riksdag, this is contrasted with the Riksdag 's members four year terms. Both the Prime Minister and his Cabinet are subject to a relatively lenient vote of no confidence that requires only an simple majority (175 votes) to remove either from office. For this reason, unless under extenuating circumstances, the term limit of the Prime Minister and their cabinet are likely to coincide with
…show more content…
The Prime Minister is appointed by the dominate coalition of the Riksdag, and can be subsequently disbanded by that same majority. This does not mean the Swedish Prime Minister is out of power however, strong party allegiance and an agenda setting power gives him substantial power as head of government. This role is however overshadowed when compared to the relative power invested by the Korean political structure to their head of state. Criossant, her study of delagative democratic systems, found Korea 's structural weaknesses as an void in which a “hyper-presidential-government” can be, an arguably has been, formed (Croissant, 2010). She found that when the National Assembly was dominated by the same political party as the president Tsebelis ' “absorbtion rule” on veto players essentially negates the legislatures ability to serve as a viable veto player to the President. When combined with the unbelievable decree and agenda setting powers of the President the Korean Presidential system becomes borderline non-democratic in its liberal affordance of power to the Executive (Croissant,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Bostonistan Case Study

    • 2073 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Since these members of state cabinets can be removed at any time, they are able to check the power of the state without concern of re-election. While, Bostonistan’s may be skeptical of a body of government only indirectly elected by the people its role of revisiting and slowing down the legislative processes emphasizes accountability and putting high value on counteracting the temptation of majoritarianism which diminishes and potentially destroys democracy. To illustrate its effectiveness, over the last half century Germany has not encountered a manufactured…

    • 2073 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Hoai Thuong Thi Nguyen Professor Hans Klein PHIL 3127 December 11, 2015 PAPER #2 Plato, Herman And Chomsky About Democracy Leadership is very important in a country because it has the capacity to take it to the next level of success and even lead the people during times of war into fighting successful battles that ends in victory. The philosophers like Herman and Chomsky and Plato however had different views on how the people should be governed. The different types of governments are very important to be understood so that every person who wants to understand why his government is not functioning properly can do so through the lens of the philosophers. Herman and Chomsky states that there are reasons why the government of the day may resort…

    • 1451 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Livonia Case Study

    • 1852 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The primary goal of the new government system within Livonia is to protect the new democracy and revitalize their economy, which can only be done if the people in power have the same goal in mind. Livonia must find a way for the right people to be elected and put in influential positions, which means that the right government infrastructure must be in place. With the right government infrastructure not only do the chances of Livonia protecting their democracy and improving their economy increase, the likelihood of Livonia falling back into its communist regime or falling under a new extremist regime decreases. In Livonia’s case, the new system must make sure that the parties of Hands Across Livonia are more dominant than groups like the Kinder,…

    • 1852 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In many countries such as Canada and the United States, the hegemony has been divided between the executive branch, the judiciary courts and the legislative branch. “Generally, the amount of power for each member of these institutions is to be uniformly divided; conversely, the fairly recent transformation has increasingly concentrated the majority of power towards the hearts of the government” ("Is the Canadian Prime Minister too Powerful?,"2010). In recent years, many political scientist have argued that the demographic changes in political systems have led the executive branches in western governments to have extensive amounts of power. In this essay, I will argue that the executive branches of western governments; particularly that of Canada’s…

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The president is neither dismissible or appoint-able. He is a single headed executive. In the semi presidential system, the president exists along with a prime minister and a cabinet. The prime minister and the cabinet is responsible for the legislature of a state.…

    • 145 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In democratic governments, legislatures play vital roles to help maintain peace and prosperity and work along-side the country’s leaders. However, in authoritarian governments, legislatures serve more as a symbolic organization with little power and works for the country’s leader and does what he wants. The legislatures can be disbanded and convened anytime the authoritarian leader decides because in authoritarian government the leader’s word goes. There are many examples of this in Russian history and other authoritarian regimes such as in early European history. Legislatures in authoritarian governments have very little real political power and often serve to maintain political parties and help provide legitimacy for the authoritarian government.…

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Recently, the leader of the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (DPRK) ordered his military prepared for the nuclear strike, and they are making a nuclear threat to the world again. The world would not be peaceful if a nuclear threat again appeared in this world. Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (DPRK) is also known as North Korea is an international byword for isolationism, autonomy and antagonism. Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (DPRK) has isolated itself from the rest of the world for more than 50 years. In Park Yong-Soo’s article “The political economy of economic reform in North Korea”, he claims that “North Korea has undergone an unprecedented economic crisis, which began in the early 1990s.…

    • 1560 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As legislature is a direct representation of the will of the people, democracies tend to grant the legislative branch of government a majority of the power, in comparison to the executive and judicial branches; Tocqueville asserts that without sufficient checks and balances, the legislative power can readily become tyrannical. Alongside this, Tocqueville also addresses the power of the legislature’s ability to allow the president to be re-elected, which evidently, weakens the independence of the executive branch. Tocqueville claims that if the president wishes to be re-elected, he/she will lose much of his/her ability to make independent decisions based off his/her judgement, instead however, he/she will base his/her decisions on whether it will appease the people, despite if they may have the knowledge to judge what is in the best interest of the state, evidently, increasing the danger of the legislative power to become tyrannical. Another evident weakness Tocqueville discusses in Democracy of America is the direct election of representatives and their limited duration in office; these provisions are mediocre and contradictory.…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The government control North Korea has over it’s people can be compared to extremities that are portrayed in the dystopian novel, Anthem. In Anthem, Rand’s purpose is to give an insight to what the world could be like if we let the government control society completely; and the government structure in Anthem provides readers with horrendous comparisons to the society of North Korea. The North Korean society has been…

    • 1820 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Prime Minster Powers

    • 1535 Words
    • 7 Pages

    There are certain constraints that can be exercised to limit powers of the prime minster, and in this essay we will be examining these principle constraints. Furthermore, this essay will also look into presidential prime minster, a political model where the…

    • 1535 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Leaders or ministers of an agency who generally do not have advanced technical training in the area of their administrative portfolio possess considerable power over the agencies actions, and in some cases its objectives. A severe deviation could be based purely on value or instrumental rationality, even on behalf of their associated political party. A poor decision might be in contrast with popular public opinion, and, in turn, destabilise the legitimacy of the executive authority. A contemporary example of legal-rational authority is evident in all liberal democratic states, whose leaders claim their legitimacy based on formalised legal processes. Its wide dissemination is a testament to its ability to provide lasting political…

    • 1100 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Impeachment is very difficult and president’s supporters might start crisis that could create instability and encourage non-democratic actors to take over. On the other hand, executive in the parliamentary system could easily remove through a vote of no confidence. Furthermore, succession can also be a problem in presidential systems because vice presidents are often less known persons. Lastly, Linz argues that presidentialism has a winner-takes-all logic that is unfavorable to democratic stability.…

    • 542 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Until late 2016, Korean citizens were unaware of Park’s secret relation with Choi Sun-sil, the Korean Rasputin. When their relationship got revealed, people’s trust towards Park has immediately reached the nadir, and protested for Park’s impeachment. Eventually, President Park was impeached. This shows that if the ruler of the country attempts to conceal their actions, it will eventually get revealed to the surface, ultimately leading to his/her demise. 9.…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In this chapter it describes the type of government is used and the pros and cons. According to Johannes, “the Parliamentary government is the type of government that rest on the principle of concentrating political power, fusing legislative, and executive authority (16).” This type of government is considered to be effective and efficient. This type of government depends on strong political parties. The political parties elect their members using different methods, however, there are pros and cons in Parliamentary government.…

    • 1402 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The election process for President in the United States is an indirect process wherein citizens cast their votes to a group of members of the United States Electoral College. The elected members cast their votes directly for the Vice President and President of the United States. The Presidential election method had been established according to Article Two of U.S. Constitution. It was a result of the negotiation between those who favored national popular vote and the constitutional farmers who preferred the Congress to choose the President. Based on the current election procedure, the Presidential candidate who receives majority of the electoral votes is appointed to the office however if no candidate receives the majority, the House of Representatives…

    • 1564 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays