It is true that at both the beginning and end of the short story, Louise Mallard has the heart illness, however, it is unclear whether or not the illness persists throughout the story. It seems that once she believes that she is widowed, her illness dissipates. For instance, after Josephine is checking up on Louise, Louise states that she is “not making [herself] ill” (Chopin 2). The purpose of this quote is to imply that Louise’s feels her condition is improved because of the loss of her husband. As a result, Louise’s conditions is no longer present, thus, the symbol for heart illness can not be applied. Therefore, once it is established that her heart illness is gone, the argument connecting heartbrokenness to Louise’s weak heart is no longer
It is true that at both the beginning and end of the short story, Louise Mallard has the heart illness, however, it is unclear whether or not the illness persists throughout the story. It seems that once she believes that she is widowed, her illness dissipates. For instance, after Josephine is checking up on Louise, Louise states that she is “not making [herself] ill” (Chopin 2). The purpose of this quote is to imply that Louise’s feels her condition is improved because of the loss of her husband. As a result, Louise’s conditions is no longer present, thus, the symbol for heart illness can not be applied. Therefore, once it is established that her heart illness is gone, the argument connecting heartbrokenness to Louise’s weak heart is no longer