The Relationship Between Nation Building And Empire Building

Improved Essays
Thesis
The process through which the United States engages in State building, is rooted in the interplay of state formation and empire building that the US underwent, following its independence, as it expanded westwards; US led state formation and attempts at democracy building can therefore be understood as a continuation of American imperial goals.
Outline
In this paper, we will explore the connection between the roles that the US attempts to plays internationally, developing democratic institutions and stimulating economic development, and the historic development of the US, taking into account the roles that nation building and empire building took in that development. To establish the case that the role that the US attempts to play is a positive one, we will first look at The State Partnership Program as an example of what some deem to be a positive model of US led democratization. Following this, we will attempt to demonstrate the short comings of this model, and using the conceptual framework of nation building and empire building, will demonstrate that this model fits with the historic development of the US. Finally we will draw on the example of
…show more content…
Under SPP, State National Guards provide training to the militaries of the partner nation. While SPP originally involved only direct military to military support, but grew to also include some Civilian support as well, however, unlike the military training which is fully funded by the federal government, whatever civilian support is provided is funded by the participating state government. SPP’s main benefit however, is that it allows the US to build a coalition of likeminded states that the US can rely on for support in fighting against

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    During the years of 1895-1920, America had started to move towards the idea of getting involved with foreign places. With the closing of the frontier, America had started to search for a type of ‘new frontier’ that they could conquer. The factor most important in driving American foreign policy in this time was self-interest. While idealism played a role when America felt the need to help foreign countries, it was ultimately self-interest that led America to take actions in foreign policy. Self- interest is shown when Senator Albert J. Beveridge claims in a speech that America was in need for new markets to get new resources from and to sell to for more trade.…

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    III. Critical Response to Alice H. Amsden’s Thesis At the heart of Escape from Empire, Amsden explains how shifts in American policy between the First and Second American Empire were a detriment to the development of the Third World. More specifically, Amsden’s thesis is that because of American policy rigidity, the Third World could be better suited for development if it cultivates self-determined policy. It is from this dichotomy between progressively driven policies and ideologically driven policies that Amsden theorizes a third American Empire: an ideal regime that promotes equitable policy regardless of economic, geographic or ideological status.…

    • 1526 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It is argued from two sides about the idea of U.S. Imperialism, an expression of nationalism by taking over and colonizing regions, which took place in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The Consensus has argued that U.S. imperialism was a “righteous” path and completely justified. On the other end of the argument, lays the Conflict perspective, which views U.S. behavior of Imperialism as an example of European “empire building.” The Spanish-American War and the Philippine-American War are two examples of conflicts that occurred during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Conflict theorists would insist that these wars broke out due to the consequences of Imperialism.…

    • 1376 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The century between 1820 and 1920 encompassed many different visions for types of relations that would exist between the newly founded American republics. For the United States, the vision consisted of a paternalistic dominance towards its fractious neighbors. Whether carried out by businessmen or diplomats, this policy was readily apparent. Latin American nations held an entirely different view for how relations between themselves and their more powerful sister republic should be. These conflicting visions would lead to marked alterations in how American countries interacted with one another, but while some things were inevitably transformed, others endured.…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By 1914, the Progressive Era had instilled a healthy dose of positive liberty into American domestic policy, resulting in many important educational, labor, and economic reforms that continue to affect American legislature today. But following WWI, President Woodrow Wilson took the concept of positive liberty to an even more influential level by proposing a new approach to foreign policy that essentially advocated for internationalism. In doing so, he was challenging the American tradition of isolationism that had more or less stood unchanged since the presidency of George Washington himself. Because of its perceived radicalism, Wilson’s proposed policy was initially rejected by Congress. But in the years that followed, WWII and the publication…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The earliest American foreign policy successes formulated through the consistent turmoil that engrossed Europe. The historian Samuel Flagg Bemis even coined the phrase “Europe’s distresses led to America’s earliest diplomatic successes.” From the nation’s bloody revolution, to major expansions across the North American continent, major victories for the United States was an outcome of war torn European nations unable to preserve their power in the west and cunning American legislators that parted from traditional diplomacy. Americans fought an uphill battle for respect and global recognition starting with the American Revolution. Patriots kept the British at bay in the early phases of the war but could not sustain under continued offense…

    • 1413 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout time, America has played significant roles in other nations. It has influenced many countries, both positively and negatively. Being one of the most powerful countries, America managed to politically and economically control many areas. Their actions were motivated by different reasons, being the biggest ones a false idea of superiority and a strong prejudice towards other races. But imperialized and oppressed territories couldn’t do anything to stop them, for they lacked, at that time, the strength to get independence.…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although the U.S involvement in global imperialism in the late 1800’s was an investment of uncertainty, their bold moves in acquiring new land have historically been justified by a combination of humanitarian, economic and political theories. During this time period, the United States had begun to achieve great strides as many major cities developed, thus contributing to the shaping of American history and identity. Despite the immense amount of progress that was made, there were several components that the U.S had been striving to resolve including sustaining acquired wealth as well as sustaining the economy. In hopes to address these increasingly pressing matters, President Theodore Roosevelt turned to imperialism in hopes to create a more…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The late nineteenth century is known as “The Age of Imperialism”. This was a time that many major world powers, including the United States, sought to expand their territorial possessions. The idea of American imperialism was very popular, perhaps because U.S. citizens felt that America was exceptional compared to other countries, mainly because of its special mission to spread freedom and democracy worldwide. In order to accomplish this, America would need to exert its economic, military, and cultural influence internationally. Among the many supporters of American imperialism, there are four notable intellectuals that greatly assisted our nation into supporting this ideology, those being Frederick Jackson Turner, Alfred T. Mahan, Herbert…

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American Revolution was a major turning point in American history. It marked the beginning of a new powerful nation and essentially changed the nation politically and socially; however, to some extent, it did not lead to an economic change. There were some benefits to the war; the establishment of the Declaration of Independence, a stronger, centralized government, and eventually progressed the roles of women and slaves. On the contrary, there were still diversions between the rich and poor during and after the Revolution.…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    American Police Action: A Controversy The United States has consistently been the world’s most powerful country, which is a title many Americans are undoubtedly proud to hold. However, with the responsibility that comes with being the most powerful country in the world, the United States has to decide how to use their power. A common but controversial topic is if the US should be the world’s policeman. Time and time again, the world has seen the US act as a global policeman, but there have been no benefits to foreign police actions.…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The variety of issues that the United States has faced over the last two decades forced the country to focus on its own economic recovery. The United States saw a significant economic turnaround after shifting its focus from “global policeman” to domestic issues. During this period, the United States retook its position as the preeminent world power, recapturing the highest GDP and balancing the national deficit. While the United States scaled back its foreign assistance, states began to fail, and radical groups took haven if these areas. Failed states continued to rise as the United States developed its technologies, energy developments, and resource independence.1…

    • 2250 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When Americans started to expand its territory, they didn't look after Native Americans and ignored them. A decade later, with the "criminal aggression" in the Philippines, racism was reflected in new expansion. The American Anti-Imperialist League asserted that the blood of the Filipinos was on American hands, and Americans resented the betrayal (Doc D). Josiah Strong, a prominent Congregationalist minister from Ohio, thought that America needed to claim as many of the unoccupied lands of the world, as it could, in order to further the Anglo-Saxon race (Doc B). At this time, president Roosevelt employed the foreign policy using his new naval Power.…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    State power was exemplified through its organization of congress, where each state had one vote and 9/13 states had to support a law in order for it to be passed. Furthermore, the national government didn’t have an executive or judicial organization. Thus congress lacked the power to tax, regulate trade, or control coinage. With the period of discontent, economic crisis and collapse of Revolutionary expectations that came from the Articles, there was a proposition for redirecting this crumbling…

    • 1927 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Of all the civilizations in history, there is perhaps none as influential (to the Western world at least) as that of Rome. From its earliest roots as a small kingdom, through its era as a republic, to the dominance and decline of its empire, the Roman civilization stood for over two millennia, nearly half of recorded history. Since its fall, countless nations attempted to emulate Rome, attempting to recapture even a hint of its former glory. It can be argued, however, that of all these imitators none came as close in spirit as the United States of America. But while America’s adoption of Roman ideologies helped it mirror the latter’s rise to power, disturbing parallels are coming to light between the state the Roman Republic was in before its fall and United States today.…

    • 1618 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays