Why The Spirit Catches You And You Fall Down Essay

Superior Essays
Medical science doesn’t always solve medical issues based on patient diagnosis. You may find that the the technology and medical science provided by doctors can sometimes create new problems and can result in death. Many medical doctors do not believe that alternative medicine practices in various cultures coupled with technology and medical science produce better medical outcomes.
Lia Lee was diagnosed with epilepsy as a baby in the book “The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down” by Anne Fadiman. Fadiman explains how Lia’s doctors “eagerly embrace new drugs, technologies, and procedures to try and cure Lia’s epilepsy. Their over reliance on the "culture of bio-medicine" may blind them to the merits of cross-cultural medicine. Doctors become absorbed in their work and become so myopic”.
Lia’s parents were opposed to the surgery because they were afraid that their daughter would die.
…show more content…
There are many Hmong beliefs, practices and cures they believe are effective forms of medicine, care and healing. The biggest problem of the cultural differences is the fact that Hmong religion requires animal sacrifices, especially when it comes to the attempt of trying to retrieve a lost or trapped soul, and fixing damaged souls.
The “neeb” is a shamanic ritual form of healing. In order to be sure that rituals were able to heal the infected, they used the body parts or limbs of gutted animals (examples: pigs, cows). The shaman must be sure from his helpers, that they are around the rituals so that the procedure of the Hmong beliefs commence properly.The killing of animals within hospitals are illegal but for the sake of treating Hmong patients, hospitals must make an exception to this religious conflict if they want to treat the patient. This will not be possible in many societies as it is viewed as

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    When asked to speak on the reasoning behind Lia Lee’s parents’ culture and opinion towards traditional medical practices, the California doctors stated that, “men think it is divine merely because they don’t understand it.” (Fadiman, 29) The doctors that cared for Lia believed that the scientific reasoning and diagnosis in Lia’s case was rational and therefore the answer to her problems, while ignoring any other worldviews. This outlook on the human condition diminishes the role of sacred space and the cosmic sense of nature’s ability to heal. Additionally, Eliade describes this thinking as, “the desacralization of the cosmos accomplished by scientific thought.”…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Contrary to Conquergood’s uplifting philosophy on the quintessential needs to acknowledge patients realities, Fadiman in the late chapters of the novel notes a epidemiologist own thoughts on the issue of clashing cultures “for better or for worse, Western medicine is one-sided. Until the culture of medicine changes, it may be difficult for doctors having gone through rigorous academic study to take their reality as only a view, not reality itself…” I found this quote to be very dramatic in the sense that it brings to light the flaws within American medical schools. The culture the colleague mentions, I believe, does have the capability to change given the assumptions that medical school students are not too busy worrying about residency and completing course prerequisites, instead rather taking the time to translate the cultural suffering of various societies into their own studies. Courses lacking integration of anthropology and ethnography are the reasons why the next generations of doctors may be lacking essential concepts of cultural language and the manners which to engage and communicate with patients without the assertive barrier of medical knowledge as a dominating means to control a…

    • 989 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rye Country Day does not offer any classes related to the world of medicine, the closest thing that comes to mind is the anatomy and physiology class, however that course has a focus on the body, not medicine. As a result this book became the first instance in which medicine was presented to me through school. Not only did the book provide detail on the science behind Lia’s condition, but on the significance of medicine in our culture and obviously that of Hmong culture. Hence this book stood out to me among other books in the various English curriculums at Rye Country Day as it presented not only a non-fictional approach, but a sense that education was being delineated in a multifaceted manner. The reality is that in the past English curriculums of Rye Country Day, the various novels have tended to blend into one another; The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down is the diversity missing from those curriculums.…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction The film The Split Horn The Life of a Hmong Shaman in America focuses on how health and illness is dealt with in the Hmong culture. It is about the life of a Hmong family who moved to Appleton Wisconsin from Laos and how they are adapting to this new place. The journey of a Shaman 's family is explored and it is expressed that they have their own set of traditions in their culture but when this family moved to America it was learned that it is difficult to carry out traditions. Illnesses are looked at from different viewpoints across different cultures and depending on an individual 's culture, explanations for health are looked at and treated differently. This family learns that it is difficult to adjust to the American lifestyle,…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Fremgen, she describes a case study, "The case of Janet K. and Epilepsy". Janet was a 27-year-old nursing graduate. From a very young age, she was diagnosed with epilepsy. Epilepsy is a neurological disorder which causes seizures (Mayo Clinic, 2017). As a result of her diagnosis, she suffered from seizures.…

    • 1509 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Essay On Hmong Culture

    • 2194 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Things such as dabs (evil spirts) can harm one of the twelve souls needed, “to be intact in order for a person to be in good health (Lee and Pfeifer, 2009/10).” Other reasons for illness could be spiritual imbalance from: fear, sadness or loneliness (Australian Centre for International and Tropical Health at the University of Queensland, 2003). That’s not to say that the Hmong doesn’t consider certain injuries to the body as separate, like cuts or other external injuries and infectious diseases. Diseases like TB and Chickenpox are known to the Hmong, along with heredity, weather, stress and reckless behavior (Australian Centre for International and Tropical Health at…

    • 2194 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Whether we focus on pharmacology or surgical practices, we all know someone who has survived some kind of diagnosis that 200 years ago would have been certain death. Over the years Holistic or complementary and alternative medicine,…

    • 194 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nursing Case Study

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Therefore, she recently went to her medical doctor, who prescribed some sleeping medications. One week prior to her appointment, she had a seizure. The etiology is unknown, but the doctor at the hospital recommended an…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down explores the relationship between the Hmong culture and the American culture; in particular the differences in medicine. Medicine has been a difficult subject to understand and master; moreover it becomes almost impossible if the person was raised in an entirely different culture than that of western medicine. This book discusses what it was like from both sides; the Hmong and those of the western doctors what it is like to deal with each other when it involves a common interest. That common interest being Lia Lee, an epileptic Hmong child. Both of the parties cared for Lia Lee; however their cultural differences were enough to distract from the real goal.…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    (Hunter, 2010) Such Indigenous expertise is essential to asserting the social and political control which is a precondition to sustained health…

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    it became a problem because this type of ritual is beyond the American culture which conflicted with the laws that they paid no attention to. Another conflict was the medical procedure of the American doctors and the spiritual healing process the Lee’s traditionally believe can help cure diseases or illnesses. How both cultures define epilepsy is the same which is a dangerous condition but the treatment styles are opposite. The doctors see the potential in prescribing the necessary medications to control Lia’s seizures, whereas they see seizures as the power to perceive things other people cannot see and the only way to treat it is through the ritual of healing spirits. Parents are believed to be responsible for the child’s welfare and for…

    • 354 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down is a book that highlights the struggles between two cultures in healthcare. The lack of understanding and communication lead to a medical tragedy for Hmong child Lia Lee. The story starts with the Lee’s forced immigration to America and talks about Lia being born with epilepsy. As the story unfolds there are many challenges that both cultures face in attempt to provide the best care for Lia. The family has very strong religious and cultural beliefs and the Western medicine only see the biomedicine side of the care Lia needs.…

    • 1576 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This article regarding homeopathy is allotting the readers a description of the theory behind it. By doing this, Bruce Goldfarb is allowing the readers to discover their own opinions involving this medicinal method, while still sharing his own. The debate of whether homeopathy is a valid and legitimate practice has been going on since the 18th century when it was originally founded by Samuel Hahnemann. Hahnemann’s new theory was that “like cures like” and if a small amount of the same disease was fostered, it would alert the body’s instinctive healing powers. Along with that theory, Hahnemann, joined by other homeopaths, believed that the more dilute the prescription was, the stronger the reaction in the body would be.…

    • 654 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many options are available today for people looking for alternatives to traditional methods of healthcare. Most people are not aware of the different approaches to health and healing that can be taken. The term alternative medicine is, “used simply to denote approaches to health and healing that do not rely on drugs, surgery, and/ or other conventional medical procedures for treating illness.” (Goldberg). When becoming involved in alternative medicine, a world of possibilities is introduced.…

    • 1820 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Orang Asli Case Study

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The diversity of culture, tradition, living, beliefs and language is caused by an ethnicity and location which are reflected with living land and nature (Kardooni 2014). In this case, their unique culture was impacted by the used and practice of traditional medical. Past studies was state there are similarities between tribe of Semang, Jahut and Kensiu in traditional medical. Traditional medical of these 3 tribe are associated with the nature and plant. However, different species of plant as a traditional medical illness are practiced among tribes (Samuel et al 2010; Ong et al 2013 & Nur Shahidah Mohammad 2012) .…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays