The Social Reercussions Of Human Rights Enforcement And Economic Development

Great Essays
The study of development is so often focused primarily on the economic sector of growth or lack thereof. In that, while we frequently discuss notions of power, the labour market, and various economic theorists - it is seldom acknowledged how living in these economic conditions affects the citizens on a human rights level. I am of the opinion that human rights enforcement and economic development need to occur hand-in-hand, to avoid instances of international exploitation and rights infringements. In order to best illustrate this point, I will be drawing on two primary theories and concepts, these include; globalization, and dependency theory. In conjunction with one another, we can adequately comprehend the social repercussions of economic …show more content…
However, before we delve deep into philosophical questions on the universality of human rights - let me state that for the purposes of this essay, and as per my own personal beliefs - that human rights are universal. This is not to say that I am ignorant to the cultural sensitiveness of human rights - but rather to state that I view human rights as a fundamental guarantee to all humans, regardless of race, gender, sexuality, disability, culture, religion, etc. In that, “human rights are inherent and inalienable in human beings, simply by the fact of their being human” (UN 2006, 5). However, this does not dismiss the fact that the execution of human rights does demand cultural sensitivity by its very …show more content…
In this theoretical framework, it is understood that ‘core’ countries (ie. developed countries such as Europe) have flourished as a direct result of the destruction of ‘periphery’ countries (ie. Third World countries) (Peet & Hartwick 2009, 166). In other words - much like our current capitalist system - the successful depend on the weakness and destruction of the poor. Andre Gunder Frank, while critically analysing the development theory, understood it to mean that the underdevelopment of periphery countries as a direct result of “loss of surplus expropriated for investment in the center’s development” (Peet & Hartwick 2009, 170). Following that train of thought, the only way to develop then is to emancipate the periphery from the core countries (Ibid). While this seems like a rather impossible goal, especially given today’s capitalist discourses in economics, the human rights violations that occur in periphery states cry for a more autonomous and equal system. In other words, a system that does not specifically favour certain countries at the expense of others. These human rights violations are so often “imposed on a country’s population from above, and those most adversely affected often have little or no input in its implementation” (Goodhart 2013,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    1.1 Mark Lynas’ article “Africa’s Hidden Killers” alludes to many inequalities in the village of Misisi and in the country of Zambia as a whole. Also, in how other more powerful countries see developing countries. The article graphically depicts how the impoverished and malnourished people of Misisi struggle everyday to not only put minimal food on their tables, but how they scavenge to make the equivalent to $0.60 a day all while trying to survive from preventable diseases. Lynas’ article deals with “within-national” inequality, as described by Branko Milanovic. Milanovic explains within-national inequality as individuals in a country personally struggling to thrive as a nation against other more established and wealthier countries.…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When faced with the brutal and tragic reality of poverty around the world, humanitarians are compelled to act and earnestly ask, “What must we do to end global poverty?” Despite the sincerity of many experts, common development practices utilize authoritarian means which trample on the individual rights of the people afflicted by poverty. Easterly calls the reader to debate the merits of these methods against their counter—free development, which holds liberty, rather than economic stability, as the ultimate end. The first facet of the development debate is examining the Blank Slate approach, as opposed to considering and learning from history.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over the course of time, our perception of human rights has changed drastically, considering back in the day these rights were only given to a certain group of people. The main contributor to this is the natural divide between races and their conflicting cultures, where one race believes that their values and beliefs rank superior to another. Even today, prejudice beliefs and media outlets cause us to alter our views and dehumanize others based on both race and culture. Although basic human rights should be given to every person, throughout history the perspectives and lifestyles of certain people have barricaded others from receiving these rights. Mankind has dealt with integrating civil right laws in many civilizations since BCE, but many of those laws in that time period were only granted to the men…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The world faces many injustices on an everyday basis. One of the injustices is the exploitation many individual face on third world countries. Many individuals are being deprived of their human rights to satisfy the needs and demands of wealthy groups. An example would be the high demand for iPhones Nike. Many poor individuals from second and third world countries work under bad conditions and an increased amount of hours to provide to their family.…

    • 399 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Cultural Diversity Macleod

    • 1290 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Summary: Macleod shared the importance of human rights and cultural diversity. He argues that a reasonably comprehensive doctrine of universal human rights can be squared with what is known about the diversity of cultural beliefs and practices. Also, he developed the normatively persuasive arguments for human rights. Relevance to Research Question: Although the article wasn't as much explicit, it was very helpful to me because it provides a clear statement of human rights and cultural diversity. Macleod develops a discussion of cultural diversity in the sphere of human rights to a level that is deeper than that which is allowed for by the usual and verbal opposition between "universalism" and "cultural diversity."…

    • 1290 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Systemic Racism In America

    • 1451 Words
    • 6 Pages

    It took 16 presidents to declare them human beings and set the precedent of human rights that we recognize today. Feagin considers this fact and explains that a country that was conceived with such neglect and lived with it for so long is embedded with this idea into it’s DNA, in this case the institutions and construct of our…

    • 1451 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I believe that human rights are universal rights. Human rights are universal because we are all the same as humans. When it comes to human rights we should be treated equally all around the world. There are some countries and regimes in the world that do not care for others and for their rights as a person. When this happens there needs to be people that come together to stop them.…

    • 2510 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    stablishes the idea that since the 1980’s, a new period of global capitalism has developed on incomplete and exclusionary logic. This growth-centric logic has since evolved into complex and interconnected systems of formations which enable corporate monetary growth at the expense of true socioeconomic inclusivity and betterment. The people who fail to “fit” into this conception of capital growth and challenge its “prosperity” become victims of expulsion, which varies in consequence but is always brutal. This brutality and expulsion can take the form of land grabbing, eviction, incarceration, and environmental destruction. The prevailing ill conceived logic concerning growth also creates a radical detachment between environmental cost and economic…

    • 1665 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Such individuals are often aware of the role of the UN in advocating and demanding that states observe human rights. They rely on the principle of sovereignty to avoid any international intervention. The matter is further complicated by the subjectivity in determining what constitutes human rights violations across different states. According to Donnelly, human rights are “the rights than one has because one is human” . However, the definition does not hold across all societies with some alluding to their religious and cultural beliefs that are superior to the so called human right.…

    • 2040 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The fifteen primary accounts of individuals affected by free market tenets demonstrates evidence of human rights violations, environmental degradation, low wages and unsafe working conditions. The book provides evidence of the role played by multinational corporations and local business interests in facilitating these outcomes. The premise that governments should share some of the responsibility is not entirely accurate because of the nature on the global economic system and the power dynamics between Global South governments on the one hand, and multinational corporations and international economic institutions on the other. The reader is left with the impression that multinational corporations are mostly to blame for the plight of many individuals illustrated in the narratives, especially because of the relatively low bargaining power wielded by governments and the presence of labour oriented civil rights organizations in many developing countries. Although the book does not explicitly offer solutions to the problems identified and discussed, one can infer tentative solutions from the narratives…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This being said under the world systems theory countries take advantage of the citizens within that country in order to gain economically, rather than shame or exploit another country. This theory also goes by a hierarchy method, consisting of “core nations which have high amounts of industrialization and urbanization, semi peripheral nations which are for the most part developed and rely more on providing labor and raw materials to core nations, and peripheral nations which depend on core nations…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Mercy Ship

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (The United Nations, 1948) outlines in article 25.1 that everyone is entitled to sufficient social and civil living standards. This encompasses the rights to food, clothing, shelter, access to healthcare and social security. In many privileged nations, copious amounts of people never give these rights a second thought. Most were born into an abundance of security. Unfortunately, many were not.…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    World Systems Theory Essay

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Building on top of the Marxist ideas of exploitation and unequal exchanges championed by dependency theorists, Wallerstein argues that the semi-periphery is a crucial link in this system of unequal exchanges - the “intermediaries with the periphery, conveyor-belts of surplus value” (Wallerstein 1974: 241). The semi-periphery does not just act the “core” economically to some peripheral regions, they can exert influences politically and culturally through their limited hegemonic powers in the same fashion as core nations, sometimes to their own national agendas sometimes on behalf of core nations. They also serve as examples of economic development that peripheral nations aspire to become, overlooking the difficulties and challenges that accompanies being in such position. In this way, the power structure in the global economic system is obscured by the semi-periphery - it becomes difficult to see the full pictures, determining where economic and political decisions are stemming from and where surplus value is being transferred to (Wallerstein 1979:…

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    PART 1 Human Rights are fundamental legal entitlement. They are rights and benefits granted by law to all human beings despite gender, socioeconomic status, nationality, geographical location, cultural background, language or any other status (Ohchr.org, 2017 ) .They are based upon moral guidelines in order to recognise and respect people's dignity (Human Rights Commission,2017). Human rights support the fact that all persons are entitled to their human rights without discrimination, and are endorsed in the form of treaties, customary international law, general principles and other sources of international law (Ohchr.org, 2017). Trade Unionism and Labour Rights are subcategories of human rights.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Humans share a common factor: we are all humans. However, certain countries believe that, even though biologically we are all the same, some are better than others. This ideology is further supported by traders, travellers, and the media trying to enforce an unequal world. Human rights and equality are fundamental to our society, and the factors that support this should be accepted to a considerable extent. Our ideas of equality and natural rights stem from our uses of trade, travel, and media over the course of history in order to form a consensus of what should and should not be equitable.…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays