The Slums By Jane Jacobs: Movie Analysis

Superior Essays
Every story includes a beginning, middle and end. However, projects have a continuous cycle that most people lack the knowledge to understand. Jane Jacobs discusses the failing method of designing one project and duplicating the same low-income housing to give the project a new beginning. The strategy of rebuilding has not been successful. Eliminating slums or halting the decaying of neighborhoods in cities has not been accomplished. This concept of salvaging continues the failing method in a never ending cycle. However, there are proper steps that can be taken to reverse the process for decay.
The lack of involvement from city planners on the decaying issue has created what is known as “The Slums.” Jacobs’ solutions include development at
…show more content…
White and Black Americans lived in the same complex that formed a positive atmosphere. In the film, many former residents reminisced on the experience of family and community. Valerie Sills, a former resident, says “You were never alone and therefore safe.” Sylvester Brown, another former resident, states “You had an engaging electric life.” Jacquelyn Williams says “Friendships and bonds were formed.” These memories will forever be a time capsule of life. However, there were many negative memories that caused the downfall of …show more content…
The government took responsibility to fund the development and construction of Pruitt-Igoe. The Housing Authority was responsible for maintaining the housing complex. In the beginning, everything was kept in order and in good condition. Over time, tenants were charged more and more for housekeeping and landscape maintenance. The absent of funding was expected to be come from tenants. As a result, many people were not able to live comfortably and provide for their families. The lack of leadership and planning from the Housing Authority only made things worse. Living conditions became horrible, elevators began to break down, and White Americans migrated to the outer city, as a result of the Housing Act of 1949. It quickly became a place of poverty, crime, and lost hope for a better

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In “Black Philly After the Philadelphia Negro” an empirical study by Marcus Anthony Hunter, Hunter mentions that the cause of urban decay in the Seventh Ward, a black neighborhood in Philadelphia, was due to residents pushing for housing reforms. Hunter explains in the text the unbearable living conditions black civilians went through but also what they did about it. In the text it states that the black residents had many issues like “extreme poverty and violence due to the centuries of prejudice” (Hunter).The residents also had sanitary issues because they lacked clean water and space. In addition Hunter talks about, a building where people lived in that was falling apart and as a result, many people decided to do something about it. In…

    • 299 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Holistically, the urban renewal programs have a major impact on the African American community. The author is successful in exploring the various aspects of the issue at hand, and the readers get a clear picture of the entire…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A global trend that seems to impact every country in the world one way or another seems to be urbanization. Worldwide the idea of living in a big booming is becoming more and more popular. Cities mainly appeal to people as social, commercial, and political hubs. Their allure also comes from the unique culture that every city has. Although seeming glamorous, there is a dark side of urban life.…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The three articles provided, “Do Artifacts Have Politics” by Langdon Winner, “The Engineer as Social Radical” by J.C. Mathes and Donald H. Gray, and “Slums and City Planning” by Robert Moses, had several different parts that stood out to me as interesting. Each article had their own main focuses, Winner speaking about how objects and technologies in society having politics, Mathes and Gray about engineers being radicals or conservatives and technologies advancing in our society, and Robert Moses spoke about slums and how he would work towards the removal of slums in New York City. In “Do Artifacts Have Politics” by Langdon Winner first opens up his piece by speaking about how it is controversial to say that objects have political qualities.…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    A Case of Gentrification The reduction of black housing in the inner city of New Orleans is in a staggering position for a city having, record-setting economic growth post Hurricane Katrina. The longtime historically African-American lower to middle class warded off territories of New Orleans’ inner city, whether it may be uptown, downtown or in between are increasingly being overrun by a younger, more affluent race of white upper and middle class investors, eager with thoughts of redevelopment, real estate trends and revitalization. Similarly too what’s being seen in other major cities like New York, where blighted historic neighborhoods are being revitalized at a feverish pitch. An old saying states that, “either you change with the time…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This house project was finances by the Housing Division of the federal Public Works Administration (PWA). Mackley main idea was to offered many different alternative to conventional homes for all the needed poor people around this time. Another of Mackley reason of this project was to get neighbors be more connected to each other by offering recreational settings. For instance, in the book, “Civitas By Design, building better communities from the garden city to the new urbanism” by Howard Gillette, Jr, in chapter 8 says, “the placement of four apartment buildings around open space offered safe areas for play among children as well as gatherings of adults. Balconies and recessed porches in each unit facilitated exchange outside the home, even as a border of trees around the facility directed attention back to other common amenities—a community swimming pool, a cooperative grocery store, an auditorium, even roof space devoted to socializing.”…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gentrification In Detroit

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Gentrifying the city of Detroit is a good thing because the city needs to show improvement, develop into a better place ,and poor population numbers. Although lots of people may say that gentrification is an awful thing for Detroit, they always seem to miss the flaws about Detroit that needs to be handled, but there are bad things that could be horrible for the city of Detroit It is observed that Detroit has had a recent reduction in the population. Resulting to the decrease in population the “Brightmoor” neighborhood in the Detroit district is being gentrified as of a similar situation resorting to loss of population along the rest of the city. To handle the situation, the neighborhood has been gentrified with an astounding outcome.…

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are ways to improve a neighborhood, great jobs, and keep everyone satisfied. Many were proposed in the film (2012) and the government should heed these ideas. Also, the…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Huntington claims that hard-working men and women leading noble and pure lives are just as present in tenement-houses as feeble minded and corrupt people. Jacob A. Riis claims that generations degrade in the slums because of “the influences that prevail there” (Riis “The Problem of the Children” 1892). This environment is not only degrading, but can be the only way of life. “The road to ruin, as we call it, is so fatally easy to them; who shall dare to blame them if they take it?” (Edgar Fawcett “The Woes of the New York Working-Girl” 1891).…

    • 1637 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racism In America Analysis

    • 1002 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In order to understand the significance of buying a house, which is where the institutional racism comes into and the most, we must understand how these people lived. The apartments did not have bathrooms, rather a community bathroom for the entire hall, which was almost always occupied. The complex had rats and roaches and was extremely in need of maintenance attention. The Younger family was in fast need of a change. Walter Lee hated his job, he went on to say, “ A job?…

    • 1002 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    What are the goals of the “orthodox” urban planners (Garden Cities” theorists, Le Corbusier etc.) whom Jacob criticizes? Jane Jacobs throughout Chapter 1 of “The Death and Life of Great American Cities” explains her philosophy regarding urban planning that is centered around using the successes and failures of existing cities as a paradigm for urban planning and design. Jacobs claims that cities “are an immense laboratory of trial and error” in which city planning should be based off of “learning, forming and testing” various urban theories. City planning must therefore take after the failures and successes of different types of urban design and not be rooted from utopian idealism. She often criticizes “orthodox” urban planning theory because they are “guided by principles derived from the behavior and appearance of towns, suburbs, tuberculosis sanatoria, fairs and imaginary dream cities” (9).…

    • 1695 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Instead of pity, they would generate shock, edification, and fear—from those who capitalize on gentrification and gang-inunctions. Above all, these poor community members could make their environment produce for them by ensuring that they are the ones who enjoy the restoration of the community. Opting for analysis instead of storytelling, removes the target from the…

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Moore tries to, however, be realistic and mentions that as any neighborhood, her own had some issues. To back this point up she talks about the “Chatham rapist” who “haunted the neighborhood”. She speaks about the fears her parents had and then transitions to segregation. Afterward, she familiarizes the audience with her experience with segregation. Ms. Moore then talks about misconceptions that exist about the South Side and the differences between the white and black middle class.…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction The author of Evicted, Matthew Desmond, exposes the restrictions those in extreme poverty may face daily. Based in Milwaukee Wisconsin, Desmond takes his readers into the lives of those living in poorly maintained housing where tenants experience health problems, eviction, and at times even death. The property owners are wealthy and thrive off profits made by those less fortunate, yet do minimal maintenance to preserve their rental units. The families residing in the rentals cope with roach infestations, poor plumbing, and broken windows.…

    • 1818 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Milwaukee’s predominately black inner-city neighbourhoods one in 14 renters are evicted every year. Being kicked out of a house into the streets is a very common occurrence for those living in poverty. Eviction is a problem that many are facing in today’s economy that rarely gets evaluated. Matthew Desmond analyzes the problems surrounding eviction in his piece “Eviction and the Reproduction of Urban Poverty”. There are many shocking statistics throughout the piece that provide clear examples of the issues with housing in America.…

    • 1465 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays