Beowulf And Achilles: A Tragic Hero

Improved Essays
"All men naturally seek heroes (Scheske 1)." Until the end of time there will be heroes, they naturally occur whether they are true or false heroes. People look to complete themselves through another person. Humanity wants to be able to look up to someone and aspire to be like them. Everyone has either an idol or a hero that they admire. Long ago a hero had a completely different definition. Heroes used to be great warriors who killed people and creatures and who took territories. A hero would be someone who slayed a king and took over, or someone who saved a damsel in distress. In today 's world the word hero has a wide variety of definitions. Heroes now can be a soldier in a war, a doctor curing a patient, a lawyer getting justice for a crime. …show more content…
Beowulf displayed honor when fighting Grendel, he took off his armor and laid down his sword because he knew Grendel didn 't know what these things were, therefore it would have been unfair. He did this still while knowing Grendel was not honorable at all. Beowulf is shown to be much more superior than Grendel by his act of honor. In the same way, Achilles is also an honorable warrior. He realized he was hurting his people while he was being stubborn. He made an honorable decision to go and avenge his friend, while protecting his people from harm. Agamemnon dishonors Achilles by taking his prize, this enrages Achilles and he then refuses to go to war. Patroclus his best friend, agreed to disguise himself as Achilles to scare everyone into thinking he really is fighting. After this plan goes south, and Patroclus ' identity was revealed, Achilles shows bravery as he storms out onto the battle grounds slaying everyone in his sight, not afraid at all. While Beowulf are both strong honorable leaders, they are also very different from each other in their …show more content…
Beowulf fought three different monsters that were terrorizing his city. Achilles fought lots of other men, not monsters. Beowulf did not believe in fighting other men, only monsters, thus their values are quite different. Beowulf was more heroic than Achilles because he had values like loyalty, pride, and courtesy. Achilles was more of a warrior because he had superhuman strength, he mostly fought for things such as having power, high social position, and getting revenge. Achilles mostly cared about himself and not other people, Beowulf wanted to fight monsters to save all of his people which shows he was very caring and doesn 't seek power or glory. For these reasons, Beowulf is the better hero out of the two of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The previous battle illustrates that the symbol of bravery becomes more emphasized because of the dark depths of the war and that Beowulf did not get distracted with the struggles of the war. Although he was let down by his choices of men, when he was fading away toward death only one man, Wiglaf, was brave enough to assist him. Wiglaf proved his bravery by…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This shows that Hector’s failure determined the fate of Troy. He did fight Achilles, who technically a supernatural creature as man made weapons cannot hurt him. Their battle did result in the death of Hector showing his weakness. Hector made several speeches, like the one to Achilles pleading for mercy. In this speech he used words like arbiters, which shows higher vocabulary.…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Wiglaf was also brave because he took off his armor and helment to defeat the beasts. “ flames flapped the shield, charred it to the boss and the body on the warrior was useless to him” When it came to the last battle Wiglaf armor was useless because Wiglaf would have killed the monster with or without it. Wiglaf actions shows that Wiglaf was pre-paired to win the battle. Wiglaf stands by Beowulf and show his bravery by standing and going with Beowulf to battle against the beasts. Wiglaf was caring because Wiglaf was caring because he told Beowulf that they should hire someone to kill the dragon but Beowulf wanted to protect his kingdom himself When Beowulf was bit by the dragon,…

    • 564 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This scene depicts hector preparing for battle with Achilles. While he is taking off his armor he is then killed while he is unarmed. The imagery of ‘goodly armor’, or armor with lavish décor, is symbolic of wealth and power hiding the corruption of the state that he was fighting for. All along hector had the lust for power and valor, not justice. He was fighting in a war on behalf of his brothers for reasons he initially opposed to, but then was seduced into as soon as they questioned his honor.…

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Maybe he’ll win, maybe I will. The War God doesn’t care which one he kills” (Homer 234). He shows bravery even though he knows that his death is coming. In result of Hectors excessive pride, his death and the loss of his fellow warriors. Agamemnon lives through the war by hiding during battle, but Hector fights till the very end.…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Each of these individuals did some great deed to be remembered as a hero. Achilles being the leader of the Myrmidons and being honored by all men and the gods. During the battle, Achilles abandoned his men on the battlefield as a result of his army being defeated. The death of Achilles’ comrade Patroclus provoked Achilles to come back to the battle to avenge Patroclus’ death. Achilles went on a rage assassinating every Trojan which lead up to the death of Hector.…

    • 2050 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The enemy soldier could have easily killed Arthur at that moment but since Arthur showed pity towards the knight and respect, the enemy knight knighted Arthur. By doing so, Arthur gained honor from fellow knights, and respect from that particular enemy soldier. Sometimes, after a battle is over, there could be prisoners. Most times, the knights who were victorious show pity and release the prisoners and in doing so earned the respect from the enemy. Knights would do this because killing an…

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Though he may be selfless in fighting for the Trojans, he is vengeful and disrespectful. Since Achilles’ selfishly decided to stop fighting for the Achaeans, his best friend Patroclus took his place. In Book Sixteen Achilles permits Patrolcus to wear his armor during battle because it would help raise morale, but it also made him a target. Hector kills Patroclus, believing him to be Achilles, and then steals his armor to get revenge on him for killing his wife’s family. This deed characterizes Hector as vengeful, because he is unable to forgive Achilles for wronging him and instead he steals his armor.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Theme Of Revenge In Iliad

    • 1466 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The vengeance and justice in this poem are different from the modern ones, as they are fictional and they depend on the will of the gods and kings, who are similar to ordinary people with their own sins, desires, ambitions, envy, and lust. There is not anything that could bring joy to the gods or people apart from the sufferings of one another. First of all, it is necessary to understand the major force that is respected by men in the poem – strength and power. The physical strength makes a great warrior who could conquer the countries, kill foreigners and protect the country from intruders. Achilles is one of the most famous warriors in the poem and he is believed to be invincible.…

    • 1466 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Beowulf displays actions of selflessness through out the poem. His first action was by coming over to Heorot and defeating Grendel. After peace is achieved he walks into certain death to stop the terror of the Dragon that has been destroying his kingdom. Instead of having his men join him in battle he sends them off so that he may fight the Dragon alone and not risk other’s lives. After the Dragon is defeated he asks that all the spoils go to all those in the kingdom so that could prosper.…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays