The Shortcomings Of The Uniform Crime Reports

Improved Essays
While the Uniform Crime Reports were ground breaking for tracking crime data nationally, there were many flaws with the system. The Federal Bureau of Investigation would send out paper reports for the local agency to fill out and return. This system leaves a lot of room for human bias, as well as honest mistakes, when reporting crimes. These reasons alone are enough to question whether the reports were an accurate account of crime in the country. Uniform Crime reports also had several other shortcomings that lead researchers to question their validity. The single most important shortcoming of the Uniform Crime Reports is the hierarchy rule. When there is more than on crime committed by one person at one time the Uniform Crime Reports used …show more content…
According to Inciadri, even though the Federal Bureau of Investigation attempted to set clear definitions of the crimes they collected data on many agencies did not use these definitions to compile their data which leads to inaccurate reporting (1978). Since not all agencies were required to report information to the Bureau information would have to be estimated, or be incomplete (Inciadri 1978). Lastly, in some cases Inciadri found that the information reported for the Uniform Crime Reports were not consistent with what that agency had in their own files and reporting system (1978). These were just a few reasons that Uniform Crime Reports needed to be reviewed and updated to ensure the most accurate data was …show more content…
Department of Justice, 2000). The study determined that many of the short comings of the current system needed to be addressed due to the changes in crime and technology (U.S. Department of Justice, 2000). From the results of that study a new crime data reporting system was created called the National Incident-Based Reporting System. According to the U.S. Department of Justice,
In order to ensure that it fulfills its purpose, NIBRS has adopted the following goals:
1. To enhance the quantity, quality, and timeliness of crime statistical data collected by the law enforcement community.
2. To improve the methodology used for compiling, analyzing, auditing, and publishing the collected crime data (U.S. Department of Justice, 2000,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Weaknesses of Uniform Crime Reports are that it does not include crimes not reported to the police, which as stated before make up a large amount of the crime committed. UCR’s also do not include drug usage and typically has reporting errors made by the officers during arrest. The NIBRS also does not include crimes not reported to the police and is very hard to report anything using this system. Because of the difficulty, people do not want to use this method of obtaining data. The NIBRS also reports on multiple offenses which makes it looks like crime had increased.…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Another high-risk area of police work in terms of a potential for corruption is the use of informants. Police officers who handle informants are exposed to offenders far more frequently and in a less controlled environment. While guidelines that advise on the way that informers should be manages might be issued, however the concerned procedures do not address the ethical dilemmas that can arise. Sometimes, individuals may also be tempted to engage in corrupt behavior indirectly through the knowledge that such behavior is often difficult to investigate and detect. Further, where investigations are successful in uncovering incidents of corruption, there are still further problems in providing and punishing such behavior (Porter,…

    • 905 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the field of criminology law, an important aspect involves the validation and actualization of the actual causes of crime. The fact that criminal activities continue to persist our society means that understanding the real cause of crimes will remain to be complex (Bursik, 2008). However, various law criminologists have postulated various theories that attempt to explain the different causes of crime in our society. The theoretical understanding of the causes of crime helps in the demystification of criminal behavior in our community, hence, forming a proper background upon which the existing structural policies set aside to prevent criminal activities can be evaluated. According to Akers (2013), a theory refers to an educated…

    • 1521 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is important as at times, even if they do acknowledge the occurrence of a crime, because they cannot keep up with the demand of paperwork and/or workload pressures they will not fill out a report. Aside from the pressures of work, unfortunately they are just some crimes that the police do not take seriously enough although members of the community may see it as a serious crime. One example are hate crimes and racially motivated crimes. The police are not as diligent with documenting them. Another factor that influences the crime statistics is when numerous crimes are committed and only the most serious offence or the top four offences are reported.…

    • 1268 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Also, the media takes a toll on the situations and make them out to be more than what they really were. Nobody can really believe anything they hear because no one knows exact what happened unless they were there. Not only do people believe that police brutality is exaggerated, but some feel as if there’s nothing they can do about it so why care. “On a national level, upwards of 95 percent of police misconduct cases referred for federal prosecution are declined by prosecutors because, as reported in USA Today, juries "are conditioned to believe cops, and victims ' credibility is often challenged” (Rowe). This shows that the system doesn’t actually take the time to investigate that matters of what happens during cases of police brutality, so why should anyone else?…

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Q.1. 1 [250 words] Name three major problems with the concept of crime as criminal behaviour. “Criminal behaviour is defined by the laws of particular jurisdictions, and there are sometimes vast differences between and even within countries regarding what types of behaviour are prohibited”. (Edge, 2016). One of the key problems is that throughout the world many countries consider some criminal acts to be more serious than others for example marijuana is an illegal drug in Ireland but is legal in Alaska.…

    • 1622 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The NCVS gives victims a way to report crime in general. The NCVS was mainly brought about the measure difficult crimes in rape, sexual-assault, and domestic violence (Dodge and Rennison 2015). Crimes that involved rape, or any type of violence are always harder for victims to talk about and report. The survey provides people the ability to report dragic falls on their life. An advantage of the NCVS involves more protection of the victim from an armed offender especially with assualts (Dodge and Rennison 2015).…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In conclusion, there are two major sources of crime statistics UCR/NIBRS and NCVS. UCR/NIBRS uses police reports and NCVS uses the self-reporting from victims. This enables a full spectrum of statistics from both reported incidents and incidents that people are afraid to report. Both programs have evolved over time with tremendous changes. Training is a big key to both programs.…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Problem oriented policing Problem oriented is a policing strategy that was developed by Herman Goldstein. Unlike other policing strategies, problem oriented policing advocates for the application of assessment and analysis in addressing crime and disorder problems in order to come up with effective response strategies. Compared with other policing strategies, problem oriented policing presents law enforcers with a multilayered approach to addressing crimes and averting others before they take place (Boba & Santos, 2011). Moreover, the strategy also involves subjecting distinct pieces of policing work to microscopic analysis with the expectation that what is newly learnt about each problem will help in developing a new and effective way of…

    • 1527 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Offenders may move to other jurisdictions, other offenses that are difficult to detect or offenses that have a low reporting rate. Crime displacement and diffusion of benefit have measuring problems. Lack of data means there still exists a gap in research that needs to be filled. Crime displacement in relation to predictive policing needs to be researched to conclusively determine how predictive policing relates to crime displacement.…

    • 1481 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays