He expects them to be angry and make him leave the pulpit when they hear his veiled confession, but instead “they heard it all, and did but reverence him the more” (Hawthorne 107). Dimmesdale reminds himself of his seemingly unforgivable sin when he sees the meteor. This meteor comes when Dimmesdale is on the scaffold, when he is showing his secretive, sinful side instead of the perfect Puritan side he usually shows the community. The scaffold is the place where he punishes himself for his sin, so it is fitting that he sees the meteor when he is on the scaffold. The community’s ability to judge people for their goodness and sin is ambiguous—like the meteor—meaning that the community has “the incapacity to know anything for certain” (“Scarlet Letter” 313). He interprets this meteor’s shape as a symbol of his impurity. The community, however, interprets the meteor to mean that their deceased governor is now in heaven. He may have been impure, but kept it hidden, like Dimmesdale. These differing interpretations of the meteor support the theme that a community cannot define goodness and sin in an individual, because of the privacy and secrecy in everyone’s
He expects them to be angry and make him leave the pulpit when they hear his veiled confession, but instead “they heard it all, and did but reverence him the more” (Hawthorne 107). Dimmesdale reminds himself of his seemingly unforgivable sin when he sees the meteor. This meteor comes when Dimmesdale is on the scaffold, when he is showing his secretive, sinful side instead of the perfect Puritan side he usually shows the community. The scaffold is the place where he punishes himself for his sin, so it is fitting that he sees the meteor when he is on the scaffold. The community’s ability to judge people for their goodness and sin is ambiguous—like the meteor—meaning that the community has “the incapacity to know anything for certain” (“Scarlet Letter” 313). He interprets this meteor’s shape as a symbol of his impurity. The community, however, interprets the meteor to mean that their deceased governor is now in heaven. He may have been impure, but kept it hidden, like Dimmesdale. These differing interpretations of the meteor support the theme that a community cannot define goodness and sin in an individual, because of the privacy and secrecy in everyone’s