Primordialism In Kenneth Waltz's Man State And War

Improved Essays
In Kenneth Waltz’s Man State and War, he argues that “states are motivated to attack each other and to defend themselves by the reason and/or passion of the comparatively few.” Although most focus on the power of these small groups or the logical reasoning, much less attention is paid to the “passion,” where it becomes easy to see how nationalistic sentiments could become influential. John Mearsheimer has paid a great deal of attention to the role of nationalism in state interactions, arguing that the current nation-state system would not exist without nationalism. Although he admits that it is not typically seen a crucial element of realist theory, Mearsheimer agrees that it is a “powerful force” in international relations.
James Mayall connected
…show more content…
This was the first approach to the study of nations and nationalism, yet it persists today. Within the approach there are several sub-divisions, debating between whether nationalism occurs because of a proven historical fact or rather a long-standing sense of solidarity. Under the first category, Clifford Geertz argued that nationalism arises from an instinctive cultural attachment. Meanwhile, Pierre Van Den Berghe contends that this attachment was socio-biological, maintained through common descent and horizontal marriage ties. The primordialist approach sees nationalism as continuous and immortal. This is greatly portrayed through the work of Adrian Hastings, who argues for the medieval origin of nationalism in Europe. This approach to the study of nationalism has been routinely criticized, particularly because it takes an emotion rather than rational approach. Scholars have routinely proven the facts of primordialism as either false or only half truths. For example, Patrick Geary, a medieval historian, proved that the ties Hastings wrote about did not actually exist because of constant changes to cultural and political …show more content…
Unlike many prominent scholars of nationalism, Anderson’s major geographical focus of study was not Europe, but Southeast Asia, although his seminal work Imagined Communities addresses all parts of the world. This fundamentally forms how he thought of nationalism, leading him to develop theories that are aligned with the post-colonial world. Anderson’s work focuses on the importance of communication, language, and the media to nationalism, particularly through his term “print capitalism,” which he argued led to the creation of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Nationalism is a shared feeling between a group of a geographical and demographic region seeking independence for its culture or ethnicity. Nationalism can be expressed as a belief or a political ideology that involves an individual becoming attached to one’s nation. The interest of a nation as a whole held to be an independent entity separate from the interests of subordinate areas or groups and also of other nations or supranational groups. An extent of nationalism can only be pursued by nations or countries when the effects of their nationalism does not harm any other nation or country; if that point is reached, or conducting a systematic way of reaching that point, it is called ultranationalism, an extreme form of nationalism. The source…

    • 2156 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nationalism, it is a major part of our lives, a shared sense of belonging of people who identify themselves as a nation, In the three sources the authors convey their perspective of Nationalism and the causes of it in history. Although it gives people a national pride in which they overcome their differences and become as one. It also causes competition between countries for land, resources, and power, which eventually results in major wars and ethnic cleansing. The first source written by Erich Fromm, negatively describes how devotion to one’s nation is perhaps more important than humanity itself, and how people are blindly devoted to nationalism, “Love for one’s country which is not part of one’s love for humanity is not love, but idolatrous” an example of this can be perceived from sport competitions like Real Madrid and Barcelona’s rivalry, fans blindly comprehend it without…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Comanche Empire

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The essay David wrote is about the construction of nationalism in the revolutionary war. In Waldstreicher’s view, nationalism was not the creation racial or ethnic identity, but a collective identification that was combined from the public celebrations of the late 18th centuries. If you view the history of nationalism, it was the creation of rituals, order, identity and social tensions. David writes that America was divided along the lines of class, gender, race, and region. Everyone was wondering how was anyone able to control the social and economic contentions of the common people.…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Causes Of World War I

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages

    World War I, also know as 'The Great War ' was one of the bloodiest times in the worlds history. This is not only becuase it was battle between so many world powers but also becuase of the military style at the time. Many died in battle as a result of faulty strategies and even more died as a result of ignorance to innocence. Many civilians died in the destruction of cities and the imperilistic ideas of the time. This like most other wars were fought because of greed and pride, and the U.S. even tried to stay out of it to protect its interests.…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    World War 1 Dbq Analysis

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages

    World War I is renowned and historically relevant due to the many stipulations of its beginning. While the initiation of its ‘successor’, World War II can be pinpointed to a single group, the instigation of World War I is surrounded with varying opinions and perspectives. Certain individuals may argue that militarism was the culprit, or that alliances provided the spark needed to ablaze warfare on a global scale. Despite this, many historians bring forth the rise of nationalism as the leading instigator of war. Nationalistic pride can be seen as a primary motivator in the development of secondary causes of war such as the formation of alliances, imperialism and militarism.…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As late as 1870, only 10% of Africa was under European control, but this changed when King Leopold came in and the “Scramble for Africa” started. The European nations realized that Africa was filled with incredible natural resources and this created competition between the European powers. The European nations divided up Africa by claim at the Berlin Conference. The nations then went on to imperialize their parts of Africa and it would not have been possible for them without the inventions that proved to be very useful. The inventions such as the first machine gun and the treatment for malaria are what gave the Europeans an advantage.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This extreme form of nationalism can be beneficial to the nation’s welfare, ironically it can also lead to ultranationalistic actions that put the welfare of other nations at risk. Often causing conflicts and interferences with co-operation between nations, ultranationalism pressures the people of the nation to take extreme measures to accomplish their own goals. Either that or as Davison puts it, “Ultranationalist groups often perceive threats to their existence and argue that they must engage in preventive measures, such as ethnic cleansing or deportation, to counter these dangers.” Certain policies of the ultranationalistic country can intentively discriminate and degrade other nations deemed inferior. With instances like the American Civil War creating a wake for future discriminatory feelings within America and Italian fascist leader Mussolini’s policy of irredentism, it is evident that nationalistic feelings can cause strife between other nations because of the extreme patriotic feelings of a group of people who share the same perspectives.…

    • 1900 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The pursuit of national interest is always in the formula for the calculations of the rational decisions made by a nation. National interest is something each nation is thinking about when they go into war. World War I was the sacrifice of millions of lives to fulfill each nation’s national interest. William Kirby argues that, countries enter war because of their “rational calculations and national interests”. The source points out how the purpose of war is not irrational, it is rationalized by the beliefs of a nation and the benefits of military conflict.…

    • 1470 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Yet, this document does show the development of the idea of nationalism throughout the decades and gives a different view on…

    • 2104 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nationalism can also leads to conflict with others, infringes on rights of others, creates xenophobia—the fear that someone will take them over. There are several examples of countries that affected by nationalism negatively and one of those countries is Austria-Hungary this country got separated because of nationalism (Doc 2). Other example of the negative side of nationalism is in Palestine because there country got suppurated they want nothing to do with each other. “Live wherever you like, but do not live among us It is time for you to be gone Die wherever you like, but do not die among us For we have work to do in our land We have the past here We have the first cry of life We have the present, the present and the future We have this world here, and the hereafter So leave our country Our land, our sea Our wheat, our salt, our wounds Everything, and leave The memories of memory O those who pass between fleeting words!” (Doc 3).…

    • 666 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sydney J. Harris Analysis

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In societies perspective, patriotism and nationalism represent contrasting values depending on the individual being asked. Although, in my personal opinion nationalism and patriotism are two very similar matters that can drive into two paths; a negative or positive direction. Furthermore, Sydney J. Harris reflects that statement as he establishes an idea of what patriotism and nationalism distinctly represent in his opinionated claim. Sydney J. Harris’s source supports the negative outlook on nationalism and positive viewpoint on patriotism. In addition, the Sydney J. Harris demonstrates this through specific words choices, firm tone of the source and accentuating the clear gap between nationalism and patriotism.…

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We as humans tend to group together in order to better survive. The notion of community and society has always been imbedded into the way we live, whether it be the smaller communities we are part of or the larger nations we assimilate with. Just as we look for similarities our own groups, a nation and its people look for the same. Benedict Anderson’s theory of nationalism takes a step outside of the classic political frame and focuses more on the social aspects of how a nation becomes nationalized. It is no wonder that Anderson’s idea of the “Imagined [Community]” is applicable to a country the same size and far more densely populated than the United States.…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People must learn to recognize extreme nationalism in society before the national problem becomes a global war. This isn’t easy to do, as over the course of history nationalism has brought the world to its very lowest points in shambles before it’s even recognized as a minor issue. In centuries past, nationalism that is taken so far as to being used to destroy outsiders and condemn other groups of people has proven to be deadly and disastrous. (7) Nationalism has displayed various instances of being both positive and negative factors within multiple nations. For example, it has both endorsed nations to create new and fair government systems in revolutionary France, but it has also brought nations to their knees in times of war and crisis, killing millions of minorities in World War II.…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    it states, “The confusion of the idea of the nation with the practice and power of the nation-state makes nationalism one of the most powerful forces in contemporary society”(5). Although there is nothing wrong with one being proud of their nation the concept of heavy nation pride can lead to many issues. It can lead to people valuing their over the individual identities of people, it can lead to harsh generalizations, and as seen in Manto’s stories, Identity issues, and pointless war. Ashcroft also stated, “This myth of nationhood, masked by ideology, perpetuates nationalism, in which specific identifiers are employed to create exclusive and homogeneous conceptions of national traditions”(4). This speaks on the characteristic of nationalism and how it often creates harsh stereotypes of the people in various countries and…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Purpose Of Nationalism

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Nationalism itself could be defined as a sense of belonging, of people who identify and create a sense of understanding due to the common culture and characteristics among themselves, hence be called as a nation. “It is an ideological movement for the attainment and maintenance of autonomy, unity, and identity on behalf of a population deemed by some of its members to constitute an actual or potential ‘nation’” (Tarling 2004, p. 15). The core of nationalism is nation hence it projects an individual’s attachment to the nation. Originally, major causes such as religion along with cultural and political identity led to a nationalistic movement in Asia which united the people to go against the western powers.…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics