Granted my opponents such as Kant believe that lying is never acceptable even in a life or death situation (article 2 paragraph 2), yet can be helpful in a life or death situation. In the justification chart it states, “jason lies to protect his dad from having a heart attack by lying and not saying his mother has cancer (justification chart #5). This means that jason only lied for the sake of his dad not having a heart attack so he only lied to save his dad. For instance, if jason would of lied, his dad would of had a heart attack and died so he only lied to protect his father. In addition blanton states, “we shouldn't manipulate the truth except for rare times- if you're hiding anne frank in your attic because her life is in danger.” (article 3 line 11). This means that one should lie when it's necessary like in a life or death situation because it's protecting others. From this one can infer that its ok to lie when it's a life or death situation. In conclusion lying i sometimes ok but it should only be used in necessary
Granted my opponents such as Kant believe that lying is never acceptable even in a life or death situation (article 2 paragraph 2), yet can be helpful in a life or death situation. In the justification chart it states, “jason lies to protect his dad from having a heart attack by lying and not saying his mother has cancer (justification chart #5). This means that jason only lied for the sake of his dad not having a heart attack so he only lied to save his dad. For instance, if jason would of lied, his dad would of had a heart attack and died so he only lied to protect his father. In addition blanton states, “we shouldn't manipulate the truth except for rare times- if you're hiding anne frank in your attic because her life is in danger.” (article 3 line 11). This means that one should lie when it's necessary like in a life or death situation because it's protecting others. From this one can infer that its ok to lie when it's a life or death situation. In conclusion lying i sometimes ok but it should only be used in necessary