Relationship of Holmes and Watson The relationship between Sherlock Holmes and Dr. John Watson has intrigued many hearts for years. This long-lasting friendship began with A Study in Scarlet in 1887 and has been retold and reshaped by new generations that came after. Holmes’ and Watson’s relationship started as a true friendship that grew one another and was made to modern day Something to consider when thinking of Holmes’ and Watson’s relationship is the adaptation of the original texts this is because as time progressed and people like Doyle decided to retell the story of Sherlock Holmes they used the adaptation theory. The adaptation theory is used to study original text or films. Thomas Leitch says that the adaptation theory is, “one
…show more content…
Both creators agree that their goal was to write what they call a “Modern Sherlock” to express their love for Sherlock Holmes Canon. Moffat and Gatiss knew in order to bring it to the screen they had to incorporate the friendship between Holmes and Watson. When he was reflecting on the show’s success Moffat said, “We thought it would be like an audience of four million and an obscure award at a Polish festival or something like that. It happened so completely suddenly. We barely finished the show and it’s this enormous hit. There seemed to be no intervening moment of escalation.” (Moffat, Interview, transcription mine). Many would say that the success of Sherlock is due to the the relationship of Holmes and Watson it has mad the storyline all the more interesting. Watson was a man that struggled with his past in Afghanistan. Watson has no job and little money. Anna Neil in “ The Savage Genius of Sherlock Holmes” says that when Watson first meet Holmes, “… he begins to recover respectability and civility.” and “… becomes healthier in the mind as well as body…” (Neil). This shows exactly how well Holmes is for Watson. However, Watson also does Holmes some good. He is able to show us just how great Holmes by being so ordinary (Shmoop Editorial Team). And just like Watson, Holmes has a few issues of his …show more content…
Being a sociopath or even a psychopath means that one has no feelings towards others. Therefore, Holmes’ relationship with Watson knocks out the idea of him being a psychopath or sociopath. However, whether he is Holmes is Aspergic or not is still a curiosity. Aspergic symptoms include attachment to particular routines, apparent lack of empathy, lack of social understanding, formal style of speaking, narrow range of obsessive interests (“A Psychological…”). These symptoms actually characterize Holmes. Therefore, it is very possible that Holmes is a victim of Aspergic. Sherlock Holmes is known for being anti-social. The only time Holmes appears to be social with other is to solve a case. Outside of that Holmes’ only social outlet is Watson. Holmes could not even connect more with someone that is more like himself than Watson. One would think that Jim Moriarty would be a more compatible match for Holmes since they posse a few of the same traits. Moriarty matches homes in terms of they both have a genius like mind set however, they use them in different ways. His trust for Watson speaks a lot about them both. It shows that Holmes is not a very trusting person. It also shows that Watson is a very trustworthy person this is because in order for a not so trusting person to trust someone they must first
Both creators agree that their goal was to write what they call a “Modern Sherlock” to express their love for Sherlock Holmes Canon. Moffat and Gatiss knew in order to bring it to the screen they had to incorporate the friendship between Holmes and Watson. When he was reflecting on the show’s success Moffat said, “We thought it would be like an audience of four million and an obscure award at a Polish festival or something like that. It happened so completely suddenly. We barely finished the show and it’s this enormous hit. There seemed to be no intervening moment of escalation.” (Moffat, Interview, transcription mine). Many would say that the success of Sherlock is due to the the relationship of Holmes and Watson it has mad the storyline all the more interesting. Watson was a man that struggled with his past in Afghanistan. Watson has no job and little money. Anna Neil in “ The Savage Genius of Sherlock Holmes” says that when Watson first meet Holmes, “… he begins to recover respectability and civility.” and “… becomes healthier in the mind as well as body…” (Neil). This shows exactly how well Holmes is for Watson. However, Watson also does Holmes some good. He is able to show us just how great Holmes by being so ordinary (Shmoop Editorial Team). And just like Watson, Holmes has a few issues of his …show more content…
Being a sociopath or even a psychopath means that one has no feelings towards others. Therefore, Holmes’ relationship with Watson knocks out the idea of him being a psychopath or sociopath. However, whether he is Holmes is Aspergic or not is still a curiosity. Aspergic symptoms include attachment to particular routines, apparent lack of empathy, lack of social understanding, formal style of speaking, narrow range of obsessive interests (“A Psychological…”). These symptoms actually characterize Holmes. Therefore, it is very possible that Holmes is a victim of Aspergic. Sherlock Holmes is known for being anti-social. The only time Holmes appears to be social with other is to solve a case. Outside of that Holmes’ only social outlet is Watson. Holmes could not even connect more with someone that is more like himself than Watson. One would think that Jim Moriarty would be a more compatible match for Holmes since they posse a few of the same traits. Moriarty matches homes in terms of they both have a genius like mind set however, they use them in different ways. His trust for Watson speaks a lot about them both. It shows that Holmes is not a very trusting person. It also shows that Watson is a very trustworthy person this is because in order for a not so trusting person to trust someone they must first